We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
Whether you want to break into anal play or are looking for new ways to spice up backdoor play with your partner, a cat tail butt plug hanging out of your tush is sure to do the trick. But which of the many products and brands should I buy?
After testing dozens of products, the DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur stands out for being the best cat tail butt plug with its highest quality cruelty-free option, and for being the perfect blend of sleek and sexy while also adding a touch of playfulness that you and your partner are sure to appreciate.
Test Winner: DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur
DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur got the highest rating in our review. Our testers loved how size-wise it pushes the boundaries of being beginner-friendly while looking sexy. It’s also easy to insert and hold onto once it’s fully inside. Discount code AFF-MSTG10 for 10% off!
Metal: DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium
The first thing I noticed after unboxing was the velvet box it arrived in and just how heavy the plug felt inside it. Size and shape-wise, I think this plug is just right, and despite its relatively moderate size had no issues getting it settled in between my cheeks!
Cat Ears: Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug
If you want to take your pet play to the next level, this Tailz set is for you. This spade-shaped plug is wide enough to offer a pleasant challenge during insertion, with a wide stem that creates a great sense of presence despite being made of lightweight silicone.
Table Of Contents
Why You Should Trust Us
Having been with us since the inception of My Sex Toy Guide in 2016, Rachel Sommer, Ph.D., brings a wealth of expertise and experience to the table. Her years spent as a clinical sexologist combined with her personal experience with 300+ products make her a trustworthy source of information regarding sexual health and safe sex toy use.
Rachel goes the extra mile to gather information from reputable sources, including manufacturers, industry experts, and user feedback to find the absolute best cat tail butt plugs. This meticulous research allows her to present a comprehensive overview of each sex toy, covering aspects such as quality, performance, durability, and user experiences.
How We Picked The Products
After conducting dozens of product reviews, I like to think that I have them down to a science.
Through trial and error, I have figured out the optimal techniques for ensuring that only the highest-rated make it through the review process, and one of them is to enlist the help of a diverse test panel, including men and women of all shapes and sizes.
After compiling my group of test panel members, I distributed 15 of the top-rated products from some of my favorite sex toy distributors, like Foxyplug, Shevibe, and Lovehoney. From there, we all spent time with each plug and rated our user experience based on the following test criteria that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100:
- Plug material: I won’t lie, I’m a sucker for glass and stainless steel plugs, as they’re both easier to clean and heavier, which makes holding a weighty tail in place all the easier (more on glass butt plugs in this article). Of course, we also had to include our top silicone plugs for folks who prefer a lighter model.
- Tail material: We were on the hunt for tails that not only looked beautiful but were also strong enough to resist the hands of time and wouldn’t lose tufts of fur during play.
- Detachability: Though not a must, detachability not only adds to the versatility of your toy but also makes post-play cleanup a heck of a lot easier!
- Plug design: Long and bulbous-shaped models are the preferred style of tail toys, as they’re easier to hold in place via a slight clenching of the tush. I also prioritized review samples with easy insert-ability and a range of sizes, from beginner-friendly to those suited for experienced anal enthusiasts.
- Sensation: As if the gentle swishing sensation of your tail against the back of your legs wasn’t enough, we also included more than one vibrating/vibrator-compatible option.
- Price: When choosing test samples for this review, I made sure to find a nice balance between quality and affordability.
- Quality: There are few experiences worse than ordering a sex toy only for it to arrive half-broken in the box or look completely different than the advertised photos. After testing each review sample first-hand, I can guarantee they’re all worthy of a place in your booty.
During testing, we rated each test criterion on a percentage scale from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). We then calculated the overall score using different weighted metrics depending on the importance of the test criteria. Half the total rating comes from Plug Design (25%) and Quality (25%). After that comes Sensation (10%), Material (10%), and Price (5%).
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| | |
|
| Name | Glass Faux | Stainless Steel | Silicone Anal Plug |
| Category | Best Overall | Metal | Cat Ears |
| Average Rating | 97% | 95% | 94% |
| Plug Material | 98% | 92% | 95% |
| Tail Material | 97% | 93% | 91% |
| Detachability: | 95% | 93% | 96% |
| Plug Design | 97% | 92% | 93% |
| Sensation | 94% | 95% | 93% |
| Price & Value | 96% | 94% | 95% |
| Price Tag | $39.99 | $39.99 | $59.99 |
| Material | Glass & Faux fur | Steel & Faux fur | Leather, Silicone, Metal, & Polyester |
| Circumference | 4.5 inches | 3.75 inches | 4.4 inches |
| Insertable Length | 4 inches | 2.75 inches | 4 inches |
1. DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur: Overall Test Winner!
Why we love DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur:
The DOMINIX Deluxe Glass sits right on the edge of being novice and intermediate-friendly, with a weighty glass body that adds an undeniable sense of presence that you’ll grow to love.
Though size-wise it pushes the boundaries of being beginner-friendly, with enough lube and patience, I’m confident that even total anal newbies won’t have any trouble rocking this playful plug. The shape is also a perfect combination of being easy to insert and hold onto once it’s fully inside your tush.
Any fears that our less experienced panel members had concerning the size and weight were very short-lived, with some of them dubbing it the most comfortable plug they’ve ever used!
As is the case with all glass products, the black cat tail butt plug is very easy on the eyes, with a sleekness that makes you excited to slide it into your tush. The fluffy kitty tail, on the other hand, has a playful look, offering a contrast that made the transformation into an adorable sex kitten all the easier.
Lovers of temperature play will also be happy to hear that borosilicate glass can also be both heated and cooled to titillate the senses. And unlike silicone, glass doesn’t hold onto smell and is (in my opinion) much easier to clean thoroughly.
Minor issues found during testing:
Although I do dub this a beginner-friendly plug, it’s right on the edge of being too large for anal newbies, especially when you factor in the weight of the glass – which can be intimidating for first-timers. Instead, find a more suitable device for your experience in our best butt plug roundup.
If you’re ready for a bit of a challenge, I can still recommend picking up this baby. Otherwise, it’s a perfect option as a size-up for folks with more experience.
Why DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur is the highest-rated cat tail butt plug:
When compared to the competition, the DOMINIX Deluxe was the clear winner, easily earning itself the highest rating of 97% from our test panel members, based on the following criteria:
- Plug design: What can I say, I’m a sucker for glass! I loved both the added weight of the glass as compared to silicone and also appreciated the longer and thinner body and how easy it made holding it post-insertion.
- Tail material: It’s not easy finding a cat butt plug with a tail that can deliver on fluffiness without losing too much fur during use, but the DOMINIX Deluxe delivers on both angles. Overall, it performed better than the competition in this critical category.
Features:
- Material: Glass and faux fur
- Total Length: 21”
- Insertable Length: 4”
- Circumference: 4.5”
Pros:
- Budget-friendly option ($39.99)
- A weighty glass plug is more filling than a silicone
- Super easy to clean and doesn’t hold onto the smell
- The tail is exceptionally fluffy and doesn’t shed
- The perfect option for a size-up
- Comes with a gorgeous velvet storage bag
- DOMINIX Deluxe Glass can be used with all lube types
Cons:
- May be slightly too big for beginners
- Glass is noticeably heavier than silicone which can put some people off
2. DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium: Metal Cat Tail Butt Plug
Why we love DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium:
If metal is more your style, then the DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel could be just for you! This weighty plug is also ideal for temperature play and offers a little extra bushyness when compared to our previous pick.
The first thing I noticed after unboxing was the velvet box and just how heavy the plug felt inside it. Size and shape-wise, I think this one is just right, and despite its relatively moderate size had no issues getting it settled in between my cheeks!
Something about this place just calls to be tugged on, and I loved that it could withstand rough play with little to no shedding. Despite being detachable, there’s no need to worry about accidentally pulling the anal toy apart during play thanks to it being screwed on instead of magnetic.
The combination of the weighted plug and silky fur rubbing against your legs makes this plug easy to fall in love with. And that’s to its cleanability and high-quality build, you won’t have to stop using it any time soon!
Minor issues found during testing:
In order to hold its bushier shape, the DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel requires a tad more rigidity, which makes it noticeably less “swishier” than other lengthier picks.
Why DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium is the best metal cat tail butt plug:
It’s easy to fall in love with the DOMINIX Deluxe. The bushy tail sets it apart from the competition, earning an average rating of 95% from our panel members.
- Plug design: My panel members and I all agreed that the use of metal for DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel made it feel more sturdy and high-quality. The extra-long stem also made it easy to wear for extended play.
- Detachability: Detachable cat tails really are the gold standard! They make cleaning your plug and maintaining your tail far simpler.
Features:
- Material: Stainless steel and faux fur
- Insertable Length: 2.75”
- Circumference: 3.75”
- Weight: 6.07 oz
Pros:
- A detachable tail makes cleanup a breeze
- Budget-friendly ($39.99)
- The tail is extra bushy and doesn’t shed
- The weighty metal butt plug feels great in
- Comes with a velvet storage box
- Can be used with all lube types
Cons:
- Not as “swishy” as other options
- The weight and rigidity of metal butt plugs aren’t for everyone
3. Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug: Cat Ears With Tail!
Why we love Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug:
If you have some experience with anal plugs and are ready to take your tail play to the next level, this Tailz set has everything you need.
This spade-shaped plug is wide enough to offer a pleasant challenge during insertion, with a wide stem that creates a great sense of presence despite being made of lightweight silicone.
Both the size and shape work in its favor, as they help to counterbalance the weight of the somewhat rigid internal wiring that’s completely malleable and allows for your transformation into a perky kitten with an upright tail.
Near the base, you’ll also find two loops that can be equipped with bullet vibrators, adding an extra dose of sensation for folks who prefer a gentle buzzing during anal play.
Minor issues found during testing:
The thing that gives this cat tail its malleability is thin wiring – similar to that which you might find on an adjustable tripod, located in its core. Though it does the job well, the metal does make the cat’s tail a tad bit heavier.
Why Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug is the most recommended combo:
In terms of quality and features, no other cat tail sets could compete with the Tailz. Our panel members gave it an average rating of 94% based on the following criteria:
- Sensation: When it comes to sex toys, vibes are always welcome! I loved having the option to use a bullet vibrator with this perky cat tail butt plug and ears.
- Tail material: The option to adjust this plug via the internal metal wiring definitely sets this one apart, giving it a unique twist when compared to the majority of other cat tail butt plugs.
Features:
- Material: Mask: Faux leather & Plug: Silicone, metal, and polyester
- Total Length: 24”
- Insertable Length: 4”
- Circumference: 4.4”
Pros:
- Good value for a full set ($59.99)
- Internal wiring allows you to adjust the tail’s position
- Compatible with small bullet vibrators
- A great option for a size up
- The wide stem offers a nice stretch
Cons:
- The cat tail is heavy due to internal wiring
- The size and shape make it better suited for folks with some anal experience
Other Good Alternatives
Tailz Bad Kitty. In need of just a bendable kitten tail plug? Then Tailz Bad Kitty was made for you. With all the same specs as the Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug – including the option to attach a bullet vibe, this model stands out from the competition for its perkability. You’ll find the Tailzs Bad Kitty and other similar products in our tail butt plug guide.
Foxy Plugs 10 Speed Vibrating Cat Tail Butt Plug. Calling all vibe lovers! The Foxy Plugs 10 Speed is a budget-friendly vibrating cat tail plug that is small enough for complete beginners. This high-quality silicone model comes complete with a tail bushy enough to put a raccoon to shame.
Foxy Plugs Multicolor. Black, not your color? We’ve got just the one for you. Foxy Plugs Multicolor is a rainbow cat tail butt plug that comes complete with a battery-powered 10-speed bullet vibrator. The tail is thick and voluminous and feels amazing grazing the back of your legs.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 8 Best Strapons For Lesbians [Video Demonstration] - September 3, 2025
- 8 Best Egg Vibrators [Video Demonstration] - September 2, 2025
- 6 Best Vibrating Butt Plugs [Video Demonstration] - August 18, 2025
