We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
Some of the sex toys that we review here are plain but powerful — we’re generalizing here, but these are often the ones that we reach for when we’re on our own and on a mission. Others make a super sexy statement, and that can be enough even if they don’t have a whole lot else going for them.
This dildo gag is very much in the second category, but if that’s what you’re looking for, it will serve you pretty well. Read on for the full review.
This piece of gear is not classy, clever, or even cute. It’s (quite literally) in-your-face crude. But it does exactly what it sets out to do, and it does that pretty well. If you’re looking for something to humiliate your sub on a few different levels without actually hurting them, here it is! And to be fair, this piece is not just a joke. It is body-safe and reasonably well made, especially considering the price point.
Who Should Try It? Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag is probably best suited for beginners who want to dip their toes into domination play without breaking the bank.
Who Can Skip It? Let’s be honest: It’s not the best penis gag out there. If you want something that will last a long time, look sexy, and be more comfortable, I recommend investing in a higher-quality product.
You Can Buy It on the Shevibe website for $15.
What Is the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag?
The Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag straps across the sub’s mouth to keep them quiet. It’s got the typical straps and a leather mouthpiece (instead of a ball or a bit), but there’s also an anatomically correct silicone dildo on the other side of the mouthpiece.
“Making” your sub wear a penis on their face is humiliating, and it’s intended to be. This is a toy for people who are into that. There are plenty of other toys for folks who are not into that.
And to further emphasize the power dynamics, the Dom/me can ride the dildo that’s now mounted on the sub’s face. We urge caution with this since the sub will be gagged and can’t utilize any safe words; you can set up another signal like a bell or buzzer in the sub’s hands.
Unboxing and First Impressions
The Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag’s packaging is utilitarian. It’s a thin-nish printed cardboard package with the product inside. This is not a fragile item, though, so it doesn’t really need a molded cradle or padding to protect it.
There is no user guide, storage bag, or other extras. However, we need to keep in mind that this is a $15 piece of bondage gear! It is clear that the manufacturers focused on the product and not the packaging, and honestly, at this price point, that’s just fine with us.
Our first impressions were pretty positive. It’s not the buttery genuine leather that we’ve seen from The Stockroom, but it’s decent-quality leatherette with solid, even stitching. The silicone dildo is body-safe with some detail and texture.
How Do I Use the Dick Gag?
The Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag is not a complicated piece of gear. Place the mouthpiece in the sub’s mouth and fasten the straps behind their head and under their jaw. The straps should be firm enough that everything stays in place, but they should not be tight enough to bind.
We recommend checking the strap placement and tightness before you start your scene, so any discussion and adjustments are not part of the dynamic. The sub should feel comfortable expressing any discomfort; after all, safe and sane BDSM means that the sub should not have to experience any distress that they do not expect and consent to.
My Personal Experience
We ended up liking the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag more than we thought we would. What looked a little silly in its cardboard box was actually pretty sexy in practice.
The gag was reasonably comfortable, all things considered. The leatherette was soft and nicely finished, and while the mouthpiece was large enough to leave us (both of us — we tried it both ways) feeling some jaw strain, it was not unexpected or unbearable. The straps held securely without being overly tight, and the silicone dildo felt solid.
Design
The Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag embodies classic BDSM aesthetics with a lean towards industrial/light goth. The leatherette is black, of course, with metal hardware. The proprietary orange stitching honors its name (note that this sex toy is not affiliated with the series or any entity associated with it). The silicone dildo is nicely finished with a sculpted head, some ridges for texture, and even a few veins for realism.
Material
It’s not luxurious, but it is truly better than we had expected for the price. The leather is synthetic, but it is sturdy, soft, and nicely stitched and the metal fastenings feel solid. The dildo is body-safe, non-porous, phthalate-free silicone with a pleasant finish. There are no chemical smells or weird stickiness, and the whole thing cleaned up nicely with a commercial sex toy cleaner.
Stimulations
The dildo is a reasonable size for both anal and vaginal play, and the sculpted head and ridges add a nice touch of texture. However, the real stimulation here is what it represents and how it plays into a power dynamic. If this is the kind of thing that turns you and your partner on, the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag delivers admirably.
Build Quality
As we wrote about the materials, the build quality is solid overall and exceptional for the price point. While it won’t be mistaken for a truly high-end piece of gear, it is well made. The stitching is clean and even, the buckles hold tightly, and the silicone is firm and nicely finished. The straps may stretch a little bit during especially vigorous or extended use, but that’s really the only complaint we have.
Ease of Use
The Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag is a very straightforward piece of kit. Mouthpiece in mouth, straps in place, and good to go! The only concern we have — and this is definitely not exclusive to this toy — is that the sub can’t speak a safe word when they are gagged. And if the Dom/me is riding the sub’s face, they probably won’t be able to see a hand signal. As we wrote above, you’ll need to set up something else, like a buzzer or bell.
Versatility
This is pretty much a one-trick pony, and that’s okay. This is a toy that you buy for the express purpose of gagging a sub and making them wear a dildo. It does that well! But it doesn’t really do anything else. Maybe you could decorate a buddy’s bowling ball on league night.
Cleaning
The silicone dildo is body-safe and non-porous, so you can clean it with mild fragrance-free soap or sex toy cleaner and warm water. The leatherette straps should not be soaked or machine-washed, but you can spot-clean them as necessary. BDSM gear made of mixed materials generally requires a little extra effort to maintain, but this one is not too bad. Just make sure that it is completely dry before you store it away.
If you want to see what the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below (It’s the second product in the YouTube video):
Alternatives to the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag
If you like the idea of face dildos or chin dildos but are not sold on this particular product, we can also recommend:
Lux Fetish’s Original Facilitator
The Original Facilitator is another chin-strap dildo, but it sits below the mouth. This is somewhat safer for the sub (although other dildo gags can be used safely with proper precautions). It’s made from latex and feels different from the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag, which might be another point in its favor, especially if you are new to this kind of play.
Sportsheets’ Pivot In Your Face Strap-On
If you’re heading in the other direction and want something more than the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag, the Pivot In Your Face Strap-On is here for you. The sub’s whole head is wrapped in a secure neoprene harness that holds any dildo with a flared base. You can go as big and bad as you want here!
I Am Sold! Where Can I Buy It?
You can buy the Orange Is The New Black Dick Gag at SheVibe.com using this link.
Sandra
- Anos RC Thrusting Butt Plug Review - September 30, 2026
- JAVIDA RC Shaking Panty Vibe Review - September 25, 2026
- Atomic Thrusting Light-Up Plug Review - September 23, 2026
