If you’re looking for some great beginner butt plugs, the search ends here! After testing dozens of extra-small models, our team dubbed the b-Vibe Rimming Plug, in its petite size, as this year’s best small butt plug for beginners. This super unique anal toy uses rotating beads to recreate the sensation of getting rimmed – and does a dang good job of it. Size-wise, it’s at the sweet spot of being beginner-friendly, but not so small that you’ll outgrow it in a month. Keep reading for the full scoop of our review to learn more!
Test Winner: b-Vibe Rimming Plug Petite
b-Vibe Rimming Plug Petite got the highest rating in our review. Our testers especially loved the ingenious design of rotating beads to stimulate the anus, using them to tickle and massage this nerve-dense area. Discount code MSTG15 for 15% off!
Budget Pick: Lovehoney Butt Tingler
Don’t have lots of money to shell out on a small plug? Lovehoney Butt Tingler is a top-seller (with over 500 positive reviews) with a modest 3.75” circumference, small enough for even absolute beginners.
App-Controlled: Lovense Hush 2 XS
You can use the award-winning Lovense app to control Hush 2 XS from anywhere. It also gives you the option to create custom patterns, sync to your favorite song, or use one of its many canned settings on days when inspiration is lacking.
Table Of Contents
- Why You Should Trust Us
- How We Picked The Products
- Everything We Tested
- 1. b-Vibe Rimming Plug Petite: Our Overall Test Winner
- 2. We-Vibe Ditto+: Great For Partnered Sex
- Other Good Alternatives
- What Is A Small Butt Plug?
- How To Use A Small Butt Plug?
- How To Clean A Small Butt Plug?
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why You Should Trust Us
Rachel Sommers is a clinical sexologist who has been working with My Sex Toy Guide since its inception in 2016. During that time, she has been instrumental in our review process, helping lead teams responsible for the first-hand testing of over 300+ sex toys.
Her expertise has been critical in upholding the My Sex Toy Guide mission to provide our readers with unbiased information and expert guidance on how to choose the right sex toy for their personal pleasure journey.
If you have questions for Rachel or want to share recommendations, please don’t hesitate to reach out. You can call her at +1 307-372-3895, send an email to [email protected], or leave a comment below. Be sure to include your full name and your phone number or email address.
How We Picked The Products
Have trouble finding reviews that provide accurate and up-to-date information? Your search ends here! My years as a clinical sexologist – in combination with testing hundreds of products, means I can spot the difference between a good sex toy and a great one. For this review, I compiled a list of the 20 best small butt plugs on the market and had my review team grade each one. After that, I defined test criteria that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100. These factors included the following:
- User feedback: When choosing products for our reviews, user feedback guides our selection process, as we always want to recommend today’s most popular picks.
- Material: There is no perfect material when it comes to a tiny butt plug. Each person has unique desires that are most easily fulfilled by either glass, metal, or plastic, and for that reason, we had to include review samples made from all three. If you want to see what glass butt plugs or metal butt plugs look like, you can check them out by clicking their respective links.
- Safety: Worried about your anal toy not being safe for use? No need to be! We made sure each product we recommend has an appropriately sized flared base to prevent any unwanted mishaps.
- Size: Obviously, size was one of the more important factors considered in this review, as everything needs to be small enough to suit a complete beginner.
- Design: Some folks love simple, and others love sparkly. My review team and I made sure to include a little something for everyone.
- Cleanability: Removable tails and non-porous materials are better for cleaning, and we try to ensure that all of the products we recommend will last the test of time.
- Special features: Looking for that X-factor? Whether it’s a colorful tail, ample vibration settings, or a product that re-creates the perfect rim job, you’ll find it in this review!
- Sensation: We were on the hunt for toys that provided the mouth-watering stretching sensation we all want out of a butt plug without being too much for the most novice bum.
- Price rating: If you’re shy to shell out hundreds of dollars on your first toy, don’t stress. Included in this review is everything from budget picks to luxury options.
- Quality: All products we recommend are sold by retailers that we have 7 years+ of experience buying from, and therefore trust to provide only the highest quality products.
During testing, we rated each of the toys based on the criteria listed above, starting from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). Each score was calculated using different weighted metrics depending on what we deemed most important. Half the total rating comes from Design and Size (25%) along with Safety and Material (25%). After that comes User feedback (10%), Sensation (10%), Special features (10%), Cleanability (10%), and Price (10%).
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
No Image Available
Name b-Vibe Ditto+ Butt Tingler Hush 2 Pure Plug Jeweled Heart Booty Call Unicorn NS Novelties
Category Best Overall Partnered Sex Beginner Long-distance Metal Princess Inflatable Tail Weighted
Average Rating 96% 95% 95% 94% 93% 92% 92% 90% 89%
Design 92% 95% 96% 95% 96% 95% 94% 91% 91%
Safety 94% 92% 93% 90% 90% 91% 92% 88% 88%
Size 95% 94% 91% 92% 95% 93% 94% 92% 92%
Build Quality 94% 96% 90% 90% 94% 95% 92% 90% 87%
Cleanability 96% 93% 94% 92% 91% 96% 93% 93% 93%
Special Features 93% 92% 90% 91% 90% 85% 97% 91% 87%
Price & Value 93% 93% 96% 94% 90% 92% 92% 88% 94%
Price Tag $144.99 $129 $16.99 – $26.99 $79-$109 $99.99 $26.99 $32.99 $150 $17.20
Material Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Steel Steel Silicone Silicone &
FibersGlass
Insertable Length 3 inches 2.75 inches 3.5 inches 3.86 – 5.16 inches 2.5 inches 2.5 inches 4 inches 4.5 inches 2.75 inches
Diameter 1.43 inches 1.19 inches 1.1 inches 1 – 2.25 inches 0.95 inches 1.1 inches N/A 1.5 inches 0.8 inches
1. b-Vibe Rimming Plug Petite: Our Overall Test Winner
Why we love the b-Vibe Rimming Plug:
B-Vibe has been making waves in the world of butt plugs, claiming multiple awards for their top-tier product lines and luxury toys since their inception in 2016. Since anal is all they do, it’s no surprise that they’ve created some of the best butt plugs known to man – one of which quickly stole the hearts of our reviewers. Introducing the b-Vibe Rimming plug, our highest-rated model!
I can honestly say that I’ve spent my life up until this point convinced that the one-of-a-kind sensation of a rim job would be accessible only via the tongue of a lover and not for solo play. That is, until, I had the pleasure of using the b-Vibe Rimming Plug. The ingenious design team at b-Vibe had the brilliant idea of using rotating jelly beads to stimulate the anal opening, using them to tickle and massage the sensitive nerve endings in the anal sphincter, and the result is pretty spectacular.
Although it’s not to be confused with an actual rim job, the rimming beads do their job wonderfully, and offer a sensation that easily rivals even the most skilled tongues. I also loved that, unlike many other beaded toys, the b-Vibe Rimming Plug doesn’t make an off-putting grating noise – though it can’t be considered whisper-quiet. I’d be lying if I said that I spent a ton of time exploring the 7 vibration patterns offered by the Rimming Plug (the beads kept me a little distracted), but from what I saw, even sans beads, the vibes can pull their own weight, making this a versatile toy.
Coming in with a circumference of 4.5”, the size of this small silicone plug is well within what I would consider appropriate for a beginner model; just make sure to use lots of water-based lube! A few of the minor details, like USB rechargeability (as demonstrated in the image above) and silky-smooth silicone, definitely helped bring it from ordinary to extraordinary and give it the luxury touch that you would expect from a $159 toy.
And as you would expect from our top-rated product, the b-Vibe Rimming Plug comes equipped with an easy-to-use remote that helps you avoid an awkward reacharound to adjust the settings during use. You can see the remote along with the other content of the box in the image above.
Minor issues found during testing:
Though overall, there isn’t much to dislike about the b-Vibe Rimming Plug, there are a couple of things that I would do differently. The biggest complaint among my test panel members was related to the fact that you’re not able to control the vibes and rimming beads separately, and I found that the first overrode the latter on its higher speed settings.
And although the vibration settings on the Rimming Plug are quiet enough to be used almost anywhere, the rotating beads can be on the noisy side, making it unideal for busy households and public play. If the noise is kind of a deal breaker for you, perhaps you can try looking for a more quiet alternative in our butt plug guide.
Why b-Vibe Rimming Plug is the highest-rated beginner butt plug:
After comparing this one to the dozens of others that we tested, there was no doubt that it would clinch the title among the review samples. Our testers loved it so much, they gave it an average rating of 97%, by far the highest in our review roundup.
- Special features: I’ve been a butt plug user for going on a decade, and in all my many years, I’ve never found another toy as unique as this one! The rimming beads on this extra small model make it a must-have for every collection.
- Size: The petite size, nicely rounded shape, extra-long stem, and t-shaped base make it much more comfortable than the other models we tested, and a top-notch butt plug for beginners.
- Quality: I loved that this toy could withstand a gentle clenching of my anal muscles without missing a beat. The craftsmanship that went into this Rimming Plug is immediately visible after unboxing it.
If you want to see what the b-Vibe Rimming Plug looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Total Length: 5”
- Insertable Length: 3”
- Circumference: 4.5”
Pros:
- It can be controlled via a remote
- Has a whopping 4.5-hour run time
- Whisper-quiet when using vibes only
- USB-rechargeability
- The sensation of the rimming beads is addictive
- Vibes are strong, deep, and rumbly
Cons:
- Not completely waterproof (no shower butt play allowed)
- Slightly expensive ($159.99)
- You can’t control the rimming beads and vibrations separately
- The rotating mechanism in the slim neck isn’t whisper-quiet
2. We-Vibe Ditto+: Great For Partnered Sex
Why we love We-Vibe Ditto+:
We-Vibe Ditto’s impressive design combines simplicity and functionality efficiently. From the cock-eyed build with a bulging side to the protruding bump at the center (circled in blue above), everything about the We-Vibe Ditto+ promotes anal orgasms while ensuring the sex toy stays intact.
The well-measured build makes it ideal for different anal sex fans. Unless you’re the most experienced sex toy user looking for intense anal stretching, We-Vibe Ditto+ will be enticing. Its tapered head makes penetration easy, while the extended, slim neck ensures it stays in place throughout use. And with a flared base (image below), you can use the anal plug during intense masturbation or partnered sex without worrying about over-insertion.
We-Vibe Ditto’s velvety, smooth silicone complements the tapered design. The cozy finish feels incredibly sweet during insertion and subsequent thrusting. Plus, the new remote control has a soft silicone finish that feels great on the hand.
Besides the all-silicone remote control, the 2nd generation Ditto features impressive upgrades, including the tapered design for easy insertion and a more powerful motor for intense sensations.
The small Ditto+ has an extended range of vibration patterns, rendering it highly customizable regardless of your experience and preferred stimulation. In addition, the modes are named intelligently, so you can easily remember your favorite every time you use the anal plug.
Pro Tip: We-Vibe Ditto’s vibration settings start on the buzzy side of the spectrum and slowly turn rumbly, making the sex toy perfect regardless of your preference.
I loved how easy to use the included remote control was (circled in the image above. And mainly because of the silicone finish and straightforward user interface. Luckily, Ditto+ is compatible with the We-Vibe app. I’ve used numerous sex toy applications, and the We-Vibe app only comes second to the Lovense Remote app. From the user interface to the endless customization, you’ll love the experience.
Notably, Ditto+ is relatively quiet, with a range of 35 and 60 decibels. So, while you can’t use it in the library, your popular restaurant during peak hours will do.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, Ditto+ is pricey. It costs $129, which is comparatively high for budget seekers. I recommend Lovehoney Butt Tingler if you want a cheap small butt plug.
Aquatic play fans will also be disappointed to learn that the remote control is only splashproof. A fully waterproof remote control would’ve been a reasonable upgrade on the We-Vibe Ditto+.
Why We-Vibe Ditto+ is our favorite for penetrative sex:
- Design: We-Vibe Ditto+’s designers blended simplicity and functionality efficiently. The testers highlighted how the well-thought build, tapered head, bulging side, and mid-bump were essential in making it stay inside during penetrative sex, much better than the other models we tested.
- Stimulations: The 10+ vibration modes are an impressive feat for its size. The team loved the robust motor and the progression from the gentle buzzy vibrations to the rumbly reverberations that spread throughout the anal canal. “I think everyone was surprised at the trackable changes in intensity and consistency,” confirmed one of the reviewers.
- Features: Besides the 2nd generation toy’s upgrades, We-Vibe Ditto’s compatibility with the We-Vibe app made it stand out from other review samples. The app offers unlimited customization, long-distance control, and endless possibilities.
If you want to see what We-Vibe Ditto+ looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
You can read our full review of We-Vibe Ditto+ in this article.
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Insertable Length: 2.75″
- Circumference: 3.75″
Pros:
- An incredibly designed small butt plug.
- Its small size renders it perfect for partnered sex.
- The toy and remote have a luscious silicone finish.
- Impressive range of vibration patterns.
- The mobile application offers endless customization.
- Perfect for long-distance partners.
Cons:
- The remote control is not waterproof.
- A little pricey – $129.
Other Good Alternatives
Lovehoney Butt Tingler
Don’t have a ton of money to shell out on a new soft silicone plug? Not a problem! The Lovehoney Butt Tingler is our budget pick with a modest 3.75” circumference, small enough for even our most beginner players.
It’s also fully waterproof and has the option to be used with or without the removable buzzy bullet vibrator, making it one of our most versatile options! Just be sure to stock up on AAA batteries, as batteries are not included. You can read the Lovehoney Butt Tingler full review here.
Lovense Hush 2
Whether you want to use yours for public play, to connect with your long-distance lover, or are working with limited mobility, the app-controlled Lovense Hush 2 will be your perfect fit for your anal exploration. The award-winning Lovense app can be used to control your toy from anywhere and gives you the option to create custom patterns, sync it to your favorite song, or use one of its many canned settings on days when inspiration is lacking.
You can also find the identical plug in four different sizes, making it a great beginner model as you can size up at any time without having to adjust to a completely new brand. Make sure to check the Lovense Hush 2 full review for more information.
njoy Pure Plug Small
The njoy Pure Plug Small is a great small metal butt plug that packs a mean punch! Ideal for prostate stimulation, the Pure Plug features a nicely curved base ending in a bulbous head with a super tapered tip that helps pinpoint sensation exactly where you want it.
Note: The product above is the nJoy Pure Plug in regular size. Their main difference is the nJoy Pure Plug is bigger than 1 inch in circumference and half an inch in total length. If you want to read the full review of the regular-sized nJoy Pure plug, click here.
The t-shaped base atop a super thin neck is extremely comfortable even when worn for multiple hours and also serves as a handle that aids in easy insertion and can be used to easily manipulate your plug in whatever way you desire.
Lovehoney Jewelled Heart
Ready to be treated like a princess in the bedroom? The Lovehoney Jewelled Heart is the best jeweled butt plug that can help you feel like a real-life Cinderella. The highlight of this relatively simple product is its heart-shaped base which is embossed in a sparkly light pink jewel. And I think you might be interested to know that this beaut is the highest-rated princess butt plug we tested.
At only $26.99, this small jeweled butt plug is a steal of a deal, and with over 200 5-star reviews, you can rest assured that both you and your partner (if they’re lucky enough to see it) will fall in love with this bae – just like I and my testers did. It’s also great for temperature play. For the Lovehoney Jewelled Heart full review, click here.
Booty Call Small
If anal sex with a penis-endowed partner is your goal, the Booty Call Small can help fast-track your path to it. The Booty Call, a good small inflatable butt plug, starts at a super manageable 4.5” circumference and quickly inflates to a whopping 8.25” through a few pumps of the attached hand pump.
The toy’s flexible silicone exterior is silky smooth to the touch, and at $32.99, it fits well within most budgets. You can find how well it performed compared to the other inflatable butt plugs here.
b-Vibe Unicorn Tail
Calling all My Little Pony Lovers! The b-Vibe Unicorn Tail is our favorite tailed butt plug and has everything you need to complete your transformation into a horny unicorn. The gorgeous pastel pink, purple, and green tail on this skinny babe is completely removable, making for easy post-play cleanup and leaving you with the option to use it sans tail.
Even tail-less, this plug will keep you busy with its 6 vibe patterns and 10-speed options, and I loved that the sensation of the swirly plug felt similar to anal beads during penetrative anal play. You can find more tail butt plugs in this roundup.
NS Novelties Crystal Glass Small
If you love a weighted butt plug, then you’ll be crazy about the NS Novelties Crystal Glass Small, our small glass butt plug pick. This hand-blown borosilicate glass product is not only beautiful to look at, but also adds an oomph to ass play. The long body and tapered tip provide a deeply filling sensation, and the extra-wide stem makes it ideal for stretching out your tush in preparation for all other types of butt stuff.
What Is A Small Butt Plug?
A small butt plug is a type of anal sex toy that is ideal for folks new to anal play. As the name suggests, they’re smaller than the general butt plug and therefore offer easier insertion than your standard model and shouldn’t cause an untrained tush or any pain during use.
How To Use A Small Butt Plug?
Ready to put your new mini plug to good use? Here’s everything you need to know to get started:
- Start by getting everything nice and clean! Using warm water and mild soap, give both your plug and anal opening a gentle scrub.
- From there, you’ll want to set a mood that feels warm and relaxing to help facilitate the relaxing of your anal muscles. A gentle anus massage with lube can also be a nice touch.
- After slathering your anal plug with the appropriate lube, the fun begins! Starting pointy end first, begin gently rocking your plug into your bum until it inserts fully.
You know what they say, preparation is everything! To ensure your first experience with an anal plug is a positive one, check out our extensive guide on proper plug use.
How To Clean A Small Butt Plug?
The procedure for cleaning any kind of sex toy is more or less the same, but if you’re new to toy play or are simply looking for a refresher, here’s a simple step-by-step for you to follow:
- If you have a vibrating butt plug, double-check that it’s waterproof before washing it to avoid frying the motor.
- Submersible anal toys can be run under hot water and then scrubbed using a gentle cleaner; hand soap is fine! (Make sure to get all your toy’s nooks and crannies.)
- Afterward, simply dry it with a clean towel before storing it somewhere safe. I also recommend storing sex toys separately to avoid the spread of bacteria; individual storage bags/boxes is the way to go.
Proper sex toy hygiene is proven to prevent the transmission of bacterial infections and STIs and can also make all the difference in improving its longevity. Click here for more information on the best toy cleaning practices. [1]
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What lube to use with butt plugs?
Since the anus can’t self-lubricate, using lube for butt stuff is a must! But there is no one-size-fits-all. Instead, you’ll have to shop according to your toy’s unique material.
Metal and glass toys can be used with any of the three most popular kinds of lubricant; oil, water, and silicone-based. Silicone toys, however, are better suited for use with a water-based lubricant and should NEVER be used with silicone lube!
How to store a small beginner butt plug?
The storage process for any small anal plug is more-or-less the same; after a thorough cleanse, they can be stored in their own box or bag, separate from your other toys. Just make sure to keep yours somewhere where it won’t be lost! Read more on how to store your butt plug here.
How to insert a small butt plug?
When inserting your small plug, make sure to go at your own pace and prioritize relaxing your cheeks. It’s a good idea to use a gentle rocking motion back and forth with your fingers to ever-so-slowly insert your plug, all while taking deep breaths to help you move through possible discomfort.
Of course, if at any point the insertion process becomes painful instead of just uncomfortable, stop immediately and try using your fingers instead.
How to make a very small butt plug?
Unless you’re ready for a very awkward hospital visit to get your tiny plug unstuck from your butt, using a DIY toy in your tush is a no-go. However, if you’re in a pinch, the following guide will set you up with some tips on safe homemade plug use.
What to do if your butt plug is too small?
As your anal training progresses, or if you buy a small size and soon after realize that you could have done well with a size up, you have a few options, the most obvious being to purchase a plug with a larger diameter.
But if you want to make do with what you have, you also have the option to use your plug in tandem with a dildo for maximum filling or use it with a thrusting motion to increase sensation and intensity.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 7 Easy Sex Positions For Beginners You Should Try - May 3, 2024
- 10 Women On Top Sex Positions When You Want More Control - May 2, 2024
- 8 Sex Chair Positions You Should Check Out! - May 1, 2024
