9 Best Dildo Gags In 2024, Reviewed by a BDSM Educator

Hands down (or mouth open) the highest-rated dildo gag we have tested is Lovehoney’s Zado Leather Mouth Gag. An example of expert BDSM craftsmanship paired with extremely high-quality materials and superior design, it’s astonishingly safe, not to mention impressively versatile. Whether you’re an experienced kinkster or novice, you’ll enjoy this all-around fine device.

Why You Should Trust Us

Hi, I am M.Christian. From my first introduction to a kink in 1988 to where I am today—a respected erotica author, sex tech journalist, and sex educator—I’ve loved exploring the wide and, more than anything, wild world of sexual pleasure.

No less having the opportunity to use my extensive experience, in conjunction with my team of product testers, to put together this guide about this year’s best dildo gags.

I also love hearing stories from my readers, so if you have questions, don’t hesitate to reach out. You can call me at +1 307-372-3895 or send an email to [email protected]—just make sure to include your name and contact information.

How We Picked The Products

Selecting a good penis gag is tough, but picking nine great ones is far more challenging.

Luck would have it, I’ve developed tried-and-true test criteria that we could measure using well-defined quantitative metrics. They made my selection process far easier, so much so that I’ve also used it for most, if not all, of the other guides I’ve written for My Sex Toy Guide.

• Manufacture: The first (and most important) is to make sure it’s expertly made and as safe as possible. For this, we ensured all review samples were made and sold by BDSM community-approved companies like Lovehoney, The Stockroom, and Extreme Restraints.
• Material: The next thing is if it’s crafted from premium quality leather, metal, rubber, hard plastic, silicone, or other materials. I do so because BDSM gear made from less-than-good materials tends to be less durable or possibly even unsafe.
• Design: Creating a pleasurable, comfortable, low-risk product requires a lot of skill, experience, and hands-on testing. All of which and more kink-community-recommended manufacturers such as The Stockroom, Extreme Restraints, and Lovehoney put into everything they make.
• Safety: More than anything else, for a dildo gag toy to make it onto this list, it must be designed and built to be as safe as possible. Because a gag with even a regular dildo may restrict the person using it from breathing or cause gagging, it must be able to be removed as fast as possible. Safety is another reason experienced BDSM enthusiasts shop at scene-recommended companies because they know safety is their top priority.
• Versatility: Finally, I like to give extra credit to multipurpose dildo gags, particularly for kink novices, because, with one, they can try out a wide variety of BDSM activities without needing to buy a bunch of different devices.

After using my criteria to narrow them down to fifteen candidates, I sent them over to my team of toy testers. Using their feedback, I got that number down to ten possible contenders.

During testing, we rated each test criterion on a percentage scale from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). We then calculated the overall score using different weighted metrics depending on the importance of the test criteria. Half the total rating comes from Safety (25%) and Design (25%). After that comes Manufacture (10%), Material (10%), and Versatility (10%).

My next step was to see what a few carefully selected BDSM experts and respected sexologists thought of them. The final thing I did was to see what the Internet thought, particularly reviews from customers who bought and played with the test samples. When the dust settled, I was left with this list of the nine most effective dildo gags.

Everything We Tested

In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.

Name	Zado's	Bondage Boutique's	Scott Paul	In And Out Gag
Category	Best Overall	Budget	Experienced	Double
Average Rating	95%	93%	94%	92%
Design	95%	94%	92%	91%
Versatility	95%	90%	91%	96%
Safety	93%	93%	88%	94%
Manufacture	92%	92%	92%	93%
Material	96%	95%	90%	91%
Price & Value	95%	96%	92%	94%
Price Tag	$74.99	$42.99	$178	$85
Material	Leather, Steel & Latex	Leather, Silicone & Metal	Steel, Neoprene & Leather	Leather, Silicone & Metal
Circumference	4.5 inches	5.5 inches	N/A	2 inches
Insertable Length	8.5 inches	5 inches	N/A	6 inches

1. Zado’s Leather Mouth Gag: Overall Test Winner!

Why I Love Zado’s Leather Mouth Gag:

At the top of my list of the highest quality, most enjoyable, and totally fun dildo gag is Zado’s from Lovehoney.

As I said, it’s a phenomenally well-crafted natural leather gag featuring stylish chromed steel fittings with the dildo portion made of high-quality latex. Put all this together, and it’s an impressive versatile toy suited for nearly every BDSM play style imaginable.

I especially like how quick and easy it is to reverse the dildo part. It lets the wearer enjoy its comfortable three-inch length or go for the whole five-and-a-half-inch deep throat experience whenever or however they want.

Add that it also has fully adjustable straps, compliments of its leather straps, and Zado is a and must-have for everyone who’s even the slightest bit kinky.

Minor Issues I Found During Testing:

My testers and I spent a lot of time trying to find something, anything we didn’t like about this long dildo gag.

Not a complaint about it as much as what you might want to consider when shopping for a dildo gag; we thought it could do with a quick-release mechanism. Our reasoning is that a large reason why dildo masks are so exciting is how confined they make the wearer feel; they must be made to come off as fast as possible in case of emergency.

Still, Zado is so well made and excellently designed it doesn’t need to be unbuckled to be removed in less than a second—which reinforces why I’ve chosen it as our test winner.

Why Zado’s Leather Is The Best Dildo Gag:

Lovehoney and Zado have more than outdone themselves by bringing us this premium quality leather, steel, and latex double-sided dildo mask.

From its comfortable and exciting five-and-a-half dildo part to its three-inch one at the other, no less its secure and stylish buckled leather strap, it does everything a good dildo mask should but better.

More impressively, there’s even more to like about this wonder of BDSM craftsmanship and kink engineering:

• Manufacture: It takes a tremendous amount of skill and a mind-bogglingly number of years to make a dildo mask as excellent as Zado’s Leather Mouth Gag. Deceptively simple yet mouth-wateringly exciting, it’s sturdy enough to handle everything yet comfortable in all the right ways.
• Material: Made from fine-grade leather, chromed steel, and medical-grade latex, Zado is well worth its $74.99 price tag. Unlike some BDSM toys, the minute you hold it in your hand, let alone play with it, you’ll understand why it’s well worth every penny you spend on it.
• Design: The BDSM community knows an expertly designed toy when they see it and especially use it—which is why Lovehoney and Zado are so well respected by kinksters from San Francisco to Paris.
• Safety: Though Zado  might appear intimidating, it’s also carefully engineered to be as safe as possible. Don’t let its gleaming metal studs and buckle fool you because you can remove it faster than a bratty sub can signal, “I need to get out of this.”

Features:

• Material: Leather, Steel, Latex.
• Measurements: The Double-Sided Latex Dildo Is 5″ On One Side And 3″ On The Other. It Has A 3″ In Diameter Canal And An Overall Circumference Of 4.5″. The Harness Is Adjustable Up To 28″. The Total Length Is 8.5″.
• Colors: Black And Silver

Pros:

• It’s a brilliantly designed, wonderfully exciting, and impressively versatile dildo gag.
• Its double-sided latex dildo is ideally suited for a wide range of scenes and playstyles.
• In an emergency, it can be removed quickly and easily.

Cons:

• It could do with an emergency release mechanism, though it also can be taken off at a moment’s notice.

View On Lovehoney

2. Bondage Boutique’s Silicone Gag: Budget Pick

Why I Love Bondage Boutique’s Silicone Ball Gag:

If you want a thoroughly excellent dildo mask that won’t hit your wallet too hard, look no further than this fantastic and affordable one from Bondage Boutique.

Made from supple leather and premium quality silicone, and with a durable steel buckle and metal studs, it’d be a great choice at twice the price. But considering it’ll set you back $42.99, there’s no reason not to get your hands on one of these attached dildo gags as fast as possible.

Minor Issues I Found During Testing:

You’d think a low-cost model would have more than a few less-that-great things about it. But proving Bondage Boutique has truly outdone itself by crafting a comfortable, stylish, and overall low cost.

Though I do have to say I wish Bondage Boutique’s Silicone Gag buckle had a quick-release valve. Still, it can easily be slipped off quickly in an emergency.

Why Bondage Boutique Is Our Budget Pick:

Never in a million years would I think you could have a high quality, perfectly designed, and such fun dildo mask for as little as $42.99. But that’s precisely what Bondage Boutique has given us with their double-sided, leather internal dildo gag. I am such a fan of this affordable but not cheap BDSM gear; I feel every kinkster worth their leather chaps should, if not must, get one.

But there’s more to like, love, and lust after this exciting product:

• Material: Never ones to scrimp when it comes to making superior-quality toys and BDSM equipment, Bondage Boutique went the extra mile when making their Silicone Gag. The leather is strong but pleasantly luxurious, the interior dildo is strong yet arousingly smooth, and its metalwork can take a beating while staying comfortable and attractive.
• Design: While it may, at first, appear simple, Bondage Boutique is an excellent example of sophisticated and thoughtful BDSM craftsmanship. Something that again makes it a great option for budget-minded kinksters.

Features:

• Material: Leather, Body-safe Silicone, Metal
• Measurements: The Dildo Has An Insertable Length Of 5″. The Entire Length Is 21.5″.
• Colors: Black And Silver

Pros:

• It’s an amazingly well-made penis ball gag made all the better by its low cost.
• It’s made from high-level materials such as fine leather, medical-grade silicone, and polished metal.
• It’d be a welcome addition to every kinkster’s BDSM toy collection, from novices to experienced players.

Cons:

• It lacks a quick-release safety mechanism.
• A few people may not enjoy playing with a double-ended dildo.

View On Lovehoney

3. Scott Paul Designs’ Humiliator Gag: For Experienced Players

Why I Love Scott Paul Designs’ Humiliator Gag:

If you’re a BDSM enthusiast who’s seen, done, and enjoyed everything and is looking for something new or more intense, I have good news for you. Compliments of The Stockroom, Scott Paul Designs’ Humiliator Gag could be the ultra-edgy, wildly hot toy you’ve been waiting for.

Sometimes called the “How may I help you?” gag due to its multipurpose front attachment point, which can be equipped with anything from a toilet paper roll to a feather duster, it’s every humiliation player’s dream come true.

Because The Stockroom makes it, this one may look brutally intense, but a tremendous amount of care and craftsmanship made it as exciting as it is comfortable and safe.

Minor Issues I Found During Testing:

When all is said and done, I suppose I could say Scott Paul Designs’ Humiliator isn’t as easy to use as other products on this list. But that’s also a huge reason for its erotic appeal—and a no-brainer purchase for experienced bondage players.

Why Scott Paul Designs’ Humiliator Gag Is Great For Advanced Players:

Having been around the kinky block more than a few times, without a doubt, I can say this brilliantly designed and masterfully crafted penis ball gag will fire up even the most experienced BDSM players.

Its front attachment point opens up a sexy world of possibilities and practically begs whoever owns or plays with it to think up new and wildly more intense uses for it. One tester described it as the Swiss Army Knife of kink and a guaranteed good time for submissives and those who like to play with attached dildo toys.

• Manufacture: The Stockroom is right on the money when they say it’ll last a lifetime. Between their world-famous craftsmanship and using ultra-high quality leather, metal, and neoprene, this penis ball gag will be putting smiles on your and your partner’s faces for decades.
• Design: Say what you want about Scott Paul, but when it comes to envisioning the most outrageous, exciting, and mind-bogglingly intense dildo-attached BDSM roleplay toys, no one does it better.

Features:

• Material: Steel, Neoprene, Leather
• Colors: Black And Silver

Pros:

• It’s a wickedly intense and extremely exciting multipurpose dildo gag.
• Nothing tops the Humiliator regarding the variety of unique uses it can be used for.
• It’s such an impressively sturdy and masterfully crafted penis ball gag it can be used and enjoyed for decades.

Cons:

• Some kinksters may feel the Humiliator will be too much for them to handle. It also may be too tight around their mouth which may cause gagging.

View On Stockroom

4. The Stockroom’s In And Out: Double Dildo Gag

Why I Love The Stockroom’s In And Out Gag:

Another awesomely kinky toy from the steamy minds at The Stockroom, their In And Out Gag with removable dildo, takes the prize for the highest-rated double-ended penis gag I’ve had the pleasure of playing with.

Only The Stockroom could have made such an elegant, versatile, arousing, pleasurable product. If you like having sexual options, like having it with or without a double-sided external dildo, this toy will make your day, as it’s a snap to fit one to this gag or take it off.

Minor Issues I Found During Testing:

Not that The Stockroom’s In And Out isn’t worth paying $85 for, as it certainly is and then some, but most kinksters may feel that’s a bit too much to spend on a gag—even one as finely made and versatile as this mouth toy.

Why The Stockroom’s In And Out Is The Best Double Dildo Gag:

Quality through and through and meticulously designed to balance form and function effectively, The Stockroom’s In And Out sets a new gold standard for BDSM toys. It’s elegant without being simplistic, comfortable while staying arousingly intense, and sure to get your kinky motor going like nothing else.

• Manufacture: The Stockroom is at it again, using everything they know about making fine bondage equipment to give us this lovely and exciting double-dildo gag. Please take my word for it when I say it’ll quickly become your favorite bae and will have you or your submissive begging to use it.
• Versatility: The Stockroom’s In And Out Mouth is more fun than a barrel of kinky monkeys. Do you want something without a dildo? The answer is quick and easy: take its double-sided, external dildo out, and there you go. The same is true for everything else you may want to do, as this beat can do it all and more.

Features:

• Material: Leather, Metal, Silicone
• Measurements: The External Dildo Is 2″ Wide With A Maximum Insertable Length Of 6″. Its Leather Strap is Adjustable From 10″ – 23″.
• Colors: Black, Silver, Beige

Pros:

• Its external dildo is available in either black or beige
• Its leather straps are adjustable and can easily fit more people’s heads comfortably.
• It’s a wonderfully versatile dildo gag.

Cons:

• Its high sticker price places it beyond the budgets of many kinksters.

View On Stockroom

Other Good Alternatives

The Stockroom’s Locking Ball Gag The perfect harness will always be this astonishing fun penis gag from The Stockroom. It is carefully designed to comfortably fit most people’s mouths and features a heavy steel buckle; an exciting combination of restraint and BDSM play equipment.

Bondage Boutique Inflatable Dildo Gag has its own squeeze bulb for quick and easy inflating of its rubber mouth bulb. All it takes is a little pressure to fill the user’s mouth, and deflating this inflatable dildo gag is just as easy and quick. A balance between safety and excitement firmly places Bondage Boutique as the top inflatable dildo gag on my list.

The Stockroom’s Trainer Ball Gag is what every novice kinkster should buy to help them learn all about the nearly infinite pleasures of dildo gag-wearing. Even if you know all about bondage and penis gags, its brilliant design and fine craftsmanship make it more than worth adding to your playtime activities.

Bondage Boutique’s Silicone Gag When size matters because, let’s face it, when you want to be filled, nothing tops a 5″ long, 5.5″ in circumference penis. Size queens and pleasure-providing submissives will find themselves exciting planting at the thought of using or being used by this bigger-than-life model with a dildo. One of the larger dildos I’ve seen, this large gag will double your pleasure and triple your fun.

Extreme Restraints Mouth-Full Dildo Face Mask is a unique and thrilling new take on classic gags. Fully covering the sub’s mouth while supporting a nearly three-inch internal dildo, it’s great for public or private BDSM play scenes or for anyone interested in a different style of dildo gag.

What Is A Dildo Gag?

A dildo gag is a piece of BDSM face mask equipped with a sex toy, allowing the user to penetrate their partner. Some ball gags are double-sided, so the wearer and whoever they’re playing with can experience oral pleasure. An inflatable dildo gag is made to fill the wearer’s mouth.

They are sometimes also made to accommodate other features or sex toys like BDSM blindfolds, d ring attachment points, and more. Leather, faux leather, latex, hard rubber, steel, and silicone are just some of the materials they can be made from.

How To Use A Dildo Gag?

Most gags can occasionally limit the wearer from breathing freely, so you must be extra careful when playing with them. It all starts with communication, as in spending considerable time discussing what you’d like to do, might be open to trying, and what must never occur with your partner. It’s also when a safe word or words should be set up, emergency procedures established, and mutual consent given and received.

A major problem with ball gags and safe words is they are sometimes designed to make saying anything difficult, let alone for the gagged person to speak in moans. To ensure the person wearing it can communicate with their partner, I recommend holding something small on one or both hands (AKA safety signal). That way, should something go wrong, or they just want to take a breath, they can drop whatever they’re holding as a signal to their partner.

Even so, it’s a good idea to routinely check with whoever’s wearing a gag with a dildo to ensure their breathing hasn’t been affected or in distress. If they are, remove the ball gag immediately, and if necessary, call emergency services. Remember, in a BDSM emergency, seconds count, so never hesitate to call for help. It’s also why always having your phone ready is a great idea.

On a side note, you should never leave a partner unattended, even for just a second or two, because that’s all it takes for a scene to go from bad to possibly life-threatening. To avoid something severe from happening, we would suggest using BDSM masks or BDSM hoods instead, as they are much safer options but still give you that BDSM excitement.

How To Clean a Dildo Gag?

Do not attempt to clean a ball gag without consulting the manufacturer’s recommended instructions. Failure to do so may damage it or even negatively affect the health of the next person unlucky enough to wear it.

Sometimes a company’s site may not provide easy cleaning instructions. If this is the case with your rubber ball gag, contact them directly before washing or maintaining it yourself. Only if you cannot find anything anywhere about cleaning yours should you think about trying to do it on your own.

If you do, never apply too much water, mild soap, sex toy cleaner, or anything else, and instead, use as little as possible. For faux leather, latex, hard rubber, or silicone dildos use warm water and a small amount of antibacterial solution or toy cleaning solution, rinse, and dry thoroughly.

Leather dildo gags require extra care, but a little water, vinegar, or oil is often recommended. You can read more on how to clean your dildo gag in this guide.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How Does A Dildo Gag Work?

Dildo gags are designed to enable the wearer to sexually pleasure another person by using a penetrative sex toy fitted over or sometimes into their mouth. They may or may not be designed to work with blindfolds, ear muffs, or other gag bondage-related accessories. [2]

Sometimes the user will need to suppress their gag reflex, as in when performing deep throat, to use most dildo gags. They are sometimes made with a velcro fastening strap for a flexible fit and maximum comfort. Not everyone may like velcro fastening dildo masks, as they may sometimes come loose.

What Does A Dildo Gag Look Like?

Dildo gags resemble a piece of mouth or head bondage equipment fitted with a penetrative sex toy. Some even come with a second toy, so while the wearer is using the first on their partner, they can also experience receiving oral sex at the same time. [3]

Related: 8 Best Face Dildos, Tested & Ranked by a Sexologist!

How To Properly Wear A Dildo Gag

The correct way to use a dildo mouth gag is first to ensure the wearer can breathe easily and, if necessary, can remove it quickly. [2]

Secondly, dildo gags must be positioned so that when used for penetration play, they won’t shift or move in any way that might impair the wearer’s ability to breathe. But while this is important, do not over-tighten as it can be painful to the wearer.

Are Dildo Gags Safe?

Yes. When worn and used correctly, dildo gags is safe to use and play with [1]. However, as there’s always at least some risk the wearer might be injured, they and their partner must take every possible precaution to play safely. If that makes you a wee bit nervous, you can perhaps start with an easier option such as ring gags.

How To Store A Dildo Gag

The proper method for storing a dildo mouth gag depends on its design and what it’s made from. Rubber, latex, or silicone dildos should avoid excessive heat or direct sunlight. Those made from leather or other natural materials should also be stored in a dry, cool place where they won’t get wet.

You can read more about storing sex toys in this guide.

How To Make A Dildo Gag

Do not, under any circumstances, ever attempt to make a ball gag with dildo. Though they may look deceptively simple to make, in reality, it requires an extensive amount of experience and years of training to create BDSM gear that’s safe to use.

What Size Dildo Gag Should I Buy?

Before purchasing a mouth gag dildo, you should measure the head of the person wearing it. To guarantee a comfortable fit, always choose a fully adjustable model and not a one-size-fits-all.

What Is The Best Material For A Dildo Gag?

There isn’t a perfect material a deluxe ball gag should be made from, as while you may like leather, someone else may prefer silicone or rubber. Discuss what kind you want, or listen to your partner if they will be wearing it, and armed with this information, go out and find your ideal model.

You can find more information on what’s sex toy materials in this article.

Primary Sources

1. Lascivity. A Primer on the Safe Use of Gags in BDSM (January 2023)

2. Demasquemagazine. A Guide To Gags

3. Cosmopolitan. Your Everything-to-Know Guide to Ball Gags (January 2021)

M.Christian

• Author
• Recent Posts

M.Christian

M.Christian loves nothing better than exploring the intersections of sex and technology. They regularly appear on sites like Kinkly, Tickle.Life, Sexpert, Queer Majority, Killing Kittens, Sex for Every Body, Future of Sex, and dozens more on topics like BDSM safety, sexual education, senior sexuality concerns, queer and gender issues, as well as reviewing numerous sextech products and adult entertainment sites.
Website | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook

Latest posts by M.Christian (see all)

• 9 Best BDSM Handcuffs 2024, Reviewed by a BDSM Educator! - December 27, 2023
• 7 Best BDSM Ankle Cuffs in 2024, Reviewed by a BDSM Educator! - December 3, 2023
• 10 Best FTM Packers & Prosthetics For Trans Men in 2024 - November 16, 2023