We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
Warning! This review isn’t for the faint of heart! Hollow butt plugs are a unique and often overlooked anal toy that promises big pleasure, and to help you find the best of the best, our testers personally tested 10 of the highest-rated products for sale today.
Through their testing, they all fell in love with the Oxballs Pig-Hole, a product made from platinum-cure silicone that achieves the perfect balance of stretch and comfort. Here’s what they had to say to the best hollow butt plug in the market!
Test Winner: Oxballs Pig-Hole
Oxballs Pig-Hole got the highest rating in our review. The testers especially loved that it comes in five size options. Its smallest is designed to be used by beginners, while the XX-large is guaranteed to have you squealing like a pig!
Budget Pick: Perfect Fit Medium
Whether you have a limited budget or want a beginner-friendly(ish) plug, Perfect Fit Medium is perfect. It’s crafted from medium firmness plastic with a slightly tapered tip to gently slide inside your bum. Discount code AFF-MSTG10 for 10% off!
Table Of Contents
Why You Should Trust Us
Here at My Sex Toy Guide, we believe in providing our readers with accurate and reliable information to help them make informed decisions about one of the most personal and important things about themselves; their sex life.
To help us do so, we have employed a team of sex experts, including Rachel Sommer, Ph.D., who has been an essential part of the testing and reviewing process since 2016, which has to date included over 300 sex toys. Her years of experience in the world of sex toys, testing everything from simple vibrators to today’s latest innovations, have allowed her to develop a keen eye for quality, functionality, and user experience. So without further ado, here’s her unbiased review of some of this year’s best hollow butt plugs.
How We Picked The Products
Recommending only the highest-rated tunnel butt plugs to my readers is my #1 goal in these reviews. For that reason, my team of sex experts and I chose ten of the most popular products on the current market and I developed an extremely useful system that enables us to narrow down the possible contenders and make picking our review samples much easier. Here are the test criteria that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100:
- Plug material: When you’ve tested as many toys as my panel members and I have, it’s not hard to tell the difference between high and low-quality plastics, and we only chose products made from the former.
- Ease of insertion: Not being able to get your anal toy in can be a real buzz kill. For that reason, we ensured that our picks weren’t mission impossible to insert and pop open.
- Safety: As always, an appropriately sized flared base was a must for all our top contenders.
- Sturdiness: Once in, hollow butt plugs must hold their shape despite any tensing of the cheeks or penetration with separate objects.
- Comfort: Whether you want to wear your hollow butt plug to the grocery store, around the house, or only in the bedroom, we were on the lookout for ergonomically correct toys that could be comfortably worn for hours.
- Sensation: Things like ribbing and unique body shapes make all the difference in enhancing sensation during use.
- Size: To make anal training easier, we tried to find review samples with multiple size options so you can simply size up when the time is right.
- Design: Important design features include things like a comfy flared base, girth in all the right places, being made from transparent materials, and the like.
- Cleanability: Silicone butt plugs that hold onto scent have an expiration date and don’t often make it on my list of recommended products.
- Price rating: Although technically not the most budget-friendly sex toy, I did try to include some less expensive options for anyone working with a limited budget.
During testing, we rated each of the review samples based on the criteria listed above, starting from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). Each score was calculated using different weighted metrics depending on what we deemed most important. The majority of the total rating comes from Plug material (20%) and Ease of insertion (20%). After that comes Safety(10%), Size (10%), Sturdiness (10%), Comfort (10%), Sensation (5%), Size (5%), Design (5%), and Price rating (5%).
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| |
|
| Name | Oxballs | Perfect Fit |
| Category | Best Overall | Budget |
| Average Rating | 98% | 94% |
| Plug Material | 95% | 90% |
| Ease of Insertion | 94% | 91% |
| Safety | 91% | 93% |
| Size | 93% | 91% |
| Sturdiness | 90% | 89% |
| Comfort | 97% | 92% |
| Sensation | 95% | 91% |
| Price & Value | 94% | 96% |
| Price Tag | $56.00 | $34.99 |
| Material | Silicone | Plastic |
| Total Length | 4 - 6.75 inches | 3.5 inches |
| Insertable Length | 3 - 5 inches | 3 inches |
| Circumference | 6.75 - 10.25 inches | 6.5 inches |
1. Oxballs Pig-Hole: Our Overall Test Winner!
Why we love Oxballs Pig-Hole:
If you’re looking for an extreme stretch, lots of room to work with, and have your sights set on rose budding, then a pig hole butt plug will be your best bet – and you won’t find any better than the Oxballs Pig-Hole. This bad boy comes in five very different size options. Its smallest is designed to be used by absolute beginners (though it will help to have a little anal play experience under your belt), while the XX-large is guaranteed to have you squealing like a pig.
Inserting Oxballs Pig-Hole has a bit of a learning curve, but it didn’t take me long to catch on. Though our reviewers all used the same folding technique to get it in, some found it best to douse it with lube, while others preferred to use it sparingly, so don’t be afraid to experiment.
Once in, using your fingers is the easiest way to ‘pop’ the plug back to its original shape, though you can also use a separate plug in the middle to hold it open during insertion or to pop it open. I was also pleasantly surprised to find that post-insertion, it didn’t collapse in on itself at all during use and instead held its shape incredibly well, even when I clenched my bum muscles. Comfort-wise, my team and I agreed that it was extremely pleasant to wear (one of the most comfortable hollow plugs I’ve ever worn), especially considering how wide open it gets you.
If you plan to use it for partner play, the size Medium or bigger is the ideal fit for a 6” cock with average to above average girth, and the plug also offers internal ribbing for his pleasure. In terms of quality, once I had it in hand, I couldn’t help but feel like this thing was virtually indestructible. And since the platinum-cure silicone doesn’t hold onto smell, this baby will definitely last a lifetime.
Minor issues found during testing:
Though the Oxballs Pig-Hole is very ergonomically correct and, therefore, super comfortable to wear (even for long periods), I found the base to be a little bulky. For that reason, not only can I not imagine walking around with it in, but I imagine it would also be difficult to hide under your average pair of jeans. In my opinion, you’re better off with a small butt plug if you find this issue quite upsetting.
And although the black does the trick, having different color options, especially a clear one, would be a nice (albeit not overly necessary) touch.
Why Oxballs Pig-Hole is the best tunnel butt plug:
Whether you’re in the market for a pig hole particular hollow anal butt plug or not, the Oxballs Pig-Hole easily took pole position and earned a rating of 98% from me and my team.
- Size: I love it when a butt plug has plenty of size options to choose from. That way, you can continue using your most beloved plug as your experience grows.
- Comfort: One of the, if not the most, important factors in choosing a butt plug of this size is how comfortable it is. I was amazed by how comfortable this bae is, especially considering the amount of gape it’s able to achieve. Oxballs Pig-Hole handily beat the competition in this critical category.
Features:
- Material: Premium-grade silicone
- Total Length: 4” to 6.75”
- Insertable Length: 3” to 5”
- Circumference: 6.75 to 10.25”
Pros:
- Made of high-quality platinum-cure silicone
- A perfect balance of soft and solid
- Short and wide, leaving lots of room for penetrative play
- Five size options to choose from
- Internal ribbing for added sensation
Cons:
- The base is quite large and not ideal for public play
- I would have liked more color options
2. Perfect Fit Medium Tunnel: Our Budget Pick!
Why we love Perfect Fit Medium Tunnel Anal Plug 3 Inch:
Whether you’re working with a limited budget or are in the market for a beginner-friendly(ish) model, this bad boy could be your perfect fit. Unlike the other review samples, which are made from soft material and designed to be folded during insertion and ‘popped’ into their final resting position, the Perfect Fit Medium is crafted from medium firmness plastic that has just enough give and a slightly tapered tip that allows it to maintain its original shape while being gently slid inside your bum.
It also has the added benefit of being completely translucent, which makes putting on a beautiful gaping show for your partner easier than ever. In terms of size, I would consider this one to be relatively beginner-friendly, especially when compared to our first pick. That being said, you can still expect to need a lot of lube (water-based since this is a plastic plug), lots of time, and maybe some prep work using a smaller size to warm yourself up.
But if you can manage the size of this clear hollow butt plug, expect to feel like you’ve somehow fit a cloud in your bum since the softness and squishiness of the plastic are just about on the same level. The pliability of the plastic also makes it a nice addition to vaginal play since it has more give and therefore doesn’t create uncomfortable pressure when maneuvering into bendier positions, which I appreciated during both solo and partner play. No worries about the plastic having that classic “cheap plastic” smell, as it’s completely odorless and easy enough to clean that it won’t pick up unwanted odor over time.
Minor issues found during testing:
The Perfect Fit Medium is definitely better suited for beginners than some other options but should still only be used by folks with some prior anal experience.
Also, since the bulb doesn’t lock into place, if you have exceptionally tight butt muscles, you may find that the hole in the Perfect Fit’s center compresses to the point that you can’t manage much more than your pinky finger.
Why Perfect Fit Medium Tunnel is our budget pick:
Finding a product that is budget-friendly but still high enough quality that I feel confident recommending it to my readers isn’t easy. The Perfect Fit Medium, however, made my job a lot easier, considering its rating of 94% from my team of sex experts, much higher than the other cheap hollow butt plugs we tested.
- Comfort: Thanks to the squishiness of the material, it feels completely unobtrusive and is great to use during vaginal sex as it molds to fit the body in any position.
- Price rating: When it comes to hollow butt plugs, a $34.99 price tag is an absolute steal, especially when you factor in the quality level of the Perfect Fit Medium.
Features:
- Material: Soft plastic
- Total Length: 3.5”
- Insertable Length: 3”
- Circumference: 6.5”
Pros:
- One of the more beginner-friendly hollow butt plugs
- Made from super soft and body-safe plastic
- Easier to insert than other hollow butt plugs
- The translucent body is perfect for gaping
- Very budget-friendly ($34.99)
Cons:
- Only one size option
- The hole in the toy’s center can be squeezed shut
Other Good Alternatives
Oxballs Butt-Hole: Looking for your next challenge? The Oxballs Butt-Hole is sure to test your limits. This ultra-ribbed hollow plug is just the right amount of soft and solid, offering an unbelievable amount of stretch while still moving with your body to enhance comfort. Its three-size options range from small to large, though even the smallest option is pretty huge, so you better be ready! The internal ribbing not only helps to enhance sensation for the wearer and penetrator but also makes it so that this large model is super sturdy and basically impossible to collapse.
Oxballs Silicone Stopper Plug: Not exactly a hollow butt plug, the Oxballs Silicone Stopper Plug helps keep all the goodness from dripping out before the fun is over. Plug up your butt, and when the time is ready, pull it out for a grand finale you’re sure not to forget any time soon.
How To Use A Hollow Butt Plug?
With plenty of size options to choose from, everyone from beginners to advanced toy users can find the right fit. After finding your perfect plug, here’s how to use it:
- Depending on your toy’s size, you might want to start with a smaller plug or your fingers.
- Gather the required anal plugs and thoroughly clean them inside and out, even if they’re fresh out of the box. You may also use this prep time to freshen up your bum’s interior (using just water and maybe a finger/douche).
- Using the appropriate kind of lube for your sex toy material, apply a generous helping to both the exterior (or your fingers) and your anus.
- Find a comfortable position (my favorite is lying on my side), spread your cheeks, and start gently inserting the tapered tip of the smallest toy.
- Take your time preparing your bum with the smaller sizes if necessary. Once ready, either insert the tapered tip of your hollow anal plug or it’s made from soft silicone fold it before inserting it and then ‘pop’ it open once fully inserted.
The process of inserting a toy of this size can feel intimidating. If you’re looking for more information on safely using your hollow sex toy, check out our guide here.
You can find more anal toys in our comprehensive butt plugs review.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 7 Best Wand Vibrators [Video Demonstration] - September 16, 2025
- 7 Best Vibrating Panties [Video Demonstration] - September 14, 2025
- 8 Best Strapons For Lesbians [Video Demonstration] - September 3, 2025
