Homemade Anal Dildo: PRO TIPS From A Sex Toy Tester

We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.

These days, it’s easier than ever to buy sex toys online or even in person — some big-box stores and pharmacies have them on the shelves and DoorDash will deliver! Even so, there’s still a lot of interest in homemade sex toys. Maybe you don’t want to deal with shopping or shipping, or maybe you want to customize something to your exact tastes.

We’ll explore some of these options, but we also need to be clear that it’s always wiser to purchase a product that’s been developed and tested to be safe. This Curved Silicone Suction Cup Dildo is under $30 at Lovehoney, and it ships quickly and discreetly.

Why You Should Trust Us

My Sex Toy Guide has been evaluating and reporting on sex toys, the personal pleasure product industry, and sexual health for over 10 years. We are well positioned to know what works and why, and more importantly, what is safe and reliable. We are also independent; our loyalty is to our readers and we are not paid by any brands. You should continue to trust us to bring you thoroughly researched, comprehensive information.

What Is a Homemade Anal Dildo?

An anal dildo is a sex toy intended for anal penetration. The anus and surrounding area is rich with nerve endings and very sensitive. People with prostates can sometimes achieve P-spot (prostate) orgasms through anal penetration, and people with vulvas can target the G-spot and the A-spot through the anal wall.

A homemade anal dildo is the DIY version of the above; some homemade dildos are more sophisticated than others. There are considerable safety concerns when you’re putting untested and likely unsanitary materials inside your body, no matter how elaborate they are.

We recommend checking out highly rated anal dildos, like the Curved Silicone Suction Cup Dildo above. This one is available at Lovehoney.com and it’s less than $30.

Are DIY Sex Toys Safe?

It is generally not safe to DIY your own sex toys. That goes double for toys that are used internally, and triple for toys that are exposed to fecal matter (no matter how clean you are and how much you prep, an anus is still the terminal exit point of the alimentary canal). Unless you are crafting your homemade anal dildo out of medical-grade silicone, borosilicate glass, stainless steel, or another non-porous material, you will not be able to clean it well enough to make it safe.

Anal dildos also need to have a wide or flared base for safety. It is easier than most people realize for a dildo to be “sucked in” to the anus, especially during orgasm contractions. The sphincter muscles are very strong and contract involuntarily when stimulated. All these people probably didn’t intend to get all these things stuck either. You also risk a homemade toy breaking off while in use.

There are plenty of very good sex toys out there these days. Brands like nJoy, Doc Johnson, Lelo, and We-Vibe, among many others, make pleasure products that are safe to use. With so many brands to choose from, you are sure to find something that suits you.

The Best of What’s Out There

Professionally produced sex toys are safer and better; the end. However, if you are still determined to try to make your own, these are some of the least-bad ideas that we’ve seen.

Please note that any action you take upon the information on this website is strictly at your own risk, as laid out in our Terms of Service.

1. Fruits and Vegetables

You can check out the produce department or your crisper drawer to find a size, shape, and firmness that appeals to you. There is definitely a lot of variety out there! Cucumbers, carrots, and bananas tend to be the favorites, but of course you can use anything that catches your fancy.

Do not peel the fruit or vegetable since that will weaken it. Do put a condom over it; fruits and vegetables have a tendency to break under pressure and if it’s contained in a latex wrapper, you’ll still be able to remove it easily. Besides, no one wants pesticides in their posterior.

2. Electric Toothbrush

A lot of electric toothbrush handles have a size and shape that work well as DIY anal dildos. Remove the bristle head! Electric toothbrush handles are also designed with ergonomic grips and can tolerate being washed.

Toothpaste is likely to irritate your rectum even in tiny amounts, so make sure to scrub it down thoroughly. We recommend using a condom here as well, in addition to a generous application of water-based lube.

3. Hairbrush Handle

Like electric toothbrush handles, hairbrush handles are meant to be held in the hand so they are ergonomic and smooth. Some are even made of silicone, which is ideal, or other plastics that have a little “give”. The hairbrush head is more than wide enough to serve as a safety stopper.

Again, you will want to scrub the hairbrush thoroughly to remove any traces of hair product, and if the handle is wooden, check for any areas that may splinter.

4. Wooden Spoons

Wooden spoons come in all shapes and sizes, and the spoon part is wide enough for safety. If you are new to anal play, you can find some handles that aren’t all that much larger than your thumb (these would usually be mixing spoons). If you’re looking for more than that, serving spoons tend to have wider handles. Wash the handle before (and after!) use, and make sure that there are no splinters or other imperfections.

If you’re considering using a wooden spoon, make sure to pick one with a handle that’s smooth and rounded to keep things comfortable and safe. Just like with the comb mentioned earlier, it’s important to avoid any spoons that have sharp edges or rough surfaces, as they could scratch or injure sensitive spots.

5. Clone-a-Willy

In some ways, this isn’t really a “homemade” anal dildo because it’s a commercially produced kit with safe, tested materials. In other ways, there’s nothing more DIY than an exact copy of your own penis (or your partner’s). No one else will have anything like it!

The Clone-a-Willy kit creates a silicone replica of your erect penis. It is not difficult to use, but logistics are easier if you have a partner to help out.

What Not to Do

We’ve explained generally why DIY anal dildos are not safe, but we’ve also seen suggestions and stories that deserve to be called out as things that are unsafe under any circumstances.

Glass Bottles: Yes, some luxury sex toys are made from glass. This doesn’t mean that any glass you happen to find around the house is safe to stick up your butt. High-end sex toy manufacturers use borosilicate glass, which is also what is used in laboratories (and your grandmother’s PYREX). This material is specially treated to be shatterproof. Beverage bottles are not. You risk serious injury. You’re much better off purchasing a glass dildo from a reputable retailer.
Anything Without a Flared Base: We’ve explained it above but we’ll say it again. If you’re going to insert anything anally, it needs to have an “emergency brake” in the form of a flared or wide base so that it doesn’t get stuck. At best, your rescue efforts will leave you sore, but the more likely outcome is a trip to the emergency department or urgent care.
Plunger or Broom/Mop Handle: First, these are generally large enough to cause bruising or other injury. We’re not shaming size queens, but if you’re going to go big, you should do it with something less rigid (silicone dildos are an excellent choice). Also, these are typically made with lower grades of wood and little attention to the finish, so they are prone to splintering or even breaking.
Porous Materials: Again, this is a recap of what we’ve already explained. Porous materials can’t be cleaned, and this makes them unsafe. Even if the toy looks clean, you can’t see bacteria or other microorganisms but they can see you. The safest sex toys are made from body-friendly non-porous materials.

Why Is It Better to Get Real Anal Sex Toys?

The bottom line, so to speak, is that you should use commercially manufactured anal sex toys because they are safer. The materials are safe for internal use and can be cleaned/sanitized, and they are designed not to get stuck or break off inside you. We think that this is reason enough! But if you need more:

Comfort

Toys made by people who know what they are doing are going to feel better than anything you cobble together at home. Sex toy manufacturers use premium materials and they create products that are designed to work with standard human anatomy. They will be a manageable size and almost certainly have a rounded or tapered tip for easy entrance.

Vixskin Johnny was the highest-rated product in our silicone dildo review article. Testers appreciated the lifelike detail and stimulating texture. It has a wide base for safety, and that base also fits in most harnesses so it can be used as a strap-on as well (don’t try that with anything from the produce drawer).

Effectiveness

Comfort is part of effectiveness, but there’s much more. If you are a visual person, you’ll love the look of an ultra-realistic dildo like the Vixskin Johnny above. You just can’t replicate that on your own! Also, sex toys produced by sex toy companies are engineered to hit human hot spots like the prostate or the G-spot and A-spot (yes, some people with vulvas can target these spots on the clitoral network with an anal dildo).

The Fun Factory Stronic is a vibrating, thrusting dildo with a tapered head and soft, skin-like silicone. It’s just not possible to make any sort of vibrating dildo at home, let alone one that’s as luxurious as this one.

Frequently Asked Questions

What materials can be used to make a homemade sex toy?

Any sex toy that will be used internally needs to be body-friendly and easily cleanable. This feels like a reasonable ask, but many common household items miss on at least one point. If you can’t be absolutely sure that your DIY anal dildo is both of these, you should put a condom over it before inserting it. Please keep in mind that oil-based lubes are not compatible with latex condoms.

What are some common risks associated with homemade sex toys?

Injuries, infections, irritation, and inflammation, to start with. All of these are risks that you face when you insert untested materials inside your body. You also run the risk of your homemade anal dildo getting stuck, either because it doesn’t have a wide base and it gets sucked in, or because it breaks in half mid-session. Your butt can stubbornly hang on to things that get stuck, so you may be looking at an expensive and awkward trip to the urgent care or emergency department.

Are there any specific cleaning methods for homemade sex toys?

This is actually one of the biggest arguments against homemade sex toys, especially for anal use. It’s simply not possible to thoroughly clean any material that is NOT non-porous, because even microscopic crevices will harbor skin cells, bodily fluids, lube, and other debris. This creates a breeding ground for bacteria.

If your DIY dildo is washable, you should use mild fragrance-free soap and plenty of warm water. Make sure that it is completely dry before you store it away.

What are some alternatives to using homemade sex toys?

Hands — your own or a willing partner’s — are the OG sex toys. You probably have them already, and you probably know how to clean them. And as we wrote in the introduction to this article, it’s very easy to buy sex toys either online or in person. While it’s true that some high-end pleasure products can be very spendy indeed, there are also plenty of basic budget-friendly toys that still meet safety criteria.

Maggie

Author
Recent Posts

Maggie Hart

Maggie Hart has written about sexual well-being and sexuality in society for quite a few years now. She is active in communities that celebrate sex for older adults.