5 Best Black Fleshlights And Other Great Alternatives in 2024

Are you tired of the cliché pink masturbators? How about a more posh-looking black Fleshlight? Well, you’ve come to the right place. This article highlights five black sleeves plus some alternatives from other brands. I’ll also highlight usage tips to ensure you get the most out of the experience.

I’ve used masturbators for over 10 years with Fleshlights taking center stage. Besides the hands-on experience, I reviewed more than ten black Fleshlights and other strokers for this article, with Kira Noir Spellbound being the highest-rated sleeve. Everything from the detailed lips to the unique texture of dense cubed clusters stood out from the competition.

Why You Should Trust Us

For more than six years, Tim Larson has been reviewing strokers on top of using them for a decade and a half. He has tested numerous masturbators, including Fleshlights and other alternatives, emphasizing hands-on experience.

It took more than 150 hours to put this article together. Besides testing every masturbator individually, we went through multiple adult toy forums and read user reviews from major sites like Fleshlight, Shevibe, and Lovehoney. So, after endless research hours and testing, here are the best black Fleshlights and other alternatives!

How We Picked The Products

We started our review process by grouping the masturbators into several categories based on metrics like the “Overall Test Winner”, “Anal Orifice”, “The most variation”, and “The best Fleshlight alternative“. Grouping the toys made it easy to match you with the right masturbator for your specific needs.

We also defined well-defined quantitative metrics that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100. These factors included the following:

• Stimulation: A quality product must deliver the kind of pleasure that leaves you thinking about it all day. So we tested for sensations that make your toes curl.
• Material: We sought materials that feel like a gentle embrace yet are resilient enough to endure the heat of the moment. Most importantly, we gave credit to the models made of materials that are easier to clean than others.
• Design: The dark, sleek design isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about how it feels in your hand and complements your space. We know that’s what our readers like, so we made sure to look for designs that aren’t just pretty but also practical in their purpose.
• Build Quality: In addition to having good materials, each Fleshlight needs to be reliable, strong, and always ready for action. We tested for endurance because we know a good Fleshlight should be ready to go the distance, just like you.
• Texture Variation: This is where the magic happens. Each model was explored for its unique internal feel. The more unique or intense the texture, the higher we ranked it. We’re talking about a landscape of sensations that keeps every experience fresh and thrilling.
• Versatility: We picked models that can shift gears with you, from those easy-going nights to times when you crave something a bit more… adventurous. This may be a bit of a spoiler but when it comes to versatility, THRUST Pro Elite Tiana took the title. I don’t want want to give too much detail; just make sure to take a closer look at this vaginal and anal masturbator if you’re into versatility.
• Realism: Now, how can it make you feel like you’re banging the girl of your dreams if the realism isn’t up to par, right? Hence, we made realism a big focus—the models that made you pause and think, “Is this for real?” were the ones that really stood out.
• Price & Value: It’s about striking that perfect chord between cost and ecstasy. We evaluated which Fleshlights give you the most joy for your investment, ensuring you walk away with a sense of satisfaction, not just a lighter wallet.

During testing, we rated each test criterion on a percentage scale from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). We then calculated the overall score using different weighted metrics depending on the importance of the test criteria. Half the rating comes from Stimulation (25%) and Material (25%). After that comes Design (10%), Build Quality (10%), Texture Variation (10%), Versatility (10%), Realism (5%) and Price & Value (5%).

Besides reviewing the masturbators individually, we also went through customer accounts and adult toy consumer forums to learn more about other people’s experiences. Combining hands-on experience with our stringent review rules book and insights from experts and authentic reviewers, we believe our top five black Fleshlights are the best on the market.

Everything We Tested

In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.

Name	Spellbound	Anna Foxxx	Misty Stone	CalExotics	Tiana
Category	Best Overall	Anal Sleeve	Variation	Alternative	Hip Masturbatator
Average Rating	94%	93%	92%	91%	90%
Material	93%	93%	93%	91%	89%
Design	95%	92%	91%	86%	91%
Stimulation	94%	95%	90%	90%	90%
Texture	95%	89%	88%	88%	86%
Build Quality	93%	88%	92%	85%	87%
Realism	90%	91%	89%	90%	89%
Versatility	90%	92%	93%	89%	90%
Price & Value	89%	90%	94%	91%	89%
Price Tag	$113.59	$113.59	$79.95	$44.99	$299.99
Material	SuperSkin	SuperSkin	SuperSkin	TPR	TPE
Length	8 inches	8 inches	9.25 inches	8 inches	7.5 inches (Vagina) & 5.5 inches (Anal cavity)

1. Kira Noir Spellbound: Our Overall Test Winner!

Why we love Kira Noir Spellbound:

We loved many things about Kira Noir Spellbound, but our favorite was the sleeve’s densely cubed clusters inside the cavity. The texture was the most stimulating among the review samples, with a mix of hardy nodes and smoothly finished bulbs in the middle. “The slim, snug passageway provided a silky grip on the shaft from the head to base, ensuring even spread of sensations,” emphasizes Shane Davis.

Besides the varied texture, we loved the multiple constrictions between the different sections. They added an extra layer of resistance during stroking, making the experience more exciting. In addition, the mix of smooth and rough nodes in the cavity created a pleasurable instroke and outstroke.

Kira Noir’s size (image above) was another review highlight. It’s one of Fleshlight’s most extensive options, accommodating up to 9 inches long and 7.5 inches wide members comfortably. The textured orifice made the sleeve impressively tight.

Note: You can use the masturbator with or without the plastic case. Girthier folks will find it more accommodating without the case. More importantly, taking off the case made it easy to regulate the intensity with the grip. Conversely, the plastic cover’s adjustable suction cap allows the user to regulate suction pressure during stroking.

Another thing we appreciated was the outstanding build quality. Like other Fleshlight Girl series sleeves, the brand used high-quality SuperSkin material for the masturbation sleeve and rugged ABS for the case. The designers paid attention to detail, from the exciting texture with different sections and constrictions to the ribbed body to simplify handling.

Masturbator users that prefer anatomically-correct sex toys will enjoy the exquisite look of the masturbator. Kira Noir’s luscious lips hug your member as soon as you make your way past the orifice for an incredibly soothing sensation.

Lastly, the test winner was compatible with standard Fleshlight accessories, including the shower mount and automated strokers like the Universal Launch. We tested the sleeve with multiple add-ons from Fleshlight, and the experience was straightforward,” says Tim Larson. “Minimum effort and maximum enjoyment were a common combo with each one of them.”

Minor issues we found during testing:

Unfortunately, cleaning the textured sleeve can be challenging. The multiple constrictions and unevenly sized nodes trap lube and body fluids, requiring more effort and time to clean and dry the masturbator.

In addition, there were some slurping noises during stroking, and people looking for a super discreet sleeve might have to look elsewhere.

Why Kira Noir Spellbound is our test winner:

• Design: Kira Noir Spellbound outperformed the competition. The sleeve design was top-notch, including multiple textures, realistic orifice, and squeezable material. We loved how stimulating the sensations were regardless of the user’s member length. Unlike most models, the texture variation was designed in a way that even guys with a shorter penis will enjoy the sensations.
• Stimulations: Besides the varied texture in the cavity, the testers highlighted the constrictions because they amplified the intensity. Notably, the designer used different sizes and smoothness for the nodes, making the stroking action more exciting. In addition, you can use the masturbator without the case, rendering it easy to regulate the intensity with your grip.
• Build Quality: Like other Fleshlight toys, the quality of craftsmanship was excellent. We loved the high-quality SuperSkin material and ABS plastic. For the sleeve, the squishy material replicated the feeling of a vagina, with incredible detailing to enhance the sensations. On the other hand, the rugged ABS on the case promoted durability in the long run.

Features:

• Material: SuperSkin
• Length: 8″
• Girth: 7.5″

Pros:

• It’s an incredibly stimulating masturbation sleeve.
• Phenomenal build quality.
• Realistic orifice and pussy lips.
• Multiple textures with constrictions.
• It’s ideal for guys with massive members.
• You can use it with or without the plastic case.

Cons:

• Cleaning can be tedious.
• The slurping noise can be annoying.

View On Fleshlight

2. Anna Foxxx Velvet: A Great Anal Sleeve!

Why we love Anna Foxxx Velvet:

Among the models we reviewed, Anna Foxxx stood out as the most authentic anal sleeve. It’s modeled from adult film star Anna Fox’s anal orifice, depicting a life of a sexual deviant out to induce kinkiness and revitalize the sex life of everyone that uses it.

The reviewers highlighted the unique texture that significantly enhanced realism. Unlike most models, there was no exaggeration, and the mild yet impactful cavity was perfect for different users. “It wasn’t the most intense Fleshlight sleeve I’ve tested, but the raw feeling of penetrating an anus was exciting,” says Shane Davis. “It almost felt like I was having anal sex with my fiancé.”

Ana Foxxx’s cavity reminded me of the Stamina Training Unit. The even distribution of nubs from the orifice to the tip provided many sensations without being intimidating. We found it to be the best option for folks seeking stamina and endurance training,

Something else that stood out during the testing was the dark chocolate complexion. If you love the gorgeous tone of African American women, Anna’s anal sleeve will get you drooling over the possibilities. Everything from the distinctive detailing to the color and wrinkled orifice amplifies the realism.

Lastly, the rugged build improved the Fleshlight sleeve’s longevity, making it ideal for collectors and other users looking to add a long-lasting piece to their collection.

Minor issues we found during testing:

Unfortunately, some readers will find the repetitive texture annoying. Folks seeking the most intense sensations will not like the STU-like masturbation sleeve.

In addition, the sleeve costs up to $79.95, making it unideal for beginners looking to experience the bliss without breaking the bank.

Why Anna Foxxx Velvet is the most incredible anal sleeve:

• Stimulations: Unlike most review samples, Anna Foxxx had a well-measured balance between intensity and functionality. The even distribution from the opening to the tip spread the sensations throughout the cavity so that everyone, regardless of their member’s size, enjoyed the experience. In addition, the texture rendered the sleeve unique and perfect for users seeking intimate edging and stamina training.
• Design: Besides amplifying the possibilities, the STU-like texture made the sleeve ideal for beginners and experienced folks. More importantly, the mild texture simplifies cleaning, making the black Fleshlight easier to maintain than the other complex models. Anna Foxxx’s case had lines running across the body, adding a bit of traction and making handling the often ‘slidy’ plastic structure more manageable.
• Build Quality: Like other Fleshlights we tested, Anna Foxxx showcased the best engineering, though in a simplistic form. The high-quality SuperSkin material and rugged ABS plastic morphed into a reliable and durable masturbation toy. In addition, the impressive attention to detail was evident from the get-go, with the high-spec detailing on the sleeve and case.

Features:

• Material: SuperSkin
• Length: 8″
• Girth: 7.5″

Pros:

• Outstanding anal sleeve.
• It is ideal for people who love African-American beauties.
• Impressive build quality.
• Realistic detailing with a wrinkled entry point.
• The repeated texture is suitable for edging and stamina training.
• Ideal for beginners and experienced users.
• The sleeve is easier to clean than other models.

Cons:

• Beginners will find it expensive.
• Experienced folks might find the texture underwhelming.

View On Fleshlight

3. Misty Stone Desire: Most Variation!

Why we love Misty Stone Desire:

Misty Stone is the most intense black Fleshlight, thanks to the multiple texture variations throughout the sleeve. The luscious bubble butt guarantees a scintillating experience from the second the tip slides through the orifice.

Stone’s multiple textures (image below) hug the penis warmly, subjecting you to a whirlwind of emotions. “I loved how passionately the tight ribbed textures felt,” says Tim Larson. “The squeezing pleasure rings and waves stimulate the penis with each thrust, rendering the stroking action very exciting.”

The anal Fleshlight stood out as the most stimulating model in the article. It starts with a super tight entry welcoming you into a somewhat yielding section that gradually widens as you move into the second. Here, protruding bumps from all sides grind onto the penis during penetration, inducing a great deal of intense stimulation.

Stone’s third section included a smooth surface with two indented rows in between. Unlike the first two sections, it felt gentle and provided a welcome reprieve to the stroking action. Lastly, the last part consists of forward-facing prongs that push the member back as you penetrate the sleeve, making the experience more fun.

Overall, the texture variation in Misty Stone was the most exciting among the tested masturbators. The size and texture differences throughout the sleeve provided a formidable challenge to the user, making the stroking action sensational.

Like other Fleshlight masturbators in the article, Misty Stone’s realism degree was impressive. We loved the wrinkled entry and meaty cheeks on the sides. It adds to the organic feeling of penetrating your partner’s backside and makes the sleeve ideal for folks who prefer anatomically correct sex toys.

Lastly, the adjustable suction regulating cap at the base made adjusting the intensity during use easy. It got a little too tight with the cap fastened, and twisting it a little helped release the tension and make the thrusting motion more seamless.

Minor issues we found during testing:

A significant concern was the pricing. Misty Stone Desire costs $79.95, which most people will find expensive. If you’re looking for a simple masturbator for a quick wank, you’ll find the sleeve too pricey.

The varied texture is ideal for intense masturbation fans looking to take their self-pleasing needs to the next level. However, beginners and people with extra sensitive skin will find the sensations too much.

Why Misty Stone Desire has the most variation:

• Design: Misty Stone Desire’s unique design with multiple sections made it the most exciting model in the article. ‘The whirlwind of textures and undulating diameter throughout the sleeve rendered every thrusting action stimulating,” says Shane Davis. The adjustable suction regulating cap added a new dimension of excitement, allowing you to stretch your imagination and regulate the intensity with a slight movement.
• Stimulations: As stressed before, the stimulation was outstanding. The varied texture and changing diameter in the cavity amplified the sensations. In addition, the squishy SuperSkin material hugged the member warmly while the forward-facing bumps pushed the penis back during penetration, making the thrusting action more fun.

Features:

• Material: SuperSkin
• Length: 9.25″

Pros:

• The most intense masturbation sleeve.
• High-quality SuperSkin material.
• Varied texture makes the thrusting action more exciting.
• Impressive 9″+ insertable length is ideal for depth play fans.
• Adjustable suction regulating cap.
• Ultra-realistic design.

Cons:

• People with sensitive skin will find it over-stimulating.
• The price ($79.95) can be pricey for budget seekers.

View On Fleshlight

4. Private Super Sexy by CalExotics: Best Alternative!

Why we love Private Super Sexy:

If you want something different, Private Super Sexy is the best non-Fleshlight alternative. The compact masturbator is ideal for different users, including vacationers and regular users looking to add something exciting to their sex toy collection.

Unlike most models we reviewed, the sleeve’s compact design made it easy to use regardless of your experience. It felt incredibly cozy on the palm, and its lightweight build made the thrusting action straightforward. “People who find regular masturbators heavy after a while will love the Private Super Sexy’s light feel,” says Shane Davis.

The detailed pussy structure was a significant feature. Everything from the wrinkled orifice to the luscious lips and the intricate texture underlined the phenomenal attention to detail. Luckily, the cavity felt as good as it looked, thanks to the squishy TPR material and realistic texture.

Something else we loved about the masturbator was the discreet look. Besides the compact size, the testers highlighted how easy it was to conceal the sleeve. A quick sticker removal will pass the product for a shampoo bottle or a portable shave kit.

The small sticker at the base covers a small opening. Taking off the sticker uncovers the convenient vacuum control system, which you can regulate with your finger. “I enjoyed the sensations when I covered it with the finger, with bits of lessened suction pressure from simple movements,” says Shane Davis.

Private Super Sexy’s open-ended design simplifies cleaning and maintenance. Rinsing with warm, soapy water does the trick, and drying is quick. In addition, the sleeve is compatible with any water-based lubricant.

Minor issues we found during testing:

Unfortunately, the TPR material is porous, meaning you must take extra care to ensure the sleeve is thoroughly dry before storage.

Why Private Super Sexy is the best alternative:

• Design: Among the Fleshlight alternatives we tested, the Private Super Sex was the most outstanding name. The compactness made it easy to use, even for smaller hands. In addition, it felt incredibly cozy on the palm, and its lightweight build simplified the thrusting action.
• Size: The masturbator’s compact size and unique external detailing made it easy to use regardless of your experience. It was slim around the middle and broader near both ends, making wrapping the palm around it easy. The sleeve’s 8-inch long cavity was ideal for depth play fans.
• Stimulations: The Private Super Sexy’s texture stood out. We loved the detailed cavity, with the varied sections and differently-sized nubs throughout its length. It wasn’t the most intense in the article, but it was up there with the best pieces. The small opening around the base lets the user regulate the suction pressure with your finger, making the experience even more exciting.

Features:

• Material: TPR
• Length: 8″

Pros:

• The best Fleshlight sleeve alternative.
• Compact, easy-to-use structure.
• Squishy-feeling TPPR material.
• The intricate texture feels incredible.
• Suction pressure regulating opening.
• The discreet build will pass for a shampoo bottle.

Cons:

• Cleaning the TPR material can be tedious.

View On PinkCherry

5. THRUST Pro Elite Tiana: Black Hip Masturbator

Why we love THRUST Pro Elite Tiana:

THRUST Pro Elite Tiana performed incredibly well among the black hip masturbators we reviewed. Notably, the dual-stimulation product came with two orifices, rendering it perfect for kinky users seeking to switch between vaginal and anal sensations.

The dark chocolatey body is perfect for people fantasizing about gorgeous black women. Its realistic detailing with the soft butt cheeks and thick thighs is a sight to behold. In addition, the anal and vaginal orifices are realistic, spotting impressive details for keen masturbators.

Something else that stood out was the ribbed texture. The repeated pattern included constrictions between the pleasure chambers lined with mil, rounded nodes. It reminded me of the Stamina Training Unit (STU), with a unique hint of extra sensations.

Note: The masturbation product is sized to scale. Unlike the competing brands, the hip masturbator felt amazingly realistic. In addition, the weighty build added to the organic feeling while promoting a more stable, hands-free experience.

THRUST Pro Elite Tiana’s TPE body felt great on the hands. Unlike silicone, the fibers are looser, making the butt and hips jiggle to the rhythm of your stroking action. We loved that the waist size wasn’t exaggerated (27″ – 30″), making it easy to grasp even with the smallest hands, thus adding stability.

The intelligent positioning makes the hip masturbator ideal for the doggy-style sex position. The reviewers highlighted how the flat base simplified handling, making the product perfect for hands-free use.

Minor issues we found during testing:

My most significant concern was the size. The masturbator was the biggest in the article, and people who want a discreet model will have to look elsewhere. We recommend the Private Super Sexy by CalExotics if you’re going to keep your new affair a secret.

In addition, the TPE material is porous. The tiny microscopic holes on the body can trap water if unchecked, creating a breeding spot for bacteria. It takes more time and effort to clean and dry the hip masturbator.

Why THRUST Pro Elite Tiana is the best black hip masturbator:

• Design: THRUST Pro Elite Tiana’s super realistic build made it the best choice for folks seeking the most organic penetrative sex experience. The massive ass, thick thighs, and multiple orifices for vaginal and anal sex made it very stimulating. In addition, the canals were uniquely textured and sized, rendering the sensations super realistic.
• Stimulations: As stressed before, the sensations were impressive. The unique detailing for both orifices made the experience of switching between the vagina and anal sleeve super intense. As anticipated, the anus was tighter, adding to the realism aspect. More importantly, the repeated pattern ensured no one was left behind, including folks with a smaller-than-average member.
• Build Quality: The attention to detail was phenomenal. We loved how everything about the hip masturbator felt well thought out and executed. The TPE body felt great on the hands, while the design with a flat base allowed for hands-free use.

Features:

• Material: TPE
• Length: 7.5″ (Vagina), 5.5″ (anal cavity)

Pros:

• Incredibly designed hip masturbator.
• Phenomenal realism.
• Squishy, responsive TPE material.
• Uniquely designed vaginal and anal cavities.
• Hands-free design.

Cons:

• It might be too heavy for beginners.
• Cleaning and maintenance can be tedious.

View On Lovehoney

What Is A Black Fleshlight?

A  black Fleshlight is a male masturbator designed to simulate realistic oral, anal, and vaginal sex. Unlike regular sleeves, the black sleeves feature an overall dark tone and the material ranges between pure black and chocolate in color.

How To Use A Black Fleshlight?

Using a black Fleshlight is no different from the other popular Fleshlights. So, once you’ve unboxed and cleaned up the masturbator, I recommend using a sleeve warmer to get the sex toy warm and ready. You can also use warm water or an electric blanket.

Once everything is ready, pour a generous amount of water-based Fleshlight lube on the orifice and yourself. In addition, re-apply the lube as necessary, and don’t forget to try different positions and angles to keep things sweet and spicy.

Here’s more on how to use your black Fleshlight.

Maintenance and Cleaning Tips

Cleaning your Fleshlight regularly is an excellent maintenance tip. Use a sex toy cleaner or antibacterial soap to remove dirt before rinsing it with clean water. In addition, dry the sleeve entirely and dust it with Renewing powder to keep it looking and feeling fresh.

Once it’s clean, store the Fleshlight black girl in a clean space free from damp conditions. More importantly, please keep it away from prying eyes and hands.

Learn more tips on Fleshlight cleaning, drying, and storage here.

Tim

• Author
• Recent Posts

Tim Larson

Tim is our male sex toy expert, and he has reviewed close to a hundred products. He also worked as an English teacher in Japan throughout his twenties, where he gained extensive knowledge of Japanese sex toys and Shibari. He has been featured in Vice.com, among other things.
Reddit | Medium

Latest posts by Tim Larson (see all)

• 16 Best Sex Toys For Men 2024, REALLY Tested! [VIDEO Reviews] - April 18, 2024
• 18 Best Automatic Male Masturbators 2024, REALLY Tested [Video] - March 22, 2024
• Shibari 101 – A Beginners Guide to Japanese Rope Bondage - March 17, 2024