We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.
Are you a newbie looking to explore prostate stimulation? Or maybe you’re an anal play pro looking to up your game? Whoever you are, you came to the right place because here we are talking prostate massagers!
We spent 6 years and hundreds of hours testing the most popular products, and we firmly believe Lelo Loki Wave 2 is the right choice for most consumers. Besides being one of the strongest among our test samples, the Loki Wave 2 stayed in place the longest during play, making it the ideal choice for hands-free play.
Test Winner: Lelo Loki Wave 2
Lelo Loki Wave 2 got the highest rating in our review. Our testers loved the ergonomic design, the smoothly curved shaft, and the tapered tip. The unique stimulation with vibrations and come-hither fingering also stood out. Code AFF-MSTG10 for 10% off!
Non-Vibrating: Aneros Helix Syn Trident
The reviewers appreciated the medium-sized and contoured body, which was superior to other non-vibrating models we tested. The small size and rounded head simplify penetration and make it ideal for people seeking a filling dual penetration experience.
App-Controlled: Lovense Edge 2
Lovense Edge 2 is most effective for long-distance and public play because of the excellent Lovense remote app. It bridges the gap for long-distance couples while offering numerous possibilities for every rectum play fan. It also had the strongest vibrations.
Why You Should Trust Us
Hi, Tim Larson here. My wife Sandra and I started up My Sex Toy Guide back in 2016, and now I’m running it as the CEO. We started this as a passion project to share our thoughts on pleasure products, and it turns out that a lot of us want to learn more about sex toys and sexual health! My Sex Toy Guide is now one of the biggest, best, and most reputable sexual wellness resources on the Internet; we currently have a dedicated, knowledgeable team of testers and researchers, and a library of over 1,000 product reviews.
We are proud to uphold the values that we started with, and integrity is at the top of this list. We buy all of the toys we test the same way that you buy your toys; we do not accept free products to sway a review. Now, to be transparent, we are a business and we make money from affiliate links; however, we only feature (or promote) products that we genuinely believe are the best.
How We Picked The Products
I made a questionnaire and shared it among my colleagues at My Sex Toy Guide. Then, I used the responses to pick the models that appeared the most before combining them with the P-spot toys I’ve come to love over the years. I distributed the review samples to the testing party (Shane Davis and me) and defined test criteria that we could measure on a scale from 0 to 100. These included the following:
- Design. Like G-spot vibrators, prostate massagers must have a curved body to enhance precision. In addition, a tapered design helps to simplify insertion. We ensured the models we reviewed featured these admirable features and others to improve your user experience.
- The ideal Size depends on your experience and stimulation preference. For instance, a beginner would go smaller on the scale. Similarly, a girth play fan will prefer a chunky anal toy compared to a depth play fan who wants a long shaft.
- Everyone loves a versatile sex toy. I advised the team to prioritize models with a versatile design, including perineum stimulation.
- We always pay more attention to vibrating models with multiple vibration settings. The more, the better.
- We also reviewed P-spot vibrators with more forms of stimulation. Besides vibration capabilities, we looked into thrusting, inflatable, and rimming models.
- Build Quality. All the prostate massagers we reviewed had to be made from high-quality, body-safe materials like silicone, stainless steel, and borosilicate glass.
- Special Features. Standout features we paid attention to include a waterproof design, wireless remote control, and a dedicated mobile app for simplified close-range and long-distance handling.
During testing, we rated each test criterion on a percentage scale from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). We then calculated the overall score using different weighted metrics depending on the importance of the test criteria. Half the total rating comes from Design (25%) and Stimulation (25%). After that come Size (10%), Build Quality (10%), and Settings (10%).
The team returned with the reports after the 35-day testing session. It took almost 28 hours to analyze and summarize the findings, so I firmly believe these are this year’s best prostate massagers!
1. LELO Loki Wave 2: Our Overall Test Winner!
Why we love LELO Loki Wave 2:
After the dust settled, our testers ranked LELO Loki Wave 2 as the best prostate massager we reviewed. The primary motivation was the dual-motor design that tickled the prostate gland and perineum in equal measure, building the foundation for intense dual stimulation. This was an astounding feature that no other product had.
The dual-stimulation design includes a 4″ prostate shaft and rumbly arm for the perineum (image below). “I especially loved the inner arm’s angled design with a bulbous body that feels incredibly filling and a tapered head to simplify insertion,” our lead product tester, Shane Davis, wrote in his test report. “Another standout design feature was the slim neck, which, coupled with the bulbous body, made Loki Wave 2 stay inside comfortably,” Shane continued.
The team agreed the silicone and ABS plastic marriage came out perfectly. Unlike most other sex toys made with two materials, the seams looked great and didn’t have the annoying dips that trap dirt and bacteria, making cleaning more tedious than necessary. Bravo LELO!
The ten vibration functions were another highlight of our review. The testers especially appreciated that there was a trackable graduation in power, making customizing the rumbles more fun.
Let’s move on to the highlight: LELO Loki Wave 2’s come-hither technology, which everyone agreed was an incredible feature. “The inner prober simulates the index finger movements during fingering while inside so that prostate stimulation comes from repeatedly tapping the gland and not vibrating only,” Tim Larson explained.
The whole team heaped praise on the variation in prostate and perineum stimulation. The fingering and vibrations created an exciting blend of sensations and gave the user multiple options to customize the experience. We can’t really describe this in words. It has to be experienced. (Yes, it’s that good).
Lastly, we also thought the control interface was intuitive. The five buttons (image above) are well-labeled and easy to reach. While we usually prefer raised buttons because they’re more responsive, LELO did a great job implementing the controls. In addition, the 10 settings give you a degree of control even without the separate buttons for both motors; some settings turn off the prostate and perineum motor, so you can enjoy either at a time.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Some people will find the $189 price tag for LELO Loki Wave 2 too high. Even with the impressive features, more affordable options like Lovehoney High Roller exist.
In addition, people with mobility issues will find it hard to reach the buttons because of their positioning near the base. A mobile phone application or remote controller would’ve been a great addition, especially for something that costs almost $200.
If you want to see what Lelo Loki Wave 2 looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Medical-grade silicone & ABS plastic
- Diameter: 1.47″
- Insertable Length: 3.9″
Pros:
- The most powerful prostate massager.
- Outstanding dual-action design.
- The bulbous shaft with a tapered head promotes intense prostate orgasms.
- It has multiple settings to explore.
- Impressive come-hither motion.
- The USB-rechargeable Loki Wave 2 is waterproof.
Cons:
- Reaching the buttons can be a challenge for people with mobility issues.
- Size queens might find the dimensions underwhelming.
2. Aneros Helix Syn Trident: Best Non-Vibrating!
Why we love Aneros Helix Syn Trident:
Aneros Helix Syn Trident might be non-vibrating, but we still believe it’s a versatile piece for solo players and couples. “I was initially hesitant because it looked smaller in real life than on the box. However, as soon as I placed it on my palm, I knew it was big enough to offer a formidable challenge”, Tim Larson reported.
The design has some noticeable features. It has a bulkier tip than the body (circled above). Even with the rounded design that significantly simplifies penetration, the testers liked the defiant tip, which amplified the sensations when coupled with the notches on the inner arm.
The material is silky silicone, giving it a flexible and durable consistency. The extra squish makes the massager beginner-friendly, and we believe it’s a good choice for the majority of consumers.
Something that stood out was the two tiny arms meant to enhance the sex toy’s safety. While they looked weak, my colleagues found them sufficient and up to the task. They also noted that the upward angle exerted pressure on the perineum and the kundalini. The arms are slim, meaning they easily fit between your ass cheeks. Solid design choices overall.
The testers also reported how easy it was to use the Aneros prostate massager. Shane Davis summarized his experience like this: “The silicone body is firm enough to enhance penetration but squishy to glide through the tight anal hole. In addition, the elongated arms made it easy to guide the massager through to the prostate and retrieve it after I was done. And without buttons to learn and settings to acclimatize, Aneros is foolproof”.
How was the size? Well, the 4″ insertable length and 3″ circumference make it a medium-sized prostate tickler. That, plus the squishy silicone material, makes Aneros Helix Syn Trident the most effective non-vibrating prostate massager for most users.
Minor issues we found during testing:
You might have to look elsewhere if you’re after a sophisticated device with bells and whistles like rumbly motors and intense prostate massage. Aneros Helix Syn Trident is a non-vibrating sex toy maneuvered with your hands.
We also think the small size might be underwhelming for experienced anal play users.
If you want to see what Helix Syn Trident looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Circumference: 3″
- Usable Length: 4″
Pros:
- A bulbous body amplifies internal stimulation.
- The rounded head simplifies penetration.
- It’s made from body-safe and easy-to-clean silicone.
- Elongated retrieval arms.
- Ideal for anal sex beginners.
Cons:
- The small size might be underwhelming to experienced users.
3. Lovense Edge 2: Long-Distance Play (And Strongest)
Why we love Lovense Edge 2:
Lovense Edge 2 is the most recommended model for people in long-distance relationships. It was also the strongest prostate massager on this list, making it perfect for our power-hungry readers.
The second-generation Edge features a redesign with an adjustable arm for precise stimulation (image below) and an upgraded Bluetooth chip for better long-distance connectivity. Other improvements from the original Lovense Edge included the enhanced battery life and magnetic charging port for extended vibrations, as well as a simplified charging experience. Everyone agreed they were some solid upgrades.
Besides the solo power button that helps cycle through the preset patterns, it’s compatible with the Lovense Remote app. The intuitive smartphone app makes it easy for long-distance partners to regulate each other’s sex toys over Wi-Fi. Unlike the onboard interface, you can create new patterns and store ten favorites for later use. You can also sync the vibrations to your Spotify playlist (this feature was great!). Other impressive mobile app features include multi-toy sync and unlimited customization options.
While the Bluetooth prostate massager felt stiff in the hands, the testers found it flexible with a little push. The stiffness is actually a benefit. You see, once you get it into the right shape, it remains in position throughout the play. But we recommend pressing it gently until you get your desired anal stimulation, taking care to avoid any damage. You should also adjust the toy outside the body for optimal results.
The Edge 2 retains its shape, and you don’t have to re-route it again – just once, and you’re set. Moving the tip furthest to an almost perpendicular position was the most comfortable and thrilling.
The Lovense Edge 2 motor churns out powerful vibrations, which impressed the team members. Unlike most prostate massagers we reviewed, each vibration pattern—low, medium, and high had its distinct rumble type, and we could feel the change when transitioning from one to another. Even the four modes—pulse, wave, fireworks, and earthquake—had a distinct ‘flavor,’ making it easy to enjoy the pleasures that came with each one.
Something else that stood out was the dual-motor design. Lovense Edge 2 has two motors – one on the base and the other in the head for coordinated prostate and perineum stimulation. With 4 patterns and 3 speeds to explore, we found the vibrations among the strongest on this list.
Pro Tip: We recommend setting the vibrations on the prostate and external arm at different levels. If you max out both, they wash each other out, and you don’t have a distinguishing factor that makes the dual-motor design stand out.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Lovense Edge 2 is somewhat loud, and public play fans might have to look elsewhere.
Another concern was the stiff body. If you’re not experienced with anal sex toys, you’ll have to sit this out. It could be squishier, and I’d recommend it to the most experienced anal sex fans.
If you want to see what the Lovense Edge 2 looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Diameter: 1.38″
- Usable Length: 3.5″
Pros:
- Intuitive and action-packed Lovense Remote app.
- Impressive dual-motor design for amplified stimulation.
- The adjustable design enhances precise prostate massage.
- A lovely range of vibration patterns.
- The app supports video chat, music sync, and sexting.
Cons:
- It’s somewhat loud.
- Lovense Edge might not be ideal for beginners.
You can find more of our Lovense reviews here.
4. LELO Hugo 2: Best Remote Control!
Among the most exciting aspects we loved about LELO HUGO 2 was the redesigned remote control (image below), which stood out. The all-silicone body felt great on the hands, and the well-calculated indents on the buttons made it easy to track the experience even when multitasking.
Unlike most review samples, the remote controller’s dimensions were ideal for different users, including those with smaller palms. On top of that, the remote controller introduced cutting-edge SenseMotion technology, making the experience even better. Once turned on, the feature lets you regulate the vibration settings by flicking the wrist.
The second-generation prostate vibrator also offered the option of a remote control or an app-controlled option. We reviewed the former, which was comparatively easy to pair and use. Unfortunately, you can only use one and not both. If you get the version with a mobile app, it doesn’t come with a remote control, and vice versa, which was a bit confusing.
Let’s talk about the sensations next. HUGO 2’s dual-motor build made the rumbly vibrations more intense on both ends, the prostate and perineum. According to the website, it was 20% more powerful than its predecessor, and the intensity was evident on the first try. “The vibrations were rumbly from the first setting to the last,” says Shane Davis. “The intense rumbles on both the perineum and prostate tickle the sensitive nerve endings, culminating in satisfying internal and external stimulations.”
The re-engineered design was another highlight of the review. Combining the tapered inner arm, a slimmer neck, and a flexible body made the vibrator completely hands-free. Retaining it inside was easy compared to the other names we tested, and it felt comfortable even when worn for extended periods.
LELO HUGO 2’s dimensions were ideal for intermediate prostate massage fans (you can see how it compares to the other review samples in the image below). The tapered head was easy to insert, and the curved design of the external arm clung onto the perineum for direct stimulation. More importantly, the all-silicone body felt cozy inside with the flexible build, allowing easy adjustments to hit the sweet spots.
How about the build quality? Overall, the silicone felt comfortable, and the non-porous feature simplified cleaning. On the other hand, the ABS section added a feeling of class and ruggedness that made the butt plug appealing to look at. “I used the original HUGO, and it felt a little uncomfortable after a few minutes,” says Shane Davis. “The new model combined a tapered design, comfortable materials, and a flexible body, making it ideal for extended wear during penetrative sex,” Shane continued.
Minor issues we found during testing:
The new HUGO 2 model comes in two versions: a remote and an app-controlled option. Unlike most hybrid toys, you can only use one and not both at the same time. If you buy the former, you can’t pair it with the LELO app; the app-controlled model doesn’t come with the remote controller.
We reviewed the remote-controlled model, which didn’t offer independent motor control, which was a bummer. In addition, the button orientation wasn’t as intuitive as anticipated, and it was a little complicated to get the buttons right because the functions were backward when the remote was turned, so the buttons were on top.
Lastly, the remote-controlled model costs $219, while the app-controlled option is $179. While the former has cutting-edge SenseMotion technology, regular prostate massage fans will find the price too expensive.
If you want to see what LELO HUGO 2 looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone & ABS plastic
- Insertable Length: 2.83″
- Dimensions: 4.1″ x 4.2″ x 1.6″
Pros:
- Well-designed remote control butt plug.
- User-friendly control interface.
- Phenomenal build quality.
- Intense rumbly vibrations.
- You can also buy the app-controlled model.
- Body-safe silicone and ABS plastic materials.
Cons:
- The remote control is not waterproof.
- LELO HUGO 2 remote is pricier than the app-controlled model.
5. Hot Octopuss PleX with flex: Most Customizable!
Why we love Hot Octopuss PleX with flex:
Hot Octopuss PleX with flex is the most customizable prostate massager we reviewed because of the innovative Treble and Bass technology. Everyone was excited to try it out, and we weren’t disappointed. “I enjoyed the bass more because of the rumbly reverberation, which I found more impactful than the sharp treble buzzes,” Tim Larson commented.
The testers also appreciated the motor separation with the treble at the tip and the bass motor in the middle. The differentiation induced an exciting balance, ensuring the rumbles were spread evenly. With five pleasure settings and patterns, there was an excellent range of vibration combinations to explore (You can see the control panel in the image below).
It took a while before everyone figured out the ideal setting for me, but as soon as they picked the rhythm, experimenting with both motors was an adventure. While adding independent control would be a game-changer, they had a blast!
Something else that stood out was the wide body, rounded head, and slim neck (circled in blue below). The well-thought-out build meant the massager enhanced a feeling of fullness during play while promoting precise prostate stimulation. It has a 5.5″ length, so you can be sure it’ll go all the way.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, Hot Octopuss PleX with flex might be too expensive for beginners on a budget. It costs $99.95, and people who are after a cheap prostate massager will have to look elsewhere.
Also, I wouldn’t say I liked that I couldn’t independently regulate the treble and bass motors. Separating the functionality would have been the icing on the cake.
If you want to see what PleX looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone, ABS
- Diameter: 0.7 – 1.2″
- Length: 5.5″
Pros:
- The most customizable prostate massager.
- Remarkable Treble and Bass technology.
- Well-thought-out build quality.
- Intuitive wireless remote control.
- It has a wide range of vibration combinations.
- The vibrator is fully waterproof.
Cons:
- Hot Octopuss PleX doesn’t have independent motor control.
- It’s pricey – $99.95.
6. njoy Pure Wand: Best Metal Prostate Massager!
Why we love njoy Pure Wand:
Are you looking for something more heavy-metal? Then you will like our next list entry: njoy Pure Wand, the top prostate massager made of metal. One end is more prominent (1.5″) compared to the smaller 1″ bulb (image above). The size variation made Pure Wand perfect for most users, as you could juggle between the two depending on your preference.
The testers found the 1″ end works great for warming up before you can turn it around and immerse the wider bulb. With the weighted metal feel, we found anal stimulation more profound with the njoy Pure Wand.
Something else that stood out was the curved body. “The curvature was slightly more pronounced than I’d anticipated, and it took a few tries to get the right rhythm,” our tester Rachel Sommer told me. “Once I was in tune with the curve and how to hold the massager, I found it easy to hit the prostate with minimal maneuvering. I usually combine my anal sex toys with a vibrator on the perineum for dual stimulation, and it took seconds to orgasm with the njoy Pure Wand”.
My colleagues couldn’t wait to try temperature play. Like other metal dildos, njoy Pure Wand’s stainless-steel material warms and cools to match the ambient temperature. We tried submerging it in warm and cold water for 10-15 minutes before play, and it felt great. “I prefer the warm after-effect because who wants an ice-cold metal dildo in their ass anyway,” Shane Davis reported.
Pro Tip: Once you submerge the njoy wand in warm water or leave it in the refrigerator, wait until it’s warm or cool enough for penetration. I usually do a hand test, placing the toy on the back of my hand – if it’s too hot or cold for the hand, it has no business in your ass.
Minor issues we found during testing:
While the weighted stainless-steel ends add to the sensation of pressure, a positive for such a small dildo, people with mobility issues and weak hands might find the weight problematic. In addition, the stainless steel might be uncomfortable for people with sensitive anal sphincters.
You might have to look elsewhere if you’re in the market for an affordable prostate massager. njoy Pure Wand costs $115 – $149.99, a price most people will find too much for a non-vibrating model.
People who prefer a rough texture or dual stimulation will be disappointed with the njoy Pure Wand.
If you want to see what Pure Wand looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Stainless Steel
- Diameter: 1″ and 1.5″
- Length: 8″ (end to end)
Pros:
- Differently sized bulbs add to the versatility.
- The sensual curve simplifies prostate massage.
- It’s ideal for temperature play.
- The weighted ends add to the sensation of pressure.
- It comes in an elegant, gift-ready package.
Cons:
- njoy Pure Wand is expensive – $$115 – $149.99.
- It might be underwhelming for those who prefer a textured shaft.
7. We-Vibe Vector: Best Hands-Free Model!
Why we love We-Vibe Vector:
We-Vibe Vector did a better job staying inside the anus than the other review samples on this list. Most team members reported that they didn’t need to re-adjust the starting position for it to be comfortable (unless you want to, of course). This motivated testers to give it a 96% rating for the hands-free aspect, making it a good option if you want to pair your prostate massage with other activities, such as penis masturbation or penetrative sex with a partner.
The team also noted that Vector has a joint at the edge where both arms meet, making it easy to adjust to the perfect angle for your body (image below). The testers found the joint elusive, so you might have to confirm, but changing the angle is straightforward once you locate it. On top of that, the joint is stiff and won’t give in once you get it to the desired angle.
We also think Vector is ideal for people new to anal play. The reason is the squishy silicone material with a tinge of firmness around the joint, which is ideal for novices. In addition, the vibrator is easy to use and offers multiple fun options to explore, especially with the mobile app.
The team ranked Vector as “Well-Constructed,” with everything from the flexible body to the all-silicone body and overall comfortable feel. The 3.5″ circumference and 4″ insertable length make a medium size perfect for most users, including those new to prostate stimulation. And with the tapered tip and slim neck, penetration is easy, and the toy feels incredibly cozy inside the ass.
As you can see in the image above, Vector has a remote control for simplified close-range control. While the controller’s design could be better – it felt slightly cheap, it makes it easy to cycle through the ten preset vibration settings. It also connects automatically with the prostate vibrator, so you don’t have to worry about the setup process.
With the mobile application, you can create different rhythms for each motor with the multi-control feature. This way, the prostate and perineum vibrations feel unique. Another way to use the We-Connect app to regulate the motors independently is by setting the music function so that one motor responds to bass while the other responds to treble.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, the We-Vibe Vector might be underwhelming for people after hard-hitting buzzing. Even with a dual-stimulation design, it offers soft rumbles perfect for a beginner or intermediate prostate massage fan.
There’s no outright way to regulate the two motors independently. It takes creativity, and you must use the mobile app to create different patterns or employ the music function.
If you want to see what the We-Vibe Vector looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Circumference: 4.5″
- Usable Length: 4″
Pros:
- A flexible design is easy to manipulate.
- Multiple control options: onboard interface, remote control, and mobile app.
- It’s made with squishy silicone material.
- The Vector is waterproof, but the remote is only splashproof.
- It comes with a storage pouch.
Cons:
- It might be underwhelming for more experienced folks.
- The remote control is battery-powered.
8. b-Vibe Rimming Plug: Best Rimming Sensation!
Why we love the b-Vibe Rimming Plug:
If you draw extra pleasure from anal rimming, the b-Vibe Rimming Plug will be a good option. While most people call it petite, the testers found it more of a medium sex toy than a small one. “Don’t get me wrong, newbies can use the anal toy comfortably, but so would an intermediate user looking to advance and test their limits,” Shane Davis told me.
The rimming sensation was unlike anything we’d experienced with a sex toy. Of course, its small size makes prostate massage impractical, but it perfectly simulates the feeling of oral stimulation. “My wife and I love eating each other’s butts out, and the b-Vibe Rimming Plug is the closest I’ve ever gotten to the real thing,” Tim Larson reported. “The rotating beads are dramatically accurate. And with a vibrating tip, I loved every bit of the experience,” Tim added.
Something else that stood out was the buzzy consistency. I’m not the biggest fan of the buzz, especially for a hands-free sex toy that’ll be in my ass as I carry on with my day. That’s a personal preference, though.
We also liked that the Rimming Plug had a wireless remote control that worked well from several feet away. The team found the buttons easy to push, sometimes too easy, which occasionally caused us to accidentally press the power button, turn the toy off, and start over again (I blame the lube on my hands).
Moving on to the motor, which has an excellent range of vibrations: 7 rotation and vibration modes with 6 intensity levels. Although you can’t regulate the rimming and vibration settings independently, we highly appreciate the variety.
Of course, I wasn’t expecting to orgasm from the rimming action, but the anal toy was an excellent addition for someone looking for a public play massager. I used it when having sex with my wife for more sensations.
Note: If you’re using it for public play, it gets uncomfortable after extended periods on the chair. The huge base (circled above) makes it anal sex friendly, but it can be uncomfortable if you sit on it for long – it’s better suited for public use if you won’t be on the chair.
Minor issues we found during testing:
The b-Vibe Rimming Plug is loud. It’s not the loudest we tested, but I don’t believe the whisper-quiet marketing ploy most reviews have brandished.
In addition, it’s not the most affordable option ($128 – $159.99), and you might have to try something cheaper if you’re not sure you’ll like an anal toy.
Lastly, you can’t regulate the rimming action and vibration patterns independently.
If you want to see what the b-Vibe Rimming Plug looks like and how to use it, please watch our unboxing and demonstration video below:
Features:
- Material: Silicone
- Circumference: 4.5″
- Insertable Length: 3″
Pros:
- An excellent range of vibration and rimming settings.
- The tapered design and flared base render it easy and safe to use.
- Handy remote control.
- It’s made from body-safe silicone material.
- Convenient storage case.
Cons:
- The anal vibe is not waterproof.
- It’s pricey – $128 – $159.99.
9. Lovehoney Booty Buddy: Our Budget Pick!
Why we love Lovehoney Booty Buddy:
Most of the budget options we tested were either uncomfortable, underpowered, or made of questionable materials. The Lovehoney Booty Buddy was the clear exception. For less than twenty dollars, it managed to outperform several toys that cost five times more. That is why we picked it as our best cheap prostate massager.
Our team found it to be one of the most accessible and user-friendly options we tested. As you can see in the image above, its shape is smartly curved to reach the prostate with minimal effort, and its slim body makes insertion easier for beginners. The firm silicone tip gives gentle pressure where it counts, and its T-bar base keeps it securely in place during movement. Unlike many low-cost plugs, the Booty Buddy is fully waterproof and made of body-safe silicone, so it can handle cleaning and repeated use without showing wear.
When we measured its vibration strength, it landed in the mid-range compared to the rest of our test group. The motor is buzzy rather than deep, but the frequency felt consistent and added just enough stimulation to make partnered play or solo exploration more exciting. Shane Davis, one of our testers, said that “it’s simple, reliable, and does exactly what you want it to without trying to be something it’s not.” For first-time users, that reliability matters more than fancy features.
The Booty Buddy also earned points for its versatility. It can be used externally as a small clitoral or perineum vibrator, and the bullet motor is removable, turning it into a standard silicone plug when vibration isn’t needed. During testing, we found that it stayed comfortable for longer wear than most of the budget plugs we reviewed. The short, ergonomic design prevents over-insertion while still pressing enough against the prostate to feel noticeable.
Ultimately, we chose the Booty Buddy because it fills an important gap in the market. Many people want to try prostate play without committing to a high-end, feature-filled toy, and this plug makes that possible. It’s inexpensive, discreet, and effective enough that even experienced users can appreciate its simplicity. Rachel Sommer, Ph.D., summed it up well when she said, “If you’ve been curious about anal play but didn’t know where to start, this little plug removes the intimidation factor completely.”
Minor issues we found during testing:
The vibration power may not satisfy those who prefer deeper rumbles, and the bullet can be tricky to remove from the silicone sleeve after use. The N battery type isn’t as common as AAA, so you may need to order extras. We also noticed that while it’s waterproof, the removable bullet should always be dried separately to prevent trapped moisture.
You can read our full Lovehoney Booty Buddy here.
Features:
- Insertable length: 3.5 inches
- Circumference: 2.75 inches
- Material: Body-safe silicone
- Power: Replaceable N battery, waterproof construction
Pros:
- Great value for under twenty dollars
- Curved shape targets the prostate effectively
- Comfortable and beginner-friendly
- Easy to clean and store
Cons:
- Vibrations are light and buzzy
- A bit difficult to remove the bullet for cleaning
- Uses an uncommon N battery
- Limited vibration range
Other Good Alternatives
Temptasia Rebellion Peg is a good choice for pegging and strap-on fans. The 5.75″ dildo’s flat base slots into most standard-sized O-rings, freeing your hands and giving you more freedom to explore other body positions and enhance the quality of sensations The testers especially loved the anal vibrator‘s smooth finish: “The texture-free shaft was convenient for such a chunky anal dildo, making it ideal for intermediate and experienced users,” Tim Larson commented.
If you’re a glass dildo fan, you should check out Icicles No. 31, which is made out of glass. While it might not be the largest, I found the rigid glass an excellent challenge for intermediate and experienced users. On top of that, it has a tapered design to simplify insertion and a rounded body for a filling experience. And with the temperature-responsive borosilicate glass, the options are endless.
Anos RC is what we recommend if you want a thrusting motion. The testers loved its vibration and thrusting combo, two capabilities that made it an excellent choice for most users. Another highlight was the range of settings, including the 10 thrusting modes and 10 vibration patterns. We also liked the included remote control, which we thought added to its versatility.
But Why Should I Buy One?
A prostate massager is an ideal adult toy for prostate owners. Besides massaging your sensitive nerve endings-rich prostate gland for intense sensations, a prostate massage can potentially help ease pressure and swelling by releasing fluids that build up in the prostate.
In addition, some men even claim they receive more sexual pleasure and ejaculation after prostate massages. However, more studies need to be done to verify this claim.
Types of Prostate Massagers
- Prostate massagers come in different shapes and sizes, but most follow a universal design: a curved shaft with a narrow tip to provide direct prostate stimulation.
- Most massagers are either vibrating or non-vibrating, with the main difference being the degree of stimulation. Vibrating anal toys use a motor with a rechargeable battery to stimulate your p-spot, while non-vibrating (also called manual) models require that you move your sphincter muscle to experience prostate stimulation.
- A prostate stimulator is also either internal or external. Internal prostate massagers are inserted into the anus to stimulate the prostate directly. On the other hand, external prostate massagers are small devices men use while sitting. They work as a perineum stimulator (the area between the scrotum and the anus) while sitting. (Read more about a taint massage here.)
How To Use A Prostate Massager?
- First, position yourself at the right angle to promote easy access to your rectum muscles. The best position for using a prostate massager is lying on your back, bending your knees, and pulling your feet towards your butt. This way, you can easily reach your rectum and slide the butt toy through. The fetal position works well, too.
- Make sure you apply plenty of lubricant to the toy and the sphincter. Please only use water-based lube for silicone toys, but if you have a non-silicone toy, like glass or metal, you can use silicone-based lube.
- Once the toy is inside, navigate it slowly until you feel it against your prostate gland. You will know when it lands on the prostate by the difference in sensation.
- I recommend you have soothing music playing in the background and switch off any other electronics in the room to avoid unnecessary distractions.
- Relax, lie back, and close your eyes for at least 20 minutes to give the body ample time to adjust and the muscles down there to relax.
- After the initial 20 minutes, it’s time to work out your prostate muscles. Start your Kegel exercises by contracting and releasing your pelvic floor muscles.
- It’s similar to when you stop urination in midstream. The contraction and relaxation of the pelvic muscles control how you urinate.
- Similarly, hold the contraction and then release it multiple times after a few seconds.
As expected, the first few sessions of holding and releasing the muscles will cause your muscles to get tired impulsively since they are not used to the exercise. But the more you exercise the muscles, the more resilient they become.
As you develop the muscles, ass play becomes more enjoyable and seamless to achieve p-spot orgasm.
You can exercise these muscles from anywhere—for example, practice contraction and relaxation in the office chair or on the couch at home. If the muscles get tired, take a break and resume when ready.
With some discipline and practice, the whole experience will be the most pleasurable thing you’ve ever done.
Pro Tip: If you’re new to prostate milking, don’t expect to achieve prostate orgasm after the first attempt. It takes a while!
For more information on using anal toys, please check out our guide on how to use a prostate massager.
How Does A Prostate Orgasm Feel Like?
While many people perceive a P orgasm to originate from the genitals, it begins with a warm feeling throughout my midsection. The sensation from the abdomen is transferred to my genitals and soon overtakes my body [2].
I’ll experience some form of uncontrollable quivering, making me arch my back and lose track of what is going on with my body. There’s nothing you can do but let it go and enjoy the ride.
In total, they last somewhere between seconds and a few minutes, but it’s followed by a relaxation of the body and mind for a couple of hours.
Can I Hurt Myself When Using One?
Yes, if you’re not following the instructions, you may be too rough and end up hurting yourself. In addition, your rectum may harbor harmful bacteria, so proper cleaning between uses is essential so you don’t spread them. You should never go from the anus to other orifices, like a vagina or mouth.
Note: Before trying your new prostate massager, you should always consult your healthcare provider for personalized advice.
Happy vibing!
Tim
Reddit | Medium | Amazon
- How To Connect Lovense Toys to Adult Time? With Screenshots - April 24, 2026
- How to Connect Lovense Toys to a PC? Easy Step-by-Step Guide - April 23, 2026
- How to Connect Lovense Toys to a Mac Computer? - April 22, 2026
