We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
Let’s face it, I think there’s something within all of us that longs to use bunny ears and a fuzzy bunny tail to transform us into a sexy Playboy Bunny. Sound familiar? Then you’re in the right place! Our team personally tested twelve bunny tail butt plugs and now we’re here to share our experience.
To make things easier, we’ve put our top pick first in this review, the PlayFul Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug, which stood out for its adorable but extremely simple design, silky-smooth silicone, and budget-friendly price. Keep reading to learn more about the butt plug that stole our hearts.
Test Winner: Playful Silicone Small
Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug got the highest rating in our review. This butt plug is simple without any bells and whistles, but it was described as ‘absolutely perfect’ by several of our testers. Discount code AFF-MSTG10 for 10% off!
Budget: Pipedream Neon Bunny Tail
Even if you’re shopping on a budget, there’s no need for you to compromise on quality. This next pick withstood the test of rough play and didn’t lose so much as a single fluffy tail fiber, introducing the Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream!
Table Of Contents
Why You Should Trust Us
At My Sex Toy Guide.com, we understand the importance of making informed decisions when it comes to exploring and understanding your sexual preferences. Our entire team of dedicated sex experts, which includes Rachel Sommer, Ph.D., who is the author of this article, brings extensive expertise and authority in the realm of sex toys.
Having been involved with My Sex Toy Guide since its inception in 2016, Rachel has been an essential part of our testing process – which includes hands-on testing and has helped us to provide accurate information about 300+ sex toys to date. You can put your trust in her and the teams of sex experts she employs the help of to provide unbiased and honest information about all of the popular adult products for sale today.
How We Picked The Products
To ensure that I recommend only the best bunny tail butt plugs to my readers, myself and my diverse team of sex experts personally tested a dozen of the highest-rated review samples currently for sale on our favorite sex toy sites, like Lovehoney, Shevibe, Stockroom, and Peepshowtoys.
From there, I defined key decision-making factors we could measure using well-defined quantitative metrics. We used the following criteria to rate each review sample out of 100 and accorded each position in this review accordingly. These factors included the following:
- Plug material: Silicone with a silky smooth texture was given bonus points, and we made sure to include only the highest-quality glass and metal butt plugs for additional variety. You can find some of the best glass butt plugs and metal butt plugs we tested by clicking their respective links.
- Safety: Anal sex toys need to be shaped in such a way that there’s no possibility of them getting stuck in your tush, and of course, choosing plugs made from totally body-safe materials was a high priority.
- Sensation: Butt plugs, whether equipped with a bunny tail or not, are supposed to be comfortable to wear and provide a delightful fill.
- Size: Generally, we try to choose review samples that are usable by folks in the beginner category to intermediate user category. However, super-comfy extra-large models are also highly sought after by myself and my panel members.
- Tail material: We were on the hunt for tails fluffy enough to rival the real thing, though we included only animal-friendly faux fur that doesn’t lose its fluff, even after hours of use.
- Design: A nicely tapered tip for easy insertion, bulk in all the right places, and a super flared base for safe wear are must-haves for the toys on our list of recommendations.
- Cleanability: Glass and metal have a special place in my heart because they’re just so dang easy to clean and don’t hold onto any unwanted odors.
- Special features: As if a bunny tail isn’t special enough, we also included vibrating options for folks who desire the extra stimulation. But if you want a variation and feel something stronger, perhaps you need a thrusting butt plug for that.
- Price rating: We tried to include a combination of budget-friendly options and more luxury picks to ensure there’s something for everyone.
- Quality: Tails that quickly lost their fluff, or worse, plugs that lost their tail entirely, were quickly eliminated from our review process.
During testing, we rated each based on the criteria listed above, starting from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). Each score was calculated using different weighted metrics depending on what we deemed most important. Half the total rating comes from Design (25%) and Tail material (25%). After that comes Plug material (10%), Size (10%), Cleanability (10%), Special features (10%), Sensation (5%), and Price rating (5%).
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| |
|
| Name | Playful Silicone | Pipedream |
| Category | Best Overall | Budget |
| Average Rating | 95% | 91% |
| Design | 96% | 89% |
| Plug Material | 94% | 90% |
| Safety | 94% | 94% |
| Sensation | 96% | 85% |
| Size | 94% | 95% |
| Tail Material | 95% | 84% |
| Cleanability | 97% | 93% |
| Special Features | 95% | 94% |
| Price & Value | 90% | 94% |
| Price Tag | $19.99 | $18.99 |
| Material | Silicone & Faux fur | Silicone & Faux fur |
| Insertable Length | 2.5 inches | 2.5 inches |
| Circumference | 3.5 inches | 3.5 inches |
1. Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug: Test Winner
Why we love Playful Silicone Small:
If you’re new to pet play or anal play in general, then I’ve got just the plug for you! Say hello to the Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Plug. This one is simple in design and comes equipped without any bells and whistles (if you count the fuchsia pink tail as neither), but it was described as ‘absolutely perfect’ by several of our sex experts nonetheless.
It’s sized for beginners, though it provides a nice enough fill to be used by folks with a little more experience and anyone on the hunt for something for anal training, as it does a stellar job of warming up your bum. The color, much to my surprise, is exactly as the plug is shown in its Lovehoney photos, and I loved the vibrant pop of pink, especially when it was poking out from between my cheeks.
The material itself is shorter in length, not as wispy as other models I’ve tried, but still just as soft as you’d expect from something being advertised as a bunny tail. I found it incredibly easy to pop in my bottom and, despite its relatively small size, didn’t struggle with it falling out during use. The sensation of it post-insertion was surprisingly filling thanks to the bulk of the toy landing closer to the extra-long and thin stem, which is nicely designed for lengthy wear time.
Minor issues found during testing:
The only real issue was had by our curvier panel members, who found that the length made it so that the tail was more squished between their cheeks than they would have liked. If you find this an issue, we recommend getting a long tail just like a cat tail butt plug has.
Other than that, it’s important to remember this is a beginner butt plug in terms of size. If you’re experienced or have a wider-set tush (as many men do), using a larger butt plug is probably better, and unfortunately, there is no size-up option for this particular product.
Why Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail is the best bunny butt plug:
The Playful Silicone Pink Bunny Tail Butt Plug packs everything you could ask for in an aesthetically pleasing, user and budget-friendly package, and easily stole the title as our top pick with an average rating of 96%.
- Tail material: Let’s face it, we’re all here for the adorable bunny tail! And this one is sized and shaped perfectly and plush to the touch. It handily beat the competition in this critical category.
- Size: Though not ideal for our more experienced readers, size-wise, this baby is perfect for beginners and provides enough of a fill to get the job done.
Features:
- Material: Silicone and faux fur
- Total Length: 5”
- Insertable Length: 2.5”
- Circumference: 3.5”
Pros:
- Perfect size and price for beginners
- Budget-friendly ($19.99)
- The tail material is incredibly soft
- Quick and discreet shipping
- Silicone is silky smooth
Cons:
- Not large enough for advanced users
- Not offered in a larger size
2. Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream: Our Budget Pick!
Why we love Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream:
Even if you’re shopping on a budget, there’s no need for you to compromise on quality. This next pick withstood the test of rough play and didn’t lose so much as a single fluffy tail fiber, introducing the Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream.
The Neon Bunny Tail is another beginner-friendly butt plug made with the classic and oh-so-fulling teardrop shape that most of us are familiar with. Despite being relatively small, I never found myself desiring a size-up, as it offers a satisfying fill and just the right amount of stretch to enhance sensation below the belt.
The teardrop shape also made it easy to hold onto between your cheeks, and I never had issues with it slipping out during play. The bunny tail is also more of a pom-type material, similar to what you may have used for crafts as a kid, but is super velvety-soft to the touch and very durable, losing none of its fibers, even during rougher play.
I found that this material type was even easier to keep clean than the longer fibers often used for tail butt plugs as you don’t have to worry about it losing any of its volume, even after a thorough rinse. The Neon Bunny Tail is also on the longer end of silicone toys that we reviewed, which means if you have a juicier butt and are looking for some extra length, this will likely be a perfect fit.
Minor issues found during testing:
Once again, the only real issue posed by this butt plug relates to its size, which, although perfect for new and semi-experienced anal toy users, is too small for folks with more experience.
I also found that, for whatever reason, the material used for the tail holds onto moisture, which means that you need to be especially careful about allowing it to dry fully before storing it.
Why Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream is our budget pick:
When compared to other bunny tail butt plugs in the same price range, the Neon Bunny Tail by Pipedream was the clear winner, both in quality and overall value. Our reviewers gave it an average rating of 94%.
- Cleanability: One of the biggest issues of any tail butt plug is keeping it fresh and clean over time. I loved how easy it was to remove lube and debris from the fibers, and I never felt like a good washing left the Neon Bunny Tail worse for wear.
- Price rating: Among all the products we tested, Neon Bunny provided the most value for our money. Not only is this one super budget-friendly, but it still delivers the level of quality that we expect from any toy we’re considering recommending to our readers.
Features:
- Material: Silicone and faux fur
- Total Length: 5.25”
- Insertable Length: 2.5”
- Circumference: 3.5”
Pros:
- Super budget-friendly ($18.99)
- Extra-long stem makes for comfortable extended wear
- Stem length is ideal for larger bums
- The material is extremely soft and durable
- No issues with it slipping out during play
Cons:
- On the small side for experienced butt plug users
Other Good Alternatives:
Stockroom’s Pink Magnetic Sparkle Glass Bunny Butt Plug. If you’re a little on the bougie side and aren’t afraid to spend some extra cash on a luxury product, Stockroom’s Pink Magnetic Sparkle will be right up your alley. This borosilicate glass bunny tail butt plug is filled from top to bottom with delicate pink sparkles and has a pink tail luscious enough to give Lola Bunny a run for her money, all for only $49.99. The tail is also removable, making for easy post-play cleanup and the option to use it in two ways; fluffy or bejeweled.
Fashionistas Large Bunny Butt Plug. This next pic is the definition of sleek and modern. The Fashionistas is a complete glass plug that comes adorned with beautiful flourishes etched onto the exterior. It boasts a perfectly filling 4.7” circumference that is ideal for anyone with a little more experience, and that is looking for a new challenge in the bedroom. Unique to this plug is the decision to use elegant white feathers for the fluffy tail, which are not only beautiful to look at but extremely soft to the touch.
Happy Rabbit Vibrating Bunny Butt Plug. If variety is important to you, it doesn’t get much more versatile than the Happy Rabbit. This baby comes complete with an interchangeable fluffy and jeweled base and 12-speed and vibration patterns to keep you busy in the bedroom. It’s also the largest of all the plugs included in this review, with an incredible 5.25” circumference and a whopping 5” insertable length that definitely satisfied the senses and removed any doubt about the Happy Rabbit popping out during use. Best of all, it’s USB-rechargeable, which means that you can simply plug the Happy Rabbit in after use to get it ready for round two.
How To Use A Bunny Tail Butt Plug?
Using a bunny tail butt plug is as easy as any other style of anal toy. But in case you need a refresher, here is an easy step-by-step for you to follow:
- Even if your new toy is fresh out of the box, make sure to always give it a thorough cleanse with hot water and mild soap or a sex toy-specific cleanser before use.
- Then, lather the insertable length of your butt plug and the entrance to your anus with the appropriate kind of lube.
- Get into a comfy position (my favorite is lying on my side), take deep breaths, and focus on relaxing the muscles around your anus. Once relaxed, slowly, and using a rocking motion, gently slide the tapered tip of your toy into your bum.
For more tips on using your butt plug safely and effectively, check out our full guide.
You can also find more of the best butt plugs right here if you’re interested.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 8 Best Strapons For Lesbians [Video Demonstration] - September 3, 2025
- 8 Best Egg Vibrators [Video Demonstration] - September 2, 2025
- 6 Best Vibrating Butt Plugs [Video Demonstration] - August 18, 2025
