We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
We understand the sense of fulfillment that comes from crafting something with your own hands, but we don’t recommend making a homemade tail butt plug due to the risks. Show some love for your tush and treat it with a Frisky Fox Tail Plug which only costs $49.99.
The only reason to make a DIY tail butt plug is if you live in an area without online adult retailers or walk-in sex shops. If you’re one of those, you can find some ideas below. But you do it at your own risk!
- Making a tail butt plug at home using unsafe materials can be risky and uncomfortable. It’s important to prioritize your safety by refraining from materials that are not intended for anal play.
- If you choose to go ahead with constructing your makeshift tail butt plug despite the risks, there are some relatively safe alternatives available. These alternatives include molding kits, repurposing existing butt plugs, and engaging in woodworking. More on these below.
Table Of Contents
Why You Should Trust Us
Tim Larson, our CEO and an experienced reviewer of sex toys, has dedicated nearly ten years to exploring the sexual wellness industry and assessing a diverse range of products. He specializes in testing male sex toys and offering guidance to readers in their quest for the perfect adult products that cater to their unique desires and preferences.
When it comes to DIY sex toys, Tim’s expertise is unmatched. Since establishing this website in 2016, he has evaluated hundreds of products and assisted millions of individuals in selecting the right options for their specific needs. He’s the perfect guy to suggest the right DIY projects for you!
To submit a question to Tim, call him at +1 307-372-3895 or send an email to [email protected]. Be sure to include your full name and your phone number or email address.
What is a DIY Tail Butt Plug?
A DIY tail butt plug works the same way as a homemade butt plug but with the added friskiness of a tail. The tail is attached to the base and resembles the tail of an animal, adding an element of kink and role-play to sexual activities.
It’s important to ensure that the tail is securely attached to the base to prevent it from coming loose during use. You can achieve this by using strong adhesives or by sewing the tail onto the base.
Note: The image above is an example of a commercial product called Frisky Fox Tail Plug. For less than $50, it’s a bargain, considering it comes with a vibrating bullet and is made from high-quality silicone material. More on the best tail butt plugs right here.
Are DIY Tail Butt Plugs Safe?
Hard no. Crafting a tail butt plug at home is not safe because not all materials are typically safe for human use. Some materials are porous, which means they can harbor bacteria and other harmful microorganisms. This can lead to infections and other health issues.
While DIY experiments can be a fun and creative project, some things are best left to the hands of professionals. We recommend investing in a high-quality tail butt plug made from safe materials and designed with a flared base to ensure a safe and enjoyable experience.
Some Semi-Safe Tail Butt Plug Ideas
Safety should always be the top priority for any kind of DIY stuff. While there are various methods to make a tail butt plug, it’s crucial to ensure that the final product is free from sharp edges that could cause harm. Let’s check out some semi-safe ideas starting with a molding kit:
Note: Any action you take upon the information on this website is strictly at your own risk. Please read our Terms of Service to learn more.
1. Molding Kits
One of the easiest ways to make your own butt plug is with a molding kit. These kits are designed for making a mold of a man’s penis, like Clone-A-Willy, but they can work just as well for butt plugs. Simply mix the molding material, pour it into the provided container, and insert the butt plug to create a custom fit. Once the material sets, remove the plug, and use it as a mold to create the final product with silicone or another nonporous material.
2. Drill a Hole in the Base
An alternative is to customize a pre-existing butt plug by drilling a hole in the base and attaching a tail. This method requires a drill, along with a touch of patience and a steady hand. We also recommend doing this on a cheaper butt plug without a motor, as you may not get it right the first time.
First, you must also ensure that the hole is positioned at the center of the base and is smooth, as any sharp or rough parts could potentially make the attachment difficult.
After drilling, carefully insert the tail and make adjustments as necessary. Attach the tail using glue, wire, or tape, and don’t use it until the tail is steadily set.
If you’re looking to add a personal touch to your tail butt plug, there are various ways to customize the tail according to your preferences. Here are some ideas you can try:
- Faux Fur Selection: When crafting or modifying a tail make sure to apply your personal style. Choose from a wide range of faux fur options available in costume shops or online stores. Consider the length, color, and texture of the fur to achieve the desired aesthetic.
- Tail Length: Tail length can greatly impact your experience. Shorter tails are less likely to be distracting and will only take a gentle pull to remove, while longer tails can provide an eye-catching effect. Experiment with different lengths to find the right balance for you, and make sure to finalize the decision before cutting the tail with a razor blade.
- Custom Colors and Patterns: Adding patterns or custom colors can make your tail stand out. Consider adding unique designs or incorporating multiple fur colors for a personalized look.
- Proper Curing: If using materials like clay or silicone, ensure proper curing to maintain the tail’s shape and durability. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions or seek guidance from DIY tips to ensure a successful outcome.
- Cleaning and Maintenance: To keep your custom tail or even real animal fur in optimal condition, clean it with mild soap and warm water after each use. Gently pull the fur to remove any debris, ensuring that the fur remains intact. If needed, secure shaving or trimming can be done to maintain the tail’s appearance.
Note: Just know that most of the best butt plugs may lose some functionality when you drill in them. Lovense Hush 2 (image above) is best known for its app-controlled feature, and below is its charging port. For these instances, instead of drilling you can perhaps wrap it around the base to keep their extra feature.
3. Clay or Woodwork
If you’re an experienced DIY enthusiast and want to try a fun and creative process, you can explore advanced options like clay or woodworking to create a fully personalized toy. However, please use non-toxic clay, as the alternative can harbor bacteria and potentially lead to infections.
Pro tip: Glassblowing is something we don’t recommend for DIY sex toys as glass can easily shatter. If you want to have glass plugs, the best course of action is to get the DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur, for only $39.99 you save yourself a lot of trouble.
Not Safe at All Ideas
We want to make it clear that some ideas are not safe at all. We strongly advise against trying the below ideas because they can cause serious harm. Here are a few examples of not safe at all ideas:
Non-Body-Safe Materials
It may be tempting to use household items or materials that are not meant for sexual use. However, this can lead to serious health risks. For example, using a plastic bottle cap or a wooden dowel as a base for your tail can cause irritation, infection, or even damage to your rectum. Only use materials that are specifically designed for sexual use and are body-safe.
Unsafe Adhesives
Some people may try to attach a tail to a butt plug using unsafe adhesives such as super glue or hot glue. This is extremely dangerous because these adhesives can cause chemical burns, tissue damage, and even allergic reactions. Always use body-safe adhesives that are specifically designed for sexual use.
Unsterilized Materials
Another unsafe idea is using unsterilized materials. You must properly sterilize any materials that come into contact with your body, especially for anal play. Failure to do so can lead to bacterial infections, which can be difficult to treat and potentially life-threatening. Always sterilize your materials before using them.
Why Is it Better To Get A Real Anal Toy?
While homemade toys may seem like a cheap and easy solution, there are several reasons why it’s better to invest in a commercial product. Let’s check them out:
Safety
Reputable stores and manufacturers prioritize safety and quality in their products. Homemade toys, on the other hand, may not be made with body-safe materials or may not be properly sanitized as they don’t undergo safety testing, unlike their authentic counterparts. This can lead to infections or other health issues.
Note: Rubber or Silicone plugs just like this product are your best pick. Rocking a 2-foot tail made from silky smooth faux fur, Tailz Bad Kitty adds a realistic touch to the bedroom that every cat-lover can appreciate.
Effectiveness
Real anal toys are designed with pleasure in mind and often come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and textures to cater to different preferences and levels of experience. Homemade butt plugs may not provide the same level of comfort or stimulation.
Special features
Another benefit of purchasing a real anal toy is the ability to experiment with different advanced features, such as vibration or remote control. These features can enhance pleasure and add excitement to solo or partnered play.
Pro tip: There are special features that only authentic products can pull off. for example. B-Vibe Unicorn is a vibrating unicorn butt plug. And no, you can’t create a vibrating tail butt plug that looks like a unicorn’s tail in your home. You just can’t.
Tim
- 10 Best Cock Rings [Video Demonstration] - September 19, 2025
- 6 Best Penis Pumps [Video Demonstration] - September 8, 2025
- 7 Best Pocket Pussies [Video Demonstration] - September 6, 2025
