After my testers tried what must have been dozens of fisting gloves, all of us agreed the safest and utterly highest-rated ones were Stockroom’s Shots Fist It Latex Gloves. Beating the competition hands down, we felt none other were as expertly designed, perfectly manufactured, made of premium quality latex, and— the only way to put it—”hands down” the most durable, comfortable, body-safe, and versatile ones ever.
Test Winner: Shots Fist It
Shots Fist It Latex Gloves got the highest rating in our review. Made from the highest quality materials and specifically designed for fisting by The Stockroom, they are as durable and flexible as they are pleasurable to wear.
Budget: Renegade Rubber Long
Everyone likes to save money, which is why, when it comes fisting gloves, we were thrilled to discover the Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten sells for the impressively low cost of just $19.99. Discount code MSTG15 for 15% off!
Table Of Contents
- Why You Should Trust Us
- How We Picked The Products
- Everything We Tested
- 1. Shots Fist It Latex Gloves: Our Test Winner!
- 2. Renegade Rubber Long: Our Budget Pick!
- 3. Master Series Pleasure Fister: Most Stimulating Texture!
- Other Good Alternatives
- What Is A Fisting Glove?
- How To Use A Fisting Glove?
- How To Clean a Fisting Glove?
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- Primary Sources
Why You Should Trust Us
Hi, I am M.Christian. With more than thirty-five years in the BDSM community under and below my belt, there’s little I haven’t tried, done, or written about. No less so than fisting, both anal and vaginal, so I know all the crucial factors needed to separate the merely good from the unequivocably best anal fisting gloves.
But I also know I can’t, well, “know” everything about fisting, which is why I called on my sex toy testing team and my carefully selected panel of BDSM enthusiasts, clinical sexologists, and sex educators to help me put together this list of this year’s top four fisting gloves.
How We Picked The Products
Attempting to pick the best of anything, let alone fisting gloves, can be extremely difficult, even for BDSM experts like myself and my testing team.
However, experience has taught me an important lesson: that using the following five-point selection process can make not only my and my testers’ job so much easier, but you can use the same system when it comes time to purchase your first set. Here are the well-defined quantitative metrics my team and I looked at:
- Manufacture: First and foremost, I’ve found that sticking to only BDSM community-respected companies like Lovehoney, The Stockroom, Hustler Hollywood, and Shots practically guarantees their BDSM gear will be exceptionally well made but also much much more pleasurable to use.
- Material: Limiting my search to only the aforementioned companies also means they go the extra mile when it comes to choosing the finest materials like vinyl or latex. In addition, kink community-respected manufacturers understand what to use and when which can make all the difference when it comes to safe and comfortable fisting gloves.
- Design: In a similar vein, The Stockroom, Shots, Lovehoney, and Hustler Hollywood get that, more than anything, their fisting gloves have to be perfectly designed. Otherwise, they might either harm the people using them or break apart in a short amount of time. We also looked at silicone or latex gloves with a good length, are nice and smooth, and are available in three different sizes.
- Safety: But of all the criteria I used when selecting this year’s best fisting gloves, by only choosing ones designed and manufactured by The Stockroom, Hustler Hollywood, Shots, and Lovehoney—companies respected for their dedication to customer comfort and safety—means their gear will be good for wearer and those lucky enough to be fisted by them.
- Versatility: Last but not least, I dished out a few extra points to review samples capable anal or vaginal penetration. But as fisting gloves are typically made and designed for that sole purpose, I also didn’t penalize any that were not particularly versatile.
I started my search for our review samples with the top, best-selling ones. Once my team of sex toy testers tried them out, I was left with ten potential candidates. During testing, we rated each of the toys based on the criteria listed above starting from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). Each score was calculated using different weighted metrics depending on what we deemed most important. The majority of the total rating comes from Manufacture (30%) and Material (30%). After that comes Safety (15%), Design (15%), and Versatility (10%).
A number that was knocked down to six after my sex tech experts gave them a once-over. Now left with five review samples to consider, I spent time looking over how well—or not—they’re reviewed online.
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| |  |
|
| Name | Fist It | Renegade | Master Series |
| Category | Best Overall | Budget | Textured |
| Average Rating | 96% | 91% | 93% |
| Design | 95% | 90% | 95% |
| Manufacture | 93% | 91% | 90% |
| Safety | 95% | 89% | 93% |
| Versatility | 92% | 92% | 94% |
| Price & Value | 95% | 97% | 93% |
| Price Tag | $34.95 | $19.99 | $39.90 |
| Material | Latex | Latex | Rubber (TPR) |
| Measurements | N/A | 18.5 inches | 15.5 inches |
| Color | Black | Black | Black |
1. Shots Fist It Latex Gloves: Our Test Winner!
Why I Love Shots Fist It Latex Gloves:
I’m happy to say that of all the latex fisting gloves my team, and I reviewed, the highest scoring, top-ranked of all time is the Shots Fist It Latex Gloves from The Stockroom.
Made from the highest quality materials and specifically designed for fisting by The Stockroom, who are legendary for crafting many of the all-time best BDSM toys and equipment, they are as durable and flexible as they are pleasurable to wear.
Not only that, but The Stockroom also went above and beyond to ensure their Latex Gloves are safe for both the person wearing them and whoever is being fisted.
When you come down to it, my entire sex toy testing team and my carefully selected panel of BDSM aficionados, highly regarded sexologists, and famous sex educators voted as one that they are truly this year’s highest-rated fisting gloves, bar none.
Minor Issues I Found During Testing:
After careful consideration, we felt the only thing some people might not like about their Latex Gloves is that they are made to be exceptionally durable and reusable; their thickness may make it challenging to navigate a person’s anus.
But this isn’t quite an issue if you have a device that could expand your or your partner’s anus. Using a BDSM speculum will highly complement the Stockroom’s Shots Fist It. If you’re interested in checking some products, here are the best BDSM speculums we tested.
That said, we still think these highest-ranking, undoubtedly top-scoring fisting gloves are so superiorly crafted and manufactured they’re a must-have, must-own for anyone interested in anal play scenes.
Why Shots Fist It is the best fisting glove:
My testing team, expert panel, and I were so impressed by them; all of us agreed to give these premium quality gloves the number one stop on our list. But there are more—far more—great reasons why we bestowed The Stockroom’s Fist It our overall test winner award:
- Manufacture: No other company, before or since, can beat The Stockroom when it comes to making such an impressive pair of fisting gloves. All of us were, quite frankly, blown away by the obvious care and workmanship that went into manufacturing them — and why all of us decided they and no other products were as good, safe, and comfortable as The Stockroom’s Shots Fist Its.
- Material: Just as The Stockroom is famous for going the extra mile when it comes to building many of the world’s finest, top-ranked BDSM toys and equipment, so too does the kink community respect their use of only the highest quality materials. For their Shots Fist It, you can tell when they went into them is just as amazing as how meticulously they manufactured them.
- Design: No toy or piece of BDSM gear, however well it’s made or how much work went into choosing the material, should be considered good, let alone the best if it’s not expertly designed. Fortunately, we agreed The Stockroom knows everything about designing fisting gloves, specifically their Shots Fist It ones — which is great news for anyone who wears them and those lucky enough to be on the receiving end of their smooth yet sturdy fingers.
- Safety: More than anything else, for any fisting gloves to be even considered for our review samples, they first and foremost be as safe as possible for the wearer and the fistee. Something we all felt these Shots Fist It are and then some, making them the ideal choice for beginners and experienced fisters alike.
- Versatility: While uniquely designed and made for anal fisting scenes, The Stockroom’s Shots Fist It allows for a variety of different styles of play. Whether it’s using a finger or two or someone’s entire fist, they remain the only choice due to their comfort, durability, and safety.
Features:
- Material: Latex
- Measurements: Each Fisting Glove Weighs Five Ounces
- Colors: Black
Pros:
- The gloves are designed and manufactured by The Stockroom, famous within the kink community for making the highest-scoring toys and BDSM equipment.
- While costing thirty-five dollars and ninety-five cents, they are so durable and reusable that they are more than worth paying so much money for.
- They are expertly crafted to be extra-comfortable for both the wearer and whoever they are fisting.
Cons:
- Some may find the gloves too thick and so difficult to feel, though.
- The high cost might put them beyond the budgets of most kinksters.
2. Renegade Rubber Long: Our Budget Pick!
Why I Love The Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten:
Everyone, especially kinksters like myself, like to save money, which is why, when it comes fisting gloves, my testers and I were thrilled to discover the Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten sells for the impressively low cost of just $9.99.
Every single member of my team and expert panel was blown away by the fact that they, and you, could have a pair of these top-ranked, high-scoring fisting gloves for less than twenty bucks.
Though even if they sold for three times that amount, we feel they’d be more than worth it due to how perfectly designed and brilliantly made these professional-grade gloves are for a great fisting experience or additional stimulation.
Not only that but when it comes to looking and playing good, few gloves are as gorgeous and stylish as a pair of Renegade Long Latex Fisting Mittens.
Minor Issues I Found During Testing:
When push came to shove, my experts and loyal team of sex toy testers agreed the only—and I mean only—drawback to a Renegade Long Latex Fisting Mitten is their $9.99 price tag is for one, and not a pair of them.
That said, they’re still a steal at $19.98, and that’s why we all felt they were something beginners and expert fists should own.
Why Renegade Rubber Long is our budget pick:
There’s so much to like and even love about a Renegade Long Latex Fisting Mitten that it’d take more than one dedicated article to explore them all.
So, trying to keep our list as brief as possible, let me say a Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten is so high ranked and top scoring because few other models are as flexible, comfy, or sensual. These arm-length latex gloves provide an enjoyable experience, even without having a single finger.
However, there are many more excellent reasons why we all gave the Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten so many points—which cements its position on our list as our budget pick.
- Manufacturer: From its tapered tip to its comfortable flared end, a Renegade Rubber Long Latex Fisting Mitten does everything and more; a high-scoring fisting glove. Not only that, but it’s made of quality latex, so is super-stylish and pleasurable for fister and fistee, no matter the style or type of anal play being done. Because they don’t have separate fingers and are extra smooth, it’s great at providing new sensations.
- Material: Formed from body-safe latex, each Renegade Fisting Mitten is exceptionally smooth, which every fisting glove should always aspire to be. Its latex construction is also more rather than less durable, so your Renegade Long Latex Fisting Mitten can be used over and over again.
- Safety: One of the top reasons why they made our list is how their super-smoothness means they won’t irritate or possibly injure the anus of whoever is being fisted.
Features:
- Material: Latex
- Measurements: Each Mitten Is Eighteen And A Half Inches In Length.
- Colors: Black
Pros:
- The fisting glove sells for the shockingly low cost of just nineteen ninety cents.
- Each glove enables easy penetration due to being specifically designed to maximize everyone’s fisting experience.
- Formed from body-safe latex and covers the wearer’s entire forearm
- Every mitten is crafted to be extremely smooth, which is ideal for fisting scenes.
- It has a shiny look and feels like a second skin.
Cons:
- Each mitten is sold separately and not as a pair.
- Some might find its lack of fingers harder to control than other fisting gloves.
3. Master Series Pleasure Fister: Most Stimulating Texture!
Why I Love The Master Series Pleasure Fister:
If you like texture, as in grooves and the like for miles, then look no further than our pick for the highest-ranking, top-scoring Master Series Pleasure Fister glove.
With every single inch of its surface carefully crafted to provide the most anal stimulation possible, the Master Series Pleasure Fister is all but guaranteed to send you or your partner’s arousal through the roof.
Just slip on this wildly textured bad boy and listen and feel whoever’s on the receiving end of it scream with delight, especially when you combine it with some finger action or hard thrusts.
Minor Issues I Found During Testing:
The only issue my experts and sex toy testers found about the Master Series Pleasure Fister is, unlike many of the gloves on our list, it likely requires a great deal of patience and a massive amount of lube to get you or your partner ready to receive it.
If you’re willing to spend some additional bucks, getting a high-quality lube injector will take the experience to an extra mile and will definitely make your life easier. Here are some of the best lube injectors we recommend.
Not that beginners should skip it; it’s just probably a good idea not to begin with a Master Series Pleasure Fister, and then when you or your partner’s ass is ready, move on to it for a more stimulating experience.
Why The Master Series Pleasure Fister is the best ribbed fisting gloves:
Uniquely and meticulously designed to maximize pleasure, the Master Series Pleasure Fister is something every fisting enthusiast should get.
Agreed, you may not want to begin with it, but nothing beats the Master Series Pleasure Fister for sensually elevating an anal-fisting scene. Trust me when I say while it may not be something you may or may not use every time you or your partner do some fisting play, you’ll be glad it’s around for when you want to try something different and wonderfully exciting.
But while that’s a major reason why it’s on this list, there are a lot more equally excellent reasons:
- Material: Crafted from high-grade thermoplastic rubber (TPR), a fister textured fisting glove is easy to clean and maintain as it is arousing to play with as it is comfortable to use.
- Design: Once in a great while, my team and I come across a sex toy or piece of BDSM gear that the moment you see it, and more than anything play with it, you know was designed and manufactured by a company or person who went above and beyond. Case in point, every one of them is a work of sexual art, largely because it’s clearly evident the manufacturer managed to give it as many grooves, spirals, bumps, and zig zags as possible.
Features:
- Material: Thermoplastic Rubber (TPR)
- Measurements: The Glove Is Fifteen And Half Inches In Length.
- Colors: Black
Pros:
- Each mitten is masterfully textured for an impressive variety of anal stimulation activities.
- Every pleasure fister textured fisting glove is sure to please even the most experienced of anal players.
Cons:
- Great though the Master Series Pleasure Fister is, most people will not be able to start a fisting scene with it.
Other Good Alternatives
Shots Toys Fist It Silicone fisting gloves because when it comes to fisting pleasure, few things are safer, more comfortable, and pleasurable than body-safe silicone. Fitted with a huge range of different textures, it’s sure to delight both fisting novices and extremely experienced players. We highly recommend getting a Shots Toys Fist It silicone glove as there’s no better-textured silicone glove—and none that is as arousing and sexually delightful for whoever gets to wear it and those fortunate enough to have this silicone glove is used.
What Is A Fisting Glove?
A fisting glove is a specially designed and manufactured garment for deep vaginal and anal penetration play. They are usually made of body-safe materials like vinyl or latex. While many fisting gloves closely resemble the non-anal-play variety, they also come with or without fingers as well as sport several textural details [2].
How To Use A Fisting Glove?
Note: Any action you take upon the information on this website is strictly at your own risk. Please read our Terms of Service to learn more.
The most important thing to understand about fisting scenes is how dangerous they can be. The human anus, after all, hasn’t evolved to take anything in but rather push waste out, so you’re already swimming upstream, so to speak.
But if you use well-made gloves and remember to use a good silicone lubricant, and stay in constant communication with the person who’s being fisting, you can greatly reduce the possibility of injury and improve your and your partner’s sex life. Don’t forget; you should always use silicone based lubes rather than water-based lube, as the anus will absorb a water-based lube far more quickly. Though water-based lubricants are good for vaginal play [3].
Above all else, fisting requires patience. It’s not something you or anyone else should rush. Depending on the person, comfortably receiving an entire fist can take anywhere from fifteen minutes to more than an hour. Because of this, think of fisting not as a destination but an arousing journey—and if, for whatever reason—the person being played with isn’t ready or capable of being fisted, never chastise or make them feel bad. Rather, support them by reminding you and them that fisting just sometimes doesn’t happen—and that’s okay [1].
How To Clean a Fisting Glove?
To prevent the spread of potentially dangerous germs, which might lead to life-threatening infections, always wash your fisting gloves before and after every use. But don’t use too much or the wrong kind of cleaning solutions. If you do, you might seriously injure yourself or your partner due to latex allergies or toxic shock.
To prevent this, always follow the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning instructions. If they, for some reason, aren’t available, reach out to the site or store where you brought them. Even the wrong toy cleaner can ruin a glove or harm the wearer. If a glove has a double-sided design be sure to turn it inside out to ensure it gets good and clean.
Even if you still can’t find them, follow the rule of less is more—as in use only an extremely small amount of scentless, mild soap or a toy cleaner solution followed by a thorough warm water wash, rinse, and dry.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Are Fisting Gloves Safe?
Yes. If used correctly by people well versed in the pleasures and risks of anal play, fisting gloves can be very safe to use [1]. But the operative words there were “well versed” as failing to grasp how risky fisting can be can potentially lead to disaster. So before you do anything, learn as much as you can about fisting, no less so what to do should something go wrong.
How To Make A Fisting Glove?
It’s not only practically impossible but extremely foolish to attempt to make your fisting gloves. First, choosing the wrong design or materials ups the ante of harming yourself or your partner. It’s much better to buy high-quality gear from BDSM-community-supported companies like The Stockroom, Hustler Hollywood, Shots, or Lovehoney.
What Types Of Fisting Gloves Materials Exist?
Fisting gloves come in all sorts of different materials, including high-quality latex, silicone, or vinyl [2]. Due to this, make sure to find out if you or your partner might have an allergy to any of them. Failure to do so may result in discomfort, pain, or a trip to the emergency room.
Primary Sources
1. TheSanFranciscoAidsFoundation. Expert Advice: 8 Steps For First-Time Fisters (July 2018)
2. Cosmopolitan. 8 Best Sex Gloves for Safer Play (and Why You Should Get a Pair) (January 2020)
3. DevianceAndDesire. Anal Fisting – Preparing for Play (August 2015)
M.Christian
Website | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook
