Anyone taking their anal experience to the next level should consider buying inflatable butt plugs. After quick inflation, you’ll experience anal stimulation unlike anything you’ve experienced before. But which of the many models should I buy?
Whether a newbie or a seasoned professional, we recommend the Booty Call Inflatable Medium. It’s perfectly sized, designed to provide painless insertion, and sold at a price that won’t have you second-guessing your purchase.
Test Winner: Booty Call Inflatable
Booty Call Inflatable Medium got the highest rating in our review. Our testers loved the easy insertion (though best for intermediate users), the snug fit, the attractive pricing, and the safe quick-release valve. Discount code MSTG15 for 15% off!
For Beginners: Booty Call Small
Our testers agreed Booty Call’s smallest model was the most suitable for beginners. They highlighted the perfectly sized tip, safe quick-release valve, and affordable price tag, essential features for a beginner-friendly product.
Vibrating: Doc Johnson A-Play
Doc Johnson A-Play was the highest-rated vibrating model in our review. The testers loved the powerful vibrations, the comfortable T-base that allowed extensive wear, and the bulbous design that allowed for easy insertion.
Table Of Contents
- Why You Should Trust Us
- How We Picked The Products
- Everything We Tested
- 1. Booty Call Inflatable Medium: Our Test Winner!
- 2. Booty Call Small: Our Beginner Pick!
- 3. Doc Johnson A-Play: Great For Vibrations!
- 4. Lovehoney 4.5 Inch: Our Budget Pick!
- 5. Cock Locker Ace of Spades: Best For Size!
- Other Good Alternatives
- What Is An Inflatable Butt Plug?
- But Why Should I Buy One?
- How To Use An Inflatable Butt Plug?
- How To Clean An Inflatable Butt Plug?
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why You Should Trust Us
Rachel Sommer has been a sexologist on the My Sex Toy Guide team since its inception in 2016. During that time, she has spearheaded the creation of hundreds of product reviews and has personally tested dozens of sex toys, including inflatable butt plugs.
You can depend on Rachel and her team of experienced sexologists for up-to-date expertise on all things sex, including recommendations for the best inflatable anal sex toys on the market.
Rachel also loves hearing stories from my readers, so if you have questions, don’t hesitate to reach out. You can call her at +1 307-372-3895 or send an email to [email protected]—just make sure to include your name and contact information.
How We Picked The Products
Regarding butt plugs, those with inflate-ability tend to stand out among the competition. They have one of the more unique designs in anal toys and provide an equally exclusive sensation.
Due to the uniqueness of this toy and the higher potential for injury that it poses, my team and I used a vigorous testing process to ensure that we only included the highest-rated products in this review. I also defined several test criteria that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100:
- Material: We here at My Sex Toy Guide love recommending anal toys made from materials that are soft on the tush and built to withstand the test of time. For that reason, silicone toys will always clench the first-place title.
- Safety: A tapered tip and super-flared base are must-haves for all anal toys. In addition, they must have a quick-release valve so you can quickly deflate them.
- Size: Not everyone is a size queen. Because of that, we aim to provide various sizes to satisfy everyone, from anal newbies to more advanced users.
- Design: Using a well-designed plug can help make your experience more comfortable and safe. Minor details like a well-placed cord that stays put also contribute to a significantly better user experience.
- Ease of cleaning: Thoroughly cleaning your sex toys reduces the chances of bacterial infections. When choosing the inflatable plugs for this review, our team prioritized cleanability. [1]
- User feedback: When narrowing down our search, we gleaned online reviews to ensure we only worked with top-rated toys.
- Comfort: Painless use is a top priority for many people considering experimenting with anal play.
- Special Features: There’s no denying that inflatable butt plugs lack variability. To offer some variety, we sought review samples with wow factors like exceptional sizing or added vibrations.
During testing, we rated each test criterion on a percentage scale from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). We then calculated the overall score using different weighted metrics depending on the importance of the test criteria. Half the total rating comes from Design (25%) and Safety (25%). After that comes Comfort (10%), Material (10%), and Size (10%).
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| | |  |  |
|
| Name | Inflatable Medium | Small | A-Play | 4.5 Inch | Ace of Spades |
| Category | Best Overall | Beginner | Vibrating | Budget | Large |
| Average Rating | 96% | 95% | 93% | 92% | 90% |
| Design | 95% | 94% | 92% | 91% | 90% |
| Size | 96% | 92% | 92% | 91% | 98% |
| Safety | 94% | 94% | 91% | 90% | 89% |
| Ease of Cleaning | 93% | 92% | 89% | 92% | 86% |
| User Feedback | 92% | 93% | 94% | 91% | 90% |
| Comfort | 96% | 97% | 94% | 92% | 90% |
| Special Features | 95% | 95% | 93% | 89% | 88% |
| Price & Value | 95% | 96% | 90% | 97% | 93% |
| Price Tag | $39.99 | $32.99 | $99.99 | $24.99 | $59.99 |
| Material | Silicone | Silicone | Silicone | Plastic | Latex |
| Length | 4.5 inches | 4 inches | 5 inches | 4.5 inches | 8 inches |
| Color | Black | Black | Blue | Black | Black |
1. Booty Call Inflatable Medium: Our Test Winner!
Why we love Booty Call Inflatable Medium:
If you’re looking for a blow-up butt plug, there’s no denying that the Booty Call Inflatable Medium is a butt stuff crowd-pleaser. This modestly-sized plug begins small enough to be used by anal newbies and expands to please even the pickiest size queens.
Like all Lovehoney products, the Booty Call arrived promptly and in discreet packaging that won’t leave the neighbors wondering. This toy wasn’t made to be aesthetically pleasing but unboxing it excited me nonetheless.
I decided to stick to solo play my first time testing out the toy, and after applying a generous amount of lube, I found that the insertion process was more or less painless, thanks to the super-tapered tip.
After a few pumps, it was easy to understand why Booty Call is beloved by so many. The filling sensation was absolutely delectable, and working with the quick-release valve, I found it super easy to find my perfect fullness.
Minor issues found during testing:
My biggest complaint with the Booty Call was the choice to attach the tube to the bottom instead of the base – mostly because I don’t plan to use the suction cup bottom. The cord positioning kept me from enjoying the full 4.5-inch insertable length.
Aside from that, I felt that the tube could have benefitted from being a tad longer and less rigid, but overall, I didn’t find that either of those factors greatly impacted my experience.
Why Booty Call Inflatable Medium is the best inflatable butt plug:
The Booty Call Inflatable Medium was our tester’s top pick for this product review, with a final grade of 96%. Some of the criteria that made it stand out were:
- Design: From the moment this toy graces your tush, it’s obvious that the creators got the parameters just right. The seamless entry was pain-free, and the snug fit prevented our panel from worrying about it popping out after being pumped up. Some of our reviewers also enjoyed using it as a vaginal toy (after being washed, of course.)
- Price & Value: Although the Booty Call Inflatable isn’t our budget pick, it’s still one of the most budget-friendly options, costing only $39.99. At this price, there’s no reason not to give it a try.
- Material: Anything silicone will be given bonus points by our testers. Silicone is non-porous, phthalate-free, and durable, making toys exceptionally easy to keep clean.
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Length: 4.5”
- Color: Black
- Mechanism: Hand-pump with a quick-release valve
- Circumference: 4.5” to 8.5”
Pros:
- Budget-friendly pick
- Suction cup bottom for steady play.
- The tube is long enough for solo play.
- The expanding anal plug is made from high-quality silicone.
- The plug material has perfect rigidity.
Cons:
- You can’t fully insert the toy because of the tube on the side.
- The tubing is a little stiff.
- The cord doesn’t detach from the pump-up butt plug.
2. Booty Call Small: Our Beginner Pick!
Why we love Booty Call Small:
Ready to expand your anal horizons? Then the Booty Call Small is for you! This bad boy is the perfect starting size for anal newcomers and can stretch out the anal cavity of anyone wanting to prepare their tush for anal sex.
Our testers felt that Lovehoney did a wonderful job packaging the small inflatable butt plug and turned a potentially underwhelming unboxing experience of a plain black silicone toy into something to remember.
When deflated, the super-tapered tip on the body (which I generously slathered with lube) went in without a hitch. The attached pump made for quick inflation, and I loved that the quick-release valve was so easy to access and deflated it so quickly. It added extra peace of mind to a potentially nerve-wracking first experience with an inflatable anal toy.
A thoughtful design feature of this plug was the decision not to have the stem/base of this plug inflate. Our less experienced test members agreed that it made the plug feel more secure once inflated and, sensation-wise allowed for a more beginner-friendly intensity – especially during extended use.
Minor issues found during testing:
As with the Booty Call Inflatable Medium, the main concern of our panel members was related to the placement of the tube. Many would have preferred it to be placed on the bottom instead of the center of the base.
Another helpful feature related to the cord would have been detachability, making Booty Call Inflatable Medium usable for public play. The small body size also makes this toy more difficult to clean. You need to take care to hit all the tiny cracks and crevices.
Why Booty Call Small is the most beginner-friendly:
Voting the Booty Call Small as the most beginner-friendly inflatable butt plug was an easy choice, and we made our decision based on the following key decision-making factors:
- Price & Value: There’s no doubt that you’ll fall in love with your inflatable plug. But for anyone considering purchasing a new toy, our team recommends starting with a budget-friendly option, just in case. At $32.99, we’re sure you won’t experience buyer remorse.
- Size: When it comes to inflatable butt plugs on the market, you‘ll be hard-pressed to find something with a smaller body size than the Booty Call Small.
- Comfort: The comfort level of this pumping butt plug, which our entire team rated at 97%, sold this toy as the beginner-friendly choice for this review. Our panel members loved the perfectly pointy tip, which made the insertion and removal process the most comfortable. Although a minor detail, they also appreciated that the stem didn’t inflate.
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Length: 4”
- Color: Black
- Mechanism: Hand-pump with a quick-release valve
- Circumference: 4.3” – 8.25”
Pros:
- Budget-friendly option ($32.99.)
- Perfect size for beginners.
- It’s made from high-quality silicone.
- The suction cup base allows for easier solo play.
Cons:
- The cord doesn’t detach from the plug.
- The recessed area can be difficult to clean.
- Cord placement makes it difficult to insert the toy fully.
3. Doc Johnson A-Play: Great For Vibrations!
Why we love Doc Johnson A-Play:
Some people believe that no sex toy is complete without vibrations strong enough to make their toes curl, and we couldn’t agree more! Which is why we love the Doc Johnson A-Play.
The A-Play allows you to combine the filling pleasure of inflatable plugs with the buzzy sensation of your favorite vibrator. The unique combination was completely new to most of our reviewers, but it didn’t take long for them to fall in love with the extraordinary blend.
Unlike most products on this list, the only part of the Doc Johnson A-Play that inflates is the tip, which, combined with the lengthy body, creates a filling sensation deep within the anal cavity. A feature that our test panel members with prostates couldn’t get enough of.
You can use the remote control to cycle through the 12 size options and 10 vibration settings, independent of one another. As you would expect from one of the highest-rated inflatable butt plugs, both the remote control and body are completely waterproof, allowing for easy clean-up or some extra slippery fun.
After 40 minutes of continuous run time, simply plug it in via the USB charging cable and get ready for round 2!
Minor issues we found during testing
Our panel members had no real issues with the Doc Johson A-play, though they had a few minor grievances.
Most of our testers felt that the vibrations, which are spread throughout the entire body of the toy, would have been better targeted in the inflatable tip. Our prostate-endowed testers felt this change would have made p-stimulation more intense and easy to feel.
The other minor flaw our testers had was around the placement of the buttons. Although you can use the remote control to adjust the settings, there are also buttons located on the bottom. When using the toy seated, it’s easy to accidentally switch gears.
Why Doc Johnson A-Play is our favorite for vibrations:
- Design: Things like a T-bar base for added comfort during extended wear, a bulbous design that allows easy insertion and a delightful filling sensation, and USB rechargeability set this remote-controlled inflatable butt plug apart from the competition. The design was the selling feature with our panel members giving it a 92 average rating in this critical category. (More on long-wear butt plug products in this article.)
- Special Features: The choice to have only the tip inflate was a unique design feature among the dozens of silicone toys we tested. We also loved that the wide variety of vibration and inflation settings operated independently and could be controlled via remote control.
- Ease of Cleaning: The Doc Johnson A-Play was the easiest toy to thoroughly clean, with no nooks and crannies and a completely waterproof body.
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Length: 5”
- Color: Blue
- Mechanism: Remote-controlled vibrations and inflation
- Circumference: 4.75”
Pros:
- Remote-controlled for hands-free fun.
- A-Play is made from body-safe silicone.
- Extra-long body for easier prostate stimulation.
- Body size is ideal for all experience levels.
Cons:
- Buttons placed on the bottom were easy to press.
- The entire length vibrates instead of just the tip.
4. Lovehoney 4.5 Inch: Our Budget Pick!
Why we love Lovehoney 4.5 Inch
If you love the classic design but don’t want to sacrifice vibrations, the Lovehoney 4.5-inch is your best bet. Although it might not offer the same aesthetic appeal as the Doc Johnson A-Play, it includes all the features you need to get the job done.
First, this vibrating inflatable plug features a hard plastic core, perfect for keeping the tapered tip rigid during insertion, so minimal effort is required to get the plug in place. Once fully inserted, the nicely flared base allows stress-free stretching of your tush, perfect for inflatable butt plug training.
In addition, the vibration speeds on the Lovehoney 4.5 Inch are controlled via a wired scroll wheel remote control, which I had no trouble getting the hang of. I loved handing the attached pump and remote to my partner for hands-free fun, though longer cord lengths and combining the two wires would make for a better user experience.
In terms of size, it’s a little large for inexperienced butt-play enthusiasts, though you might be in luck with enough lube and patience. Although this anal plug doesn’t boast the longest total length, our panel members with prostates found it did a great job stimulating their p-spot.
For only $24.99, this is one of the top products for anyone shopping on a budget.
Minor issues we found during testing
When purchasing a low-cost product, you have to accept that it won’t come equipped with all the bells and whistles you might expect from something in a higher pay grade, and certain details make it obvious that this is a less expensive toy.
This biggest letdown is that the plug connecting the plug to the pump is held in place with friction and not a proper clip. Especially after pumping up the toy, the cord easily detaches. When that happens, you have to re-inflate the plug starting from square one, which is frustrating after you’ve found the perfect fullness.
I also would have preferred a silicone body since it’s less porous and safe for everyone, even folks with a latex allergy.
Why Lovehoney 4.5 Inch is our budget pick:
When deciding on our budget pick, we looked at more than just the price tag. More important than cost is the value of a product when considering its price against the level of quality and unique features.
- Price & Value: Our panel members couldn’t believe how many features this inexpensive product had packed into it, which sealed an average score of 97%. A basic inflatable plug for its price is already a steal, and the vibrations and remote control were the cherry on top.
- Design: So many tiny details made using the Lovehoney 4.5 Inch an absolute pleasure. Things like a rigid core and super tapered tip for easy insertion, a larger body size to hit all the right spots, and a remote to control the vibrations set this one apart from the other budget-friendly products we reviewed.
Features:
- Material: Soft plastic
- Length: 4.5”
- Color: Black
- Mechanism: Wired remote-controlled vibrations and hand pump
- Circumference: 5” – 9”
Pros:
- Super budget-friendly ($24.99.)
- Remote-controlled for hands-free fun.
- The body is well-sized for prostate stimulation.
- A rigid center makes for easy insertion.
Cons:
- It’s made from latex instead of silicone, so people with latex allergies must stay away.
- Slightly too large for beginners.
- The cord detaches easily from the body.
5. Cock Locker Ace of Spades: Best For Size!
Why we love Cock Locker Ace of Spades:
This next plug is for all the size kings and queens out there! It doesn’t get much bigger than the Cock Locker Ace of Spades, and this super-sized plug is sure to test all your limits.
Despite being selected for its size, some of our testers – myself included, were still surprised by how big it is! Some colleagues even went as far as to label it “anal Mount Everest”!
Unboxing this massive toy felt like an initiation. After taking it out of the discreet packaging that Lovehoney is so famous for, I couldn’t believe the plug was even larger than the palm of my hand.
Needless to say, this pick is better suited for well-experienced anal players and not ideal as a beginner inflatable plug.
Using the huge inflatable butt plug takes some finesse, as the toy lacks a solid core to help with insertion. Because of this, the recommended strategy for inserting Ace of Spades is by folding or rolling it before inserting it, and, likely, you won’t get it on the first try.
It takes some time for the plug to fully inflate, with most of our reviewers recommending that you give it a solid 20+ pumps before expecting it to take shape. Our panel members loved that despite being latex, the Cock Locker didn’t smell like rubber, especially after the first wash.
Overall, this toy was a definite test for our panel members. But those of us up for the challenge absolutely loved playing with this toy, both solo and after handing the hand-sized pump over to our partners.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Because Ace of Spades has no core, there is a learning curve to figuring out how to insert it. The first time you use it, it can be frustrating trying to roll or fold it to get it inside your tush, which is a bit of a mood killer if you’re using it with someone else.
Our panel members also thought the creators would have been smart to fit it with a simple plastic release valve. Instead, the metal valve needs to be screwed/unscrewed to open and close the valve, which can get tricky with the amount of lube needed to insert this big toy. Not the safest solution!
Why Cock Locker Ace of Spades is the biggest inflatable butt plug:
- Size: There’s no denying that the sheer size attracts most buyers. The girth and length earned a 98% average score from our reviewers.
- Build Quality: Because Ace of Spades was created to be pumped to the max, making it out of super-stretchy high-quality material was a must. Although I’m a big fan of silicone, using latex for the Cocker Locker was a no-brainer that allowed it to expand without the possibility of popping. But please note that the safety mechanism is not 100%, which makes this product even less beginner-friendly.
Features:
- Material: Latex
- Length: 8”
- Color: Black
- Mechanism: Hand-pump with a quick-release valve
- Circumference: 20”
Pros:
- It’s made from high-quality latex.
- Very durable.
- Easy to clean.
- It stimulates the ultimate orgasms.
- It blows up to a massive 20”.
Cons:
- Not beginner-friendly.
- Folks can’t use it with an allergy to latex.
- Hard to insert initially.
Other Good Alternatives
Cock Locker Inflatable Penis has a natural phallic shape, even after being blown up. The testers found the longer shape of this toy more filling than other inflatable plugs, which tend to take on more of a rounded balloon shape. We also liked that it offers a simple design: a hand pump to inflate the toy and an easy-to-use screw valve for deflation. Our panel appreciated the super-flared base, which provides peace of mind, even when the plug is at its girthy, fully-inflated 12” circumference.
Nexus Bolster is a super quiet, vibrating, inflatable anal sex toy for precise prostate stimulation. It’s perfectly sized for folks that aren’t completely new to anal play, though anal newcomers can probably manage the bulbous shape with enough lube and some time to work it in. This diverse plug offers three vibration speeds and vibration patterns to choose from, and its inflatable tip is gently curved to hit all the right spots. The remote control pairs easily to the toy, and our panel members loved that the remote and plug are USB-rechargeable.
What Is An Inflatable Butt Plug?
An inflatable butt plug is a sex toy made from malleable plastic and attached to either a hand pump or an electronic interface that allows you to adjust the plug size to enjoy a fuller sensation during anal play.
But Why Should I Buy One?
Inflatable anal toys offer various features that you won’t be able to find in their single-sized counterparts.
For beginners, inflatable plugs offer a filling sensation that regular butt plugs can’t replicate. They also have the potential to stimulate more nerves – including the prostate, providing a more pleasurable experience for whoever is lucky enough to use one.
Kinkier folks might also enjoy the power dynamic of allowing their play partner to decide how large the toy in their bum can get or find that it greatly expands their role-play repertoire.
How To Use An Inflatable Butt Plug?
Start by securely fastening the cord that connects the plug and the pump to avoid an anti-climatic finish. After deflating the toy completely and applying a generous amount of lube, insert the tip into the anal opening, followed by the rest of the body, slowly and gently.
The fun begins when you feel the toy is fully inserted with no possibility of slipping out! Use the pump to gently inflate your toy, and see how long you can last before the grand finale. Please note that if you feel discomfort or any pain, immediately deflate the toy!
For more information on maximizing the potential pleasure of your favorite anal toys, check out our extensive butt plug guide.
How To Clean An Inflatable Butt Plug?
Simply use warm water and mild soap to wash the exterior body completely. After allowing it to dry, store it in a safe place like your bedside table.
For a more detailed explanation of cleaning your sex toys, try our comprehensive how-to sex toy cleaning guide.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How do inflatable butt plugs work?
Inflatable butt plugs will usually be attached via a cord to a pump that you can use to adjust the plug size after you’ve inserted it. Most inflatable plugs also feature a quick-release valve that you can use to quickly deflate the toy if necessary.
Why do inflatable butt plugs feel good?
Not everyone will enjoy the sensation of inflatable butt plugs but those that do might find that the stretching sensation provided stimulates more nerve endings in the anus. They also create a sense of pressure and fullness that other anal toys can’t replicate.
How to store an inflatable butt plug?
Once your pump butt plug is clean, dry, and stored in its own box or case, please keep it in a safe place like your bedside table or closet.
How to use inflatable butt plugs with a partner?
The ideal way to use inflatable butt plugs is with a partner. After deciding on the ground rules (consent, safe word, etc.), hand the pump or remote control to your partner for hands-free fun.
How big does an inflatable butt plug expand to?
The maximum size of each inflatable plug varies, with some models expanding to a whopping 12-inch circumference.
What does an inflatable butt plug feel like?
The best way to describe the sensation of inflatable butt plugs is utter fullness. This fullness is great for stimulating the many nerve endings in the anus and can even enhance the sensitivity of the clitoris or penis. [2]
How to insert an inflatable butt plug?
The best way to insert inflatable butt plugs is to ensure it’s fully deflated, use a generous amount of water-based lube, and slowly and gently insert the toy to prevent discomfort.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 10 Women On Top Sex Positions When You Want More Control - May 2, 2024
- 8 Sex Chair Positions You Should Check Out! - May 1, 2024
- 8 Best Missionary Sex Positions To Spice Up The Old Classic - April 29, 2024
