Fisting dildos come in different designs, including those with a balled-up fist or stretched fingers, and the ideal model will depend on your preferred length, circumference, and style.
After testing 15 products over the past year, we firmly believe that Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist is the highest-rated fisting dildo. The colossal hand features detailed fingers and realistic knuckles that feel more stimulating than the competition. I was skeptical about the balled-up fist, but the thumb-first design offers slight tapering for easy penetration. In addition, the slender wrist and Sil-A-Gel material make the Belladonna’s Bitch Fist easy to handle and exciting to use for extended periods. Highly recommended!
Test Winner: Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist
Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist got the highest rating in our review with an impressive 8-inch insertable length. We especially loved the thumb-first design, with the thumb out first for easier insertion. Discount code MSTG15 for 15% off!
Beginners: Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand
Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand is the most effective fisting toy for beginners. We loved the graduation finger shaping to enhance penetration. We’ve used numerous fisting sex toys, and none was easier to insert as this one.
Table Of Contents
- Why You Should Trust Us
- How We Picked the Products
- Everything We Tested
- 1. Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist: Test Winner!
- 2. Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand: Beginner-Friendly
- 3. LeLuv 3D Printed Fisting Action Dildo: Most Customizable
- 4. King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch: Penis-Shaped
- 5. Cock Locker: Inflatable Fisting Dildo
- 6. Lynx Stimulating Glove: Fisting Glove
- What Is A Fisting Dildo?
- How To Use Your Fisting Dildo
- How to Choose Your Fisting Dildo (Buyers Guide)
Why You Should Trust Us
Rachel Sommer has been reviewing sex toys for more than a decade, and fisting dildos make up a considerable percentage of her collection. “There’s something about the mammoth size and detailed finish on the fingers and knuckles that make these gentle giants stand out,” she starts. “Advanced stretching pleasure seekers will enjoy the often brutal yet satisfying experience.”
The team has reviewed over 300+ sex toys, including many fisting dildos. So the combined expertise and industry experience make this article the most thorough and informative on the Internet.
How We Picked the Products
Rachel assembled the team to discuss their personal experiences with fisting dildos. After picking the review samples, she highlighted the crucial factors influencing decision-making when buying a fisting dildo. The test criteria we could measure using well-defined quantitative metrics include the following:
- Build Quality. The team prioritized products made from hypoallergenic materials like medical-grade silicone. Silicone is the best sex toy material because of its non-porous and phthalate-free properties. While other materials like PVC and TPE are readily available, most are porous, making cleaning and maintenance tedious.
- Design. The design language was another essential consideration we had to make. As you’d expect, the best fisting toys are available in numerous shapes, and what works for you will depend on desired sensations and experience. We included different designs in this article to ensure something for everyone.
- Size. While fisting dildos are known to be enormous, the different model’s dimensions vary greatly. For this reason, we recommend looking into the length and girth when shopping for your model.
- Features. The team looked into features like the presence of a suction cup base or the easy-squeeze balls for inflatable models. Understandably, these models were pricier than the regular dildos, but the convenience is worth it.
- Controls/Handling. Another essential aspect we considered was the handling and user experience. Like other huge dildos, controlling your fisting dong can be daunting, especially if you have smaller hands. The team prioritized models made from grippy material and those with ergonomic, extended handles.
During testing, we rated each review sample based on the criteria listed above, starting from 0% (Worst) to 100% (Best). Each score was calculated using different weighted metrics depending on what we deemed most important. The majority of the total rating comes from Build Quality (30%) and Design (30%). After that comes Size (15%), Features (15%), Controls/Handling (5%), and Price (5%).
When the team returned with the reports, the team analyzed everything before summarizing the findings with comparison charts. We scoured the internet for other users’ reviews and accounts from vendor sites. From the multi-discipline deliberation and consumer-centered approach, we believe these are this year’s best fisting dildos.
Everything We Tested
In this chapter, you can see a comparison table with all the products we tested. As you can see, each row has the test criteria our team used during the testing. To make our testing process even more transparent, we also included the raw test data so you can see how the products performed with each test criteria.
| |  |  |  |  |
|
| Name | Bitch Fist | Hand | LeLuv | King Cock | Cock Locker | Lynx |
| Category | Best Overall | Beginners | Customizable | Penis-Shaped | Inflatable | Glove |
| Average Rating | 95% | 90% | 93% | 91% | 89% | 89% |
| Build Quality | 95% | 90% | 94% | 89% | 90% | 92% |
| Design | 96% | 92% | 90% | 90% | 89% | 95% |
| Settings | 90% | 89% | 87% | 91% | 85% | 82% |
| Sizes | 93% | 90% | 92% | 96% | 85% | 85% |
| Features | 91% | 89% | 88% | 87% | 88% | 89% |
| Controls/Handling | 93% | 95% | 94% | 90% | 90% | 89% |
| Price & Value | 94% | 95% | 92% | 87% | 90% | 88% |
| Price Tag | $44.99 | $44.99 | $14.99 - $34.99 | $129.99 | $39.99 | $27 |
| Material | PVC | PVC | Reinforced ABS | Soft Plastic | Latex | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPR) |
| Circumference | 9.5 inches | 8.25 inches | 2 – 2.25 inches | 10 inches | 3.5 – 6.5 inches | N/A |
| Insertable Length | 8 inches | 12 inches | 5.5 – 7.5 inches | 14 inches | 4.5 – 5.5 inches | N/A |
1. Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist: Test Winner!
Why we love Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist:
Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist is the perfect fisting dildo for experienced folks because of its 8-inch insertable length and 9.5-inch circumference. The testers especially loved the iconic thumb-first design, with the thumb striking out first for a gentle taper that simplifies insertion.
We would have loved it if the designers used silicone, but the Sil-A-Gel material did a good enough job. Especially for a $44.99 product, the material feels plush, and very few people will differentiate it from realistic silicone. The firm yet flexible material feels great on the hands, and when combined with the thumb-first design, it makes penetration fairly easy.
Something else that stood out was the incredibly realistic finish. Bitch Fist has detailed fingers and pronounced knuckles sculpted from a real-life porn star, Belladonna. The meticulous detailing and tapering give it an authentic look of a well-cared-for hand and forearm.
So how was it to use? Well, the team reported Bitch Fist packed a punch and our stretching fans will love the experience. It feels incredible on the arm, and so does it inside the vagina. “Tim and I are yet to try the dildo for anal exploration, but I’m pretty sure it’d feel great, but lots of caution must be practiced”, Sandra Larson wrote in her test report.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, the Sil-A-Gel material can be flimsy, and it can be hard to insert the fisting dildo in a squatting position. So you better be prepared with a fisting lube before giving this a try to make the insertion a whole lot easier.
In addition, cleaning the Bitch Fist can be a little tricky because of the grooves on the knuckles and fingers. Unlike silicone, it takes time and patience to clean the PVC-made fister.
Why Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist is the best fisting dildo:
- Design: Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist’s realistic features were rated higher than the other models we tested. The detailed fingers and pronounced knuckles give it an authentic look, making the experience more exciting. Most importantly, the designers used a thumb-first shape to give it a nice taper, making penetration straightforward.
- Size: Bitch Fist has a 9.5″ circumference and 8″ of insertable length, making it the perfect choice for experienced folks seeking intense stretching. While the girth could be better for a more stretching experience, the squishy material and hefty forearm feel incredible filling inside the vagina – most sex toy users will love the sensations.
- Price: Surprisingly, Bitch Fist only costs $44.99, a massive bargain for the impeccable design, uncanny realism, and well-thought-out dimensions. Again, it’s not the cheapest, but it offers excellent value for money.
Features:
- Material: PVC
- Circumference: 9.5″
- Insertable Length: 8″
Pros:
- A thoughtfully designed fisting design.
- Impressive realism.
- Detailed fingers and pronounced knuckles.
- The thumb-first design enhances penetration.
- Ideal for advanced fisting and stretching pleasure.
- Latex-free and odorless Sil-A-Gel.
Cons:
- Silicone would’ve been better.
- The flimsy feel makes insertion in a squatting position complicated.
2. Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand: Beginner-Friendly
Why we love Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand:
The testers loved Magic Hand’s intelligent design with a graduation finger shaping to enhance blissful penetration. We’ve used numerous fisting sex toy models and none felt as easy to insert as the Magic Hand.
At 11.75″ insertable length and 8.25″ circumference, the beginner-friendly dildo is slightly larger than Doc Johnson’s Bitch Fist. However, the graduating finger shape and the firm yet squishy PVC material enhance handling and make it easy to insert it. Most importantly, the hefty size is incredibly satisfying for beginners and experienced folks.
“I’ve used a dozen fisting dildos, and Belladonna’s Magic Hand is among the most authentic models on the market”, Rachel Sommer told me “Magic Hand is sculpted to match adult movie star Belladonna’s hand and forearm, adding an extra layer of realism to the experience”, Rachel added.
Besides ease of use, Belladonna’s Magic Hand costs $49.99, a considerably low price for the quality and design. Beginners and sex toy collectors will enjoy the convenience of getting a high-quality product without breaking the bank.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand can be frightening at first. It’s slightly bigger than the Bitch Fist, and the dimensions might be intimidating to the eyes of newbies. In addition, the fisting dildo is made from PVC. While it’s hypoallergenic and latex-free, silicone is the best sex toy material, and it’d have been better on the dildo.
Why Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand is the best for beginners:
- Design: Magic Hand has a unique shape with a graduating finger design not found on many other products. Unlike the close-fist fisting dildos, penetrating is more straightforward, making it excellent for beginners. Whether you want to explore vaginal or anal stretching, Magic Hand is perfectly designed.
- Price: The testers were surprised by the $44.99 price tag. “I think it’s a massive bargain for the well-sculpted fantasy dildo,” one test report said. “It provides an excellent value for money.” And for a beginner-friendly model, price is an incredible factor because newbies are looking for something that offers the most value without breaking the bank.
- Size: Magic Hand has an 8.25″ circumference and 12″ of insertable length, promoting fulfilling sensations. The extended length and relatively girthy shaft provide incredible balance for beginners to explore their possibilities without feeling overwhelmed.
Features:
- Material: PVC
- Circumference: 8.25″
- Insertable Length: 12″
Pros:
- Comparatively affordable – $44.99.
- The graduation finger shape is easy to insert.
- Ideal for fisting novices.
- The ultra-realistic design looks like the porn star Belladonna.
- Shower-friendly submersible material.
Cons:
- Silicone material would’ve been better.
- The extended forearm can be frightening at first.
3. LeLuv 3D Printed Fisting Action Dildo: Most Customizable
Why we love LeLuv 3D Printed Fisting Action Dildo:
LeLuv 3D Printed Fisting Action Dildo is the most customizable model on this list. The glowing dong offers more color and size options, making it easy to design the perfect fisting dildo regardless of experience and fetish. There are over twenty shades, ranging from pineapple to peach, grape, and blueberry. In addition, the sizes vary in length and girth, making it easy for beginners and experienced folks to pick their options. Plus, the pricing also changes with size so that a newbie pays less for the experience, a concept that’s fair and encouraging for someone new to fisting.
Something else that stood out was the iconic 3D-printed technology. The cutting-edge development adds to realism, so anatomically correct sex toy fans can enjoy a pristine, raw experience.
LeLuv 3D’s marble-like texture gives it an alluring, sparkly shine. And with the squishy material, it looks pleasing to the eyes and feels incredible inside you. “I went with the 7.5 x 2.25-inch toy and enjoyed every bit of the experience. It has a filling undertone very few dildos can recreate”, Rachel Sommer reported.
Note: You can also get the smaller 5.5 x 2 inches or the medium 6.5 x 2 inches models if you want something smaller.
LeLuv 3D pricing starts at $14.99, making it among the most affordable models in the article. Of course, that’s for the smallest size, but even the jumbo 7.5″ long model is only priced at $34.99.
Lastly, LeLuv 3D is made from waterproof and long-lasting materials, so you won’t have to worry about durability. Cleaning and overall maintenance are straightforward, ensuring you spend the most time on things that matter – having a great time. I also loved the fixed base because it gives it more stability during play, enhancing the user experience.
Minor issues we found during testing:
My most significant concern was the material: reinforced ABS plastic. While it might be sturdy and long-lasting, I’d have preferred if the designers used medical-grade silicone.
Why LeLuv 3D Printed Fisting Action Dildo is the most customizable:
- Size: The testers were excited by LeLuv 3D Printed fisting dildo’s dynamism. It’s available in three size options and endless colors, which was highly praised by the team. Whether you’re a beginner looking to explore anal and vaginal stretching or an experienced folk out to experience the wildest, LeLuv 3D offers something for everyone.
- Design: LeLuv’s 3D printed design gives it an authentic touch and makes it as realistic as a hand and forearm can be. The marble-like texture, lightweight build, and waterproof material enhance the user experience while promoting long-lasting use.
Features:
- Material: Reinforced ABS
- Circumference: 2″ – 2.25″
- Insertable Length: 5.5″ – 7.5″
Pros:
- Outstanding customization options.
- Three sizes and endless colors.
- Realistic 3D-printed design.
- The marble-like texture is appealing to the eyes.
- It’s made from 100% waterproof materials.
- A fixed base enhances handling.
Cons:
- Switching the ABS for silicone would’ve been a game-changer.
- The sturdy material might be brutal for people with an ultra-sensitive vagina.
4. King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch: Penis-Shaped
Why we love King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch:
King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch is the most realistic penis for fisting dildo fans. The massive dong looks like your penis – it confused even me when I unboxed mine.
Everything from the texture to the rounded head and lifelike testicles looks like a human penis. The high-level authenticity offers a well-measured mix of practicality and visual appeal. Whether you want the veined shaft look or the squishy balls feeling, the Mega Girthy 14-inch monster provides you the best of both worlds.
Besides the penis shape, the team loved that it came with a sturdy suction cup base for improved user experience. Handling massive dildos is always a problem, especially for people with mobility issues or small hands, and adding a suction base is a sure way to tackle the inconvenience.
Unlike other models we tested, the suction cup base is made with a flexible material, making it easy to press it against a flat surface to get as much air out (the suction cup was about 13% stronger than the closest competitor). In addition, the suction cup holds a considerable air volume, further enhancing the pressure and ensuring King Cock doesn’t come off the surface during use.
The 10″ circumference and 14″ insertable length make it perfect for girth and depth play fans. I was amazed at the incredible filling experience when I pushed King Cock a few inches in. The gradual stretching from the tapered design and the eventual feeling of fullness makes for a formidable combo most people should aspire to experience.
Lastly, King Cock is harness-compatible. You’ll need a 3-inch O-ring diameter to use it with your favorite harness.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch’s massive girth and authentic balls can complicate handling. If you don’t want to use the suction cup base, regulating the thrusting motion means using both hands, thus limiting your ability to multi-task and tickle other erogenous body parts during sex, like the clitoris, for heightened pleasure.
If this issue is a deal breaker for you, we recommend finding alternatives in this list of best thick dildos.
Why King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch is the most realistic fisting dildo:
- Design: King Cock Mega Girthy 14 Inch’s realistic penis shape makes it perfect for sex toy users that love anatomically-correct dildos. for their stretching sesh. Everything from the natural veins to the rounded head and wrinkled balls makes it ripe for the picking. The slight tapering with the pointed head and gradually widening body makes insertion straightforward while promoting a gradual stretching experience.
- Size: The massive 10″ circumference and 14″ insertable length make it a preserve of the most experienced users. The gigantic size and realistic build render it practical and exciting for fun seekers.
- Features: King Cock Mega Girthy’s suction cup base was a great addition by the designers. Unlike other models we tested, it was the most robust because of the flexible material around the base. In addition, the scoop around the base is enormous, thus trapping more air and providing more potent suction.
Features:
- Material: Soft Plastic
- Circumference: 10″
- Insertable Length: 14″
Pros:
- The most realistic fisting dildo.
- It’s an incredibly satisfying stretching experience.
- The rounded head and wrinkled balls look like a natural penis.
- It has a robust suction cup base.
- King Cock is easy to clean and maintain.
Cons:
- The massive size and realistic balls complicate handling.
5. Cock Locker: Inflatable Fisting Dildo
Why we love Cock Locker:
Cock Locker is a medium-sized inflatable dildo for people new to fisting and stretching. The 9″ long dong inflates to a maximum 9″ circumference for thrilling inflation play.
The team loved the realistic detailing on the shaft. Unlike other inflatable model we reviewed, I enjoyed the lifelike veins, rounded penis head, and the smooth yet well-defined coronal ridge.
Something else that stood out was the massive size. Cock Locker balloons from 4.5″ to 5.5″ -inches long with a few squeezes, providing a gradual yet satisfying filling experience for depth play fans. In addition, it widens from 3.5″ to 6.5″ inches in circumference for the ultimate stretching sensations.
The hand pump was also easy to use. It feels incredibly cozy on the palm, and the lightweight build means you only need a few squeezes to get started. In addition, it has a quick-release valve for safety – press it once, and the entire air inside jets out.
Minor issues we found during testing
Please be aware that Cock Locker is a latex fisting dildo. Besides being less flexible than silicone, most people have a latex allergy. Ensure you don’t have one before buying the Cock Locker.
If you do have one but you still want some inflatable dildo action, we have other recommendations for you in our inflatable dildo review.
In addition, King cock doesn’t inflate uniformly, and more air is accommodated near the head or the base. It’s not much of a problem for me, but my ADHD friends don’t like the imbalance.
Why Cock Locker is the best Inflatable Fisting Dildo:
- Design: The Cock Locker’s realistic detailing makes it stand out. Everything from the lifelike veins to the rounded penis head and the smooth and well-defined coronal ridge gives it a natural look. In addition, the gradual ballooning with each squeeze makes it ideal for people new to inflatable toys.
- Size: We believe the size is ideal for most consumers. It goes from 4.5″ to 5.5″ -inches long with a few squeezes, providing a gradual yet satisfying filling experience for depth play fans. In addition, King Cock widens from 3.5″ to 6.5″ inches in circumference for the ultimate stretching sensations.
- Handling: King Cock was easier to use than other inflatable models we reviewed. You can pump as little or as much as you wish, giving you more control over the experience. In addition, the latex has a grippy surface, making it easy to handle with bare hands.
Features:
- Material: Latex
- Circumference: 3.5″ – 6.5″
- Insertable Length: 4.5″ – 5.5″
Pros:
- Realistic detailing makes the experience thrilling.
- Convenient easy-squeeze hand pump.
- Up to 6.5″ circumference and 5.5″ length.
- A quick-release valve enhances safety.
Cons:
- Latex is not great – silicone would’ve been better.
- Uneven air distribution.
6. Lynx Stimulating Glove: Fisting Glove
Why we love Lynx Stimulating Glove:
Lynx stimulative glove is the most recommended glove for fisting and stretching fans. The versatile Lynx is designed uniquely so every finger feels different. Each finger has a unique shape and texture to inspire a range of sensations, including:
- Raised nubs
- Penis shape
- Smooth and tapered
- Bulbed and subtle ribbing
- Bold ridges
The testers especially liked the zigzag texture. Whether you want to stimulate your clitoris or other erogenous zones, the ribbed palm offers an extra incentive for external stimulation.
In addition, I could wear the glove on either hand, giving me more power and control over the experience. The decision to make the hand-glove dynamic was a success because it means anyone can use it. In addition, one hand is always free, opening your world to more possibilities.
Lastly, cleaning the glove is straightforward, and so is long-term maintenance. And especially for a $27 fisting toy, it provides excellent value for money.
Minor issues we found during testing:
Unfortunately, the fisting glove is only available in one size. The glove won’t fit people with larger-sized hands.
So if you know that the Lynx isn’t going to be good for your hands, it’s time to consider looking for an alternative. You can start in our fisting glove review.
Why Lynx Stimulating Glove is the best fisting glove:
- Versatility: The testers praised the versatility. Besides every finger having a different texture and shape, the palm has a zigzag texture, opening your world to new possibilities. We also gave bonus points to the fact that the glove works on both hands.
- Price: Notably, the stimulating glove costs about $27, a comparatively affordable price for the dynamic fisting toy. And the fact that you can use the glove on either hand, the cost is worth the convenience.
Features:
- Material: Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPR)
- Size: 15 x 5 x 1.5″
Pros:
- A well-made fisting glove.
- Multiple textures and shapes.
- Stretchy TPR material.
- It can be worn on the right and left hand.
- Easy to clean.
Cons:
- It won’t fit people with more giant hands.
What Is A Fisting Dildo?
Let’s address the elephant in the room. What on earth are fisting dildos? Well, they have some significant differences from regular models. First and foremost, they’re bigger and specifically designed to stretch the hole of your anus or vagina. Many come in the shape of a hand and resemble a duck’s beak.
Using a fist dildo requires practice, so it’s not advisable for beginners. First-timers can try using smaller dildos or their fingers first. Once they get used to it, they can try larger fist sizes.
How To Use Your Fisting Dildo
Note: Fisting is an advanced sex act, and you need to take great care when doing it. Any action you take upon the information on this website is strictly at your own risk, and we will not be liable for any losses, injuries, or damages. Learn more.
Since we receive many questions about fisting, we have created this extensive fisting guide. Here you’ll learn what fisting is, why people like to include them in their sex life, the best positions, and a step-by-step guide on safely doing it.
How to Choose Your Fisting Dildo (Buyers Guide)
- The most important is the material. You should always buy a fist dildo with non-porous and non-toxic material, such as silicone or stainless steel. NEVER buy toxic and porous products, like jelly rubber. You can read more about safe materials in our comprehensive sex toy material guide.
- You should also think about the size. If you’re a beginner, go for a slimmer girth with a tapered gradual shape, like Magic Hand or Cock Locker above. A tapered shape will make insertion easier. Bitch Fist is a step up, while King Cock should be reserved for advanced fisting enthusiasts.
- The fisting dildo should be pleasing to the eye, hence think about the design. Some models have a realistic design and texture, while others don’t look like a hand.
- Finally, think about your budget. You can find large dildos for as cheap as $20, but I would not recommend those because of quality issues. Some brands also label their products as body-safe despite including harmful ingredients. I recommend going for a product somewhere in the $50 to $100 to be on the safe side and only buying them from a trusted site, like Lovehoney, where you get good customer support and warranty.
Note: If you’re going for anal fisting, the anal fisting toy needs to have a flared base (like a butt plug) so it doesn’t disappear inside you! Learn how to anal fist here.
You can read more about buying a hand-shaped dildo in our sex toy buyers guide. And if you are new to adult toys, I recommend our guide on using sex toys.
Rachel
LinkedIn | Website | Twitter
- 10 Female Dominant Positions To Make You Feel Like A Dominatrix - May 8, 2024
- 10 Intimate Sex Positions To Get The Spark Back! - May 7, 2024
- 7 Best Sex Positions For Overweight People - May 6, 2024
