Homemade Butt Plug: PRO TIPS from a Sex Toy Tester

We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.

Featured image

If you’re reading this, it’s probably because you’re thinking of trying to create your own homemade butt plug. This is not actually a good idea! You should never put anything inside your body that wasn’t designed for that purpose. It’s easier than ever to get good, safe sex toys these days. For a nice starter plug, we recommend Doc Johnson’s Mood Naughty. It’s less than $20, and it ships quickly and discreetly.

However, we’re not new to the internet and we know that there are some brave folks who will disregard the above paragraph. We will discuss what sort of works and what should be avoided at all costs, so keep reading!


Why You Should Trust Us

We’ve been running My Sex Toy Guide for over ten years now, so as you can imagine, we have hands(and more)-on experience with many dozens of butt plugs. We know what works and what doesn’t. More importantly, we know what makes a toy safe for internal use.

Our loyalty is to our readers. We stick stuff up our butts so you don’t have to. We’re not owned by and don’t get paid by sex toy companies. If we recommend a particular product — or any product (as opposed to something you found in the junk drawer) — it’s because we have evaluated it and honestly believe that it’s worth recommending.

 


What Is a Homemade Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a small sex toy designed for anal use by all genders. The anus and rectum are rich with sensitive nerve endings that respond to stimulation, and a feeling of fullness intensifies sensation in the pelvic region so that genital stimulation can feel more intense. Butt plugs are often part of the power dynamic in BDSM scenarios. Also, wearing a butt plug for gradually increasing periods of time can help “train” your body for anal sex or other anal penetration. You can even get a butt plug with a tail for some extra fun.

Closeup of the tapered tip

In addition, for people with prostates, a butt plug may create direct or indirect pressure against the prostate and this can be very arousing. For people with vulvas, the presence of a butt plug makes the vaginal canal feel tighter.

A homemade butt plug is what people who don’t want to or can’t buy a professionally produced product create to try to replicate the above. Some ideas are worse than others.

The b-Vibe Rimming Plug above is one of the highest-rated butt plugs that we reviewed. We recommend it over any homemade alternative. It’s safe and it feels good.

 


Are Homemade Butt Plugs Safe?

Most homemade butt plugs are not as safe as products that were made for this use. They can cause irritation, infection, or injury — all of which are far more inconvenient (and likely more expensive) than buying a butt plug from a sex toy retailer.

Another issue with homemade butt plugs is that they cannot be cleaned and sterilized the way that silicone, glass, or metal can. Porous materials will harbor microscopic bacteria and other contaminants that will, at best, start to smell funky. They can also make you pretty sick.

Whether you use a homemade butt plug or one that you buy from a store, you need to keep it clean. You should also make sure not to leave it in too long.

 


The Best of What’s Out There

If you’ve been on the internet for more than a minute, you know that there is an endless variety of things that people put in their butts. We feel strongly that commercially produced sex toys are the safest option, but we also know that there will always be people who want to DIY. These are some of the least problematic suggestions that we’ve seen.

Please note that any action you take upon the information on this website is strictly at your own risk, as laid out in our Terms of Service.

1. Wooden Spoon

Wooden spoons are a popular DIY hack. They are usually inexpensive and they come in a range of sizes. The bowl of the spoon is usually wide enough to serve as a safety base. Be sure to choose a spoon that has a rounded end on the handle, and sand it down with fine-grit sandpaper. Wash it well, let it dry, and apply plenty of water-based lube.

2. Hairbrush

A hairbrush with a smooth handle and a round tip can work as a homemade butt plug. The bristle end is wide enough for safety. Make sure that the handle is smooth; you can file or sand it if necessary. You should always wash anything that goes inside your body, but it’s extra-important here because the residue from some hair care products can irritate delicate skin.

A hairbrush

3. Ice Cubes

Temperature play is something that people seem to either love or hate. If you think that you want to try it, you can put three ice cubes in a condom and knot the end. We want to say that you shouldn’t leave your icy plug in place too long, but the truth is that it will melt fairly quickly. This is one of the few times when we’re okay with the lack of a safety base, because you’ll be able to pull out the condom fairly easily once the ice has melted.

3 ice cubes

4. Plastic Handles

There are probably plenty of things in your house that have smooth plastic handles with gently rounded ends. Makeup brushes, paint brushes, and kitchen tools come to mind. Make sure that whatever you choose has a wide enough “base” that it won’t get sucked in and stuck. Also, sand or file any rough spots and wash it well before play time. You can also put a condom over the handle. (We recommend a good glass butt plug instead.)

5. Fruits and Vegetables

Fruits and vegetables are a popular choice because they are inexpensive and you can choose from a wide variety of shapes and sizes in the produce department or cut one to your exact preferences. Be sure to choose a firm piece of produce, and we recommend putting a condom over it because there’s a not-small chance that it will break under pressure. Very few fruits or vegetables naturally grow a flared base, so buyer beware.

Featured image

One trend in the BDSM community is called figging. This involves a butt plug carved out of peeled ginger, which creates a burning sensation when inserted in the anus. Dom/mes can punish their subs this way. Always use a safe word or other quick-escape clause, and either carve your ginger plug with a wide base or select a root with multiple fingers and a naturally wide “base.”

6. Toothbrush Handles

Toothbrush handles are not likely to break off inside you since they are strong and firm. Choose one that has a tapered end to make insertion easier, and as always, use plenty of good-quality lube. Wash the toothbrush before use since toothpaste can irritate skin. And this should go without saying, but don’t use your own regular toothbrush (or anyone else’s!). You should have one dedicated to this activity. Most toothbrushes won’t have a safety base, so keep that in mind.

Electric Toothbrush

7. Candles

Pillar candles are the right size and shape for a butt plug, and the wax softens slightly at body heat for a flexible and comfortable experience (you can even soften it in hot water to shape it). Try to choose candles that do not have added dyes or fragrances. Candles do not generally have wide bases, but you could put the candle in a wide candle holder for a makeshift base. Light the candle and drip a tiny bit of hot wax into the candle holder before adding the candle; this will help keep the candle in the base.

A condom

Honorable Mention

Fingers — your own or someone else’s — are Mother Nature’s OG butt plug. They are free and you probably have at least a few readily available.

 


What Not to Do

The list of things that you should not put in your butt is much longer than the list of things that are safe to put in your butt. We’re listing some of the most common bad ideas that we’ve seen and heard of, but this is by no means an exhaustive list.

Metal Objects: It is dangerous to put most metal objects inside your body. Even if they look and feel smooth, they likely are not finished to the same standards that medical instruments and commercially produced sex toys are. The lining of the rectum is delicate, and any scratches or tears can be painful. They can also get infected very easily, considering what else happens in the rectum.

Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug

It is true that some very high-end sex toys are made of metal, but manufacturers generally use highly polished surgical-grade stainless steel or anodized aluminum. Most household objects or items that you can pick up at a big-box hardware or craft store are not.

Glass: Glass shatters and splinters very easily. No one wants glass shards, or the remnants of a broken bottle, embedded in their anus and rectum. This is why no one should try to DIY a glass butt plug.

Chrystalino Expert

You may have seen glass butt plugs like the Chrystalino Expert at sex toy retailers. As with metal, these toys have been purpose-built. Almost all glass sex toys are made of borosilicate glass. Borosilicate glass is used in laboratory equipment and professional cookware because it’s been specially treated to be strong and shatterproof.

Tampons: You might think that tampons would be a safe DIY butt plug because they are meant to be used internally. You’d be right as far as that goes, but there are other reasons to avoid tampons. They are designed to absorb moisture, but this also means that they will trap bacteria inside and increase the risk of infection. Tampons are also designed to expand, and combined with drying up any natural or artificial moisture, they will be difficult and possibly painful to remove.

Porous Materials: Porous materials will create a home for bacteria and other microorganisms, which can cause infection and illness. Please note that many pores are microscopic; you may not be able to see the pores but this doesn’t mean that they don’t exist. If it isn’t 100% waterproof, it’s porous and should be treated as contaminated after the first use.

Cleaning Sex Toys In The Sink

It is crucial to clean sex toys, especially sex toys made for internal use, before you store them away. It’s not possible to get porous materials thoroughly clean or sanitized when necessary. Non-porous materials can be washed with soap and water or an antibacterial sex toy cleaner. They can also usually be soaked or boiled as needed.

Happy vibing!

Maggie

Maggie Hart
Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.