10 Common Sex Toy Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

  By

We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.

A woman face palming

Hi, my name is Sandra Larson, and I am an experienced sex toy tester with over a decade of experience helping people feel more confident and curious in the bedroom. This week, we are going to talk about something I learned when it comes to sex toys: They can seriously enhance your pleasure, but they also have a number of pitfalls.

That’s right. You only see the positives and never the awkward stuff. But that’s about to change.

To help you get the full picture, let’s walk through the ten most common sex toy mistakes and how to sidestep them like a pro.

1. Skipping the User Manual

Let’s start with the most common sex toy mistake: skipping the manual.

I know. After unboxing you just want to jump straight to the fun, but hear me out for a second with this story from my friend Carla. She fully submerged her brand new rabbit vibrator only to learn (when it was too late) that it wasn’t waterproof. “It sparked, hissed, and then died forever,” she wrote. “I screamed like it bit me.”

This can be an expensive issue because most pleasure products cost well over $100.

So, pretty please, always read the manual. Even if it’s just the first pages. It can be the difference between a heavenly orgasm and a panicked email to customer service (Most companies won’t reimburse you for user errors anyway).

2. Using the Wrong Lube

Let’s move on to another common mistake: using the wrong lubricant.

Most people don’t know that a Silicone toy + silicone lube = melted mess. Since both have “silicone” in the name, they think it must be a match made in heaven. Wrong!

These two products don’t match at all. In fact, silicone lube will 100% destroy the surface of your fancy new silicone toy. So always use water-based lubricants UNLESS the user manual says otherwise.

3. Assuming All Toys Are Body-Safe

I tell people to do a smell test before inserting anything into their bodies. If it smells like a new shower curtain? Put it down ASAP!

The sad truth is many retailers are still selling unsafe products like low-quality jelly rubber, with chemicals that should stay far away from your genitals.

So, always buy medical-grade silicone, stainless steel, or glass. Full stop. At the end of the day it’s your body. You only have one. So don’t roll the dice.

Story time: A reader sent me a photo of some nasty rash on her private parts. “I thought I was allergic to pleasure,” she joked. But it turned out she was just allergic to mystery materials.

4. Forgetting to Clean (Every Time)

A quick rinse isn’t enough.

Your sex toy must be cleaned both before and after use to avoid getting those nasty germs in your most precious body parts.

I recommend reading our cleaning guide above before buying any kind of sex toys. In short, use a mild soap, lukewarm water, and a soft brush for the grooves. Every time.

And always make sure they are completely dry before storing them away (moisture invites mildew).

You never have to worry again if you do this.

5. Not Charging It Beforehand

Imagine this scenario: You set the mood. Lights are dimmed. Music low. Horniness level is high. But then the sex toy just dies.

Now you have to wait over one hour for the next sexy time opportunity. No bueno!

So I recommend making charging part of your masturbation routine. You can even create a Google calendar reminder or do it at the same time as you charge your phone. Trust me. Seeing that LED light start blinking is fast lane to no aphrodisiac!

6. Going Too Hard, Too Soon

Power doesn’t always equal pleasure (I learned this the hard way).

I mean to start slow, especially with a new sex toy. Cranking something to the highest setting right away might seem thrilling. But it often ends up with overstimulation and frustration instead.

Let me tell you another story. One client told me he maxed out the stroker vibrations right from the beginning. “But I’d be overstimulated and annoyed. Now I slowly tease myself without any vibrations for ten minutes before turning everything on.”

Your body is precious and deserves a slow burn. Try to build anticipation slowly, like a song that doesn’t rush the chorus.

7. Not Talking to Your Partner First

This is a common issue I hear from couples. You don’t want to pull out a sex toy during the act without showing it first. This can be a huge turn-off and could make your partner never want to try sex toys ever again.

Instead, have a conversation about them. Involve them in the buying process. “Want to try something new tonight?” goes a long way. At the end of the day consent is sexy and makes your partner respect you more.

But what if you are nervous about the conversation? You can practice in front of a mirror first. You will be surprised how effective this can be.

8. Using It While You’re Still Numb

Your body can be a bit numb after a particularly powerful vibrator session. So give yourself a break before going another round.

The truth is you can temporarily desensitize your nerve endings sometimes for days. So let your body rest. There’s no prize for using a sex toy every night like it’s cardio.

Here’s another story: One woman emailed me in panic after she experienced two weeks without any pleasure. “I thought something broke in my body,” she wrote. Nope. All she needed was a break. After a couple of weeks she was back in the saddle again.

9. Treating All Toys the Same Way

Let’s be honest: not all sex toys want to live in your sock drawer.

Leather harnesses require conditioning. Silicone should have lint-free storage. Batteries hate heat.

I know. It can be confusing, but that’s what user manuals are for. So as I said in the first chapter of this article, please read the manual.

You can also read more on sex toy storage here.

10. Feeling Shame About Using Them

Let’s wrap up the article with the heaviest one. It’s also the most common: shame.

I know. We’ve come a long way, but sadly, sex toys are still taboo for most people. Even in relationships.

To help you ease the shame, you should think of them as a tool. Just like a power drill helps you put up picture frames around the house, a vibrator helps you reach orgasm more effectively.

They are not here to replace a partner or your hands. They are gateways to better conversations, deeper pleasure, and more “oh my god: moments.

Final Thoughts

Sex toys are truly incredible. I would even say life-changing. But like everything they have a learning curve (with a few bruises along the way).

So laugh at the fumbles. Share your fails with friends. And celebrate the wins (even small ones like figuring out the proper cleaning process).

And don’t worry. We’ve all made mistakes. I’ve made dozens and I am still here to talk about them. The key is to laugh, learn, and keep the batteries charged.

So start where you are, laugh a little, and keep on exploring. Because your body is worth it.

Happy vibing!

Sandra

Sandra Larson
Follow me
Latest posts by Sandra Larson (see all)
Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.